Jump to content

Free schools - the more the merrier


silverfox

Recommended Posts

Great angst over a Muslim free school opening in Blackburn.


Good.


The more free schools that open, including creationist etc, the more liberal our society will become.


There is a mistaken view in this country that the more we are all taught the same the more tolerant we become as a society.


Deeeeer, as my kids would say, you only become tolerant with diversity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all pretty non sequitur if you ask me. Silver fox's theory is a strawman and I have no idea how schools teaching ignorance makes society more tolerant.


History teaches us that when religion has a sway on thinking, society's anything but tolerant.


But if people want to pay to teach their kids medieval superstition, far be it from me to stand in their way as long as not a penny of my tax is contributed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

MP - you know better than that. Free schools allow parents a greater say in their running but that does not mean that he schools will necessarily pander to fundamental religious views. Those that do will find themselves out on a limb with limited attendance fairly quickly.


Those that deliver good and inspiring teaching, strong values, appropriate discipline and listen to the views of parents will, on the other hand, become successful with parents queuing to place their children there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sadly 'strong values' is often a euphemism for religious bigotry, and I imagine there will be no shortage of people who wish to indoctrinate and distort their children by teaching them that prejudice and dogma are more important than an open mind and an inclusive society.


Silverfox's assertion that we become more tolerant by teaching intolerance is staggeringly disingenuous.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

DJKillaQueen Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Is there anything free about a school that has a

> religious doctrine at the core of it's identity?


But they don't necessarily have religion "at their core" - some may, others may not. A theme is emerging that appears to be an attempt by opponents of free schools to smear the concept with this ridiculous allegation.


Freedom is indivisible - if some choose to set up a religious based school or one committed to rigid Dawkinite atheism that's OK by me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

silverfox Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Great angst over a Muslim free school opening in

> Blackburn.

>

> Good.

>

> The more free schools that open, including

> creationist etc, the more liberal our society will

> become.

>

> There is a mistaken view in this country that the

> more we are all taught the same the more tolerant

> we become as a society.

>

> Deeeeer, as my kids would say, you only become

> tolerant with diversity.



Is this meant to be ironic?


I'll tolerate most things but I won't tolerate intolerance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll tolerate most things but I won't tolerate intolerance.


Nice soundbite - meaningless phrase.


If you disapprove of intolerance demonstrate that intolerance is wrong - by argument, humour, word and deed. Do not implement a ban.


As a pretty fervent atheist I found Frank Skinner's recent defence of religion and puncturing of some Dawkinite atheist views both amusing and thought provoking. His was a classic example of a tolerant person confronting a form of intolerance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't want to ban religion!! Or stop people expressing their religious views! When did I say that?


I'm suggesting - and I'm surprised if this is controversial - that maybe there is a pretty good arguable case against funding state schools to indoctrinate children with religion and, in my experience, actively discourage those children from challenging the tenets of that religion. That is not what I call education - and schools are there to educate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Like an addict, silverfox cannot disassociate the hormonal surges he receives in a cathedral when 'Jerusalem' raises the roof from intellectually rigorous arguments about religion.


Silverfox likes that surge. Like Nick O'Teen he wants other people to experience it too.


He can't explain it. He doesn't 'think' he's having a good time. He's genuinely having a good time. The thinking brain is in the bin.


When you challenge 'faith' schools it's like taking a bottle from an alkie. He doesn't care, he's f*cked in the head. He's angry, he quotes nonsense. He wants his bottle back.


When you ask him to stop drinking, he thinks it's your failure because you're not drunk too ;-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sure we would all agree it would be wrong for the state to make us all dress the same way, in Mao Zedong style suits.


Nor would it be appropriate for the state to try to make us all look the same, with the same hairstyles, only one colour of lipstick, eye-shadow etc


While such efforts in social engineering may go some way towards minimising discrimination it would be at the expense of individualism and diversity. This is why the military has these dress and haircut codes.


Why then do some people insist we are all taught the same,in uniform schools all following the same curriculum? Why are some people so frightened by different ideas that conflict with their own?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, as it happens silverfox, that's exactly what religion does.


Religion kills dissent and diversity, it kills original thinking and the spirit of enquiry. It takes people who have 'different ideas that conflict with their own' and burns them at the stake.


It takes daughters who want to meet their boyfriend, slits their throats and buries them in the yard.


It sets arbitrary rules based on iron age social issues and applies them to the 21st century. It refuses to accept that they may be flawed.


Then it has the nerve to call people who welcome liberalism and calls them 'discriminatory'...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • It doesn't work as a commercial venture.  Bit churlish to say I told you so.  I told you so.  I'll send less greetings cards.  What pees me off is international postage where you can no longer send light letters at 10 grammes, normal ones up to 20g, now all at the much more expensive 100 g  Didn't we vote to take back control and price everything according to irrational units like ounces? That's some obscure humour btw   
    • Available from Monday April 8th 2024, 2on2Walkies take pride in doggie care and only walk 2 furry friends at a time. I make sure that they get plenty of doggie interaction and socialisation in the park as well as making friends. Back home happy and tired I always check that the water bowl has fresh water and always make sure the doggie is left comfortable before I leave. I'm fully insured and have a couple of slots available for local walks to either Peckham Rye Park or Dulwich Park.  Thank you!  
    • Why would they only send them recorded delivery? I used the signed for option yesterday.
    • > however I know I will have to prove it and provide a receipt,  both I can't provide. So what leads you to say that the dustmen have done damage to it? 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...