Jump to content

Recommended Posts

This hadn't occurred to me before (having given our 2 and 5 year olds those little Actimel yoghurt bottles for a while now) but my OH has just turned around and said that probiotics are bad for children.


Does anyone know?

Am clueless on this one - and will miss those handy little bottles :)

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/25227-probiotics-and-kids/
Share on other sites

Ok, so a very quick google scholar search appears to show that the consensus is that probiotics may not prevent infectious gastrointeritis (jury is still out on prophylaxis essentially), but they do show that they may reduce the duration of infectious diarrhea in infants and children.


A lot of prepackaged yogurts and probitic drinks have a high sugar content. If the rest of the child's diet is fine, I can't personally see how an actimel or yakult pot is a "bad" thing.

My son, between 10months and 18months went through a phase of having one tummy bug after another. I'm sure part of it was just his age (starting to crawl = exposure to more germs + putting everything in his mouth) and the season (this would've been Sept through to the following spring / summer), but where his nannyshare partner would suffer for the normal 48 hours, my son would have horrendous nappies for 2 - 3 weeks each time. It was pretty grim for everyone. I started using a daily probiotic supplement at 18 months (the Udo's choice infant powder), and haven't looked back. He's now coming up to 3, and we've had maybe one or two very mild tummy upsets, which have lasted 24 hours or less...


Obv I can't prove the cause and effect, but the improvement was so immediate and so marked, that I can't help but think the probiotics were at least part of the reason. Would be interested to find out if there is any evidence against the use of probiotics for kids though.

Probiotics were a lifesaver for us with our colicky baby - we used one called Biogaia from about 12 weeks til about 6 months, and it was a miracle. I has antibiotics in labour which we think killed her good bacteria (completely non-medical opinion!!).

We did stop but mainly cos of the cost(!) and being out of the colicky phase, plus my now 14 month has the constitution on an ox (famous last words - in 5 minutes nursery will call saying she has been sick). I would not hesitate to reintroduce if she had any more tummy issues.

The probiotic we used was infant specific though, and just 10 drops on a spoon (or in a bottle, if you were lucky enought to have a bottle willing child unlike me!). I also researched at the time, especially as she was so little, and could only find positive things on probiotics for kids, but thinking moves on so thats not to say theres no negative evidence out there - maybe I just didnt dig too deep?

Surely that's just covering their arses for stupid liability cases, b/c the product research was not conducted on under-3s? It also doesn't conclusively mean that the product is "bad" for under-3s. And it certainly does not equate to ALL probiotics being "bad" for children. There is conclusive, peer-reviewed evidence (look it up for your selves, it's easy to find) that certain probiotics can shorten infant diarrhoea and replace gut flora lost to antibitic treatment.

from - probioticsinpractice.ie

Actimel is not specially formulated to meet the nutritional requirements of infants or young children, so it is not recommended for those under 3 years old.


also- Actimel.co.uk

Actimel is suitable for everyone from age 3 upwards when consumed as part of a healthy balanced diet and lifestyle. It is not formulated to meet the specific nutritional requirements of an infant or young child. If you have any concerns about consuming Actimel we recommend that you talk to your GP.


See more on actimel/probiotics in general on Wikipedia.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Well for comparison, Actimel's two main ingredients are the same as ice cream, ie dairy+sugar. For arguments sake, I'm fairly certain ice creams aren't specially formulated to meet the nutritional requirements of infants or young children, but we could debate till the proverbial cows come home whether ice cream is "bad" for children under 3 years old. Interesting, I don't know of any research to suggest that ice cream shortens diarrhoea or has other health benefits, though most of us have given ice cream to our young children!


There are probably other probiotic formulations that do not contain the sugar that Actimel does (incidentally, check out how much sugar is in yogurts specifically aimed at children!), which would make them more suitable for infants.

I don't think all probiotics are bad for children under 3, but they should be specially formulated, they are still developing. I remember when I was breastfeeding and drank actimel, my baby would get really upset with colic, there were other things that caused him colic, but the probiotic was the worse.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • What was he doing on the stage at Glastonbury? Or on the stage at the other concert in Finsbury Park? Grinning like a Cheshire cat whilst pissed and stoned 20 somethings on the promise of free internet sung-- Oh Jeremy Corbyn---  What were his policies for Northern mining towns with no jobs or infrastructure? Free Internet and university places for youngsters. What were his other manifesto pledges? Why all the ambiguity over Brexit?  I didn't like Thatcher, Blair or May or Tony but I respected them as politicians because they stood by what they believed in. I respect all politicians across the board that stick to their principles. Corbyn didn't and its why he got  annihilated at the polls. A socialist, anti imperialist and anti capitalist that said he voted for an imperialist and pro capitalist cabal. He refused to say how he'd vote over and over again until the last knockings. He did so to appease the Islington elite and middle class students he was courting. The same people that were screaming that Brexit was racist. At the same time the EU were holding black and Asian immigrants in refugee camps overseas but not a word on that! Corbyn created and courted a student union protest movement that screamed at and shouted down anyone not on the left . They claimed Starmer and the centre right of labour were tories. He didn't get elected  because he, his movement and policies were unelectable, twice. He turned out not to have the convictions of his politics and died on his own sword.    Reform won't win an election. All the idiots that voted for them to keep out Labour actually enabled Labour. They'll be back voting tory next time.    Farage wouldn't be able to make his millions if he was in power. He's a very devious shyster but I very much doubt he'd actually want the responsibility that governance requires.
    • The purge of hard left members that were part of Corbyn's, Mcdonnel's and Lansmans momentum that purged the party of right wing and centrist members. That's politics. It's what Blair did to win, its what Starmer had to do to win. This country doesn't vote in extreme left or right governments. That's partly why Corbyn lost  We're pretty much a centrist bunch.  It doesn't make it false either. It's an opinion based on the voting patterns, demography and statistics. Can you explain then why former mining constituencies that despise the tories voted for them or abstained rather than vote for Corbyns Labour?  What is the truth then? But he never got elected!!! Why? He should have been binned off there and then. Why he was allowed to hang about is an outrage. I hold him party responsible for the shit show that we've had to endure since. 
    • Depends on what the Barista says doesnt it? There was no physical confrontation with the driver, OP thinks she is being targetted when she isnt. These guys work min wage under strict schedules so give them a break unless they damage your stuff
    • CPR Dave, attendance records are available on Southwark's website. Maggie Browning has attended 100% of meetings. Jon Hartley has attended 65%.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...