Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I have been diagnosed with anxiety in the past and have had both medication and CBT on the NHS. Both 'worked' to an extent in different ways. I've read paco's post and the process it describes sounds similar to CBT.


Like a previous poster, I am uncomfortable with the 'peddling of (expensive) wares' on a thread that's a cry for help and advice. I agree that there are actions that you can take to begin to tackle your problems, but suggest that the first port of call should be your GP / other free NHS services (health visitors etc) who can provide access to FREE therapy etc.


Extra financial pressures are the last thing you need when you're suffering from anxiety, depression, etc.


When I was post-partum / in the midst of anxiety and panic attacks pre-baby, I was desperate and suggestible. The vulnerable and suggestible are a good market to sell expensive goods / services to. So I do find it inappropriate that this is taking place on this thread (even if it is well-intentioned).

There is another very good reason for making a sympathtic GP your first place to seek profession help, if professional help is what you want. That reason is that your GP should order blood tests which could help rule out other health issues such as thyroid, low iron, or low Vit D, etc. While not being the cause of anxiety/depression outright, these conditions can exacerbate underlying problems. If after that you want to explore other avenues of treatment, by all means there are many to choose from.


SarahG, your post seems genuine enough, but keep in mind that there have been cases of people posting disingenuous comments on local forums. So suffice it to say that making blanket statements about the curative powers of any treatment (NHS or private) aimed at vulnerable individuals, is always going to met with some skepticism. xx

Agree with Saffron.


Do not want to throw doubt on the good intentions of anyone on this thread, but someone very close to me suffers from (among other things) severe, chronic anxiety. I accompanied this person to a consultation with a professor of psychology at a London teaching hospital. His advice was very clear that there is very good evidence to support the effectiveness of drug therapy and/or CBT for most (obviously, not all) sufferers of anxiety AND that the evidence is that any other type of therapy (which is not, broadly, aimed at giving you SKILLS, or helping you work out effective coping strategies) is actually counterproductive. He was particularly clear that psychotherapies, for example aimed at making connections between childhood experiences and current anxiety, have been shown to make some forms of anxiety worse.


This is my exact (vicarious) experience with my loved one, who IMO has become hooked on a therapist who gives him what he wants, which is lots of reinforcement that his anxious/negative world view is justified (and supports his ignoring medical advice about treatment), when this obviously isn't helping his symptoms.


I don't want to scare or aggravate anyone's anxiety by saying this. In a sense, any treatment which you find helpful is helpful to you. But I do question the legitimacy of a lot of private "therapy" when nowadays evidenced based options are widely available on the NHS.

I haven't read through all the responses, so apologies if someone has mentioned this before, but several months after my second was born I started feeling increasingly irrational and anxious about everything (much more than just the postpartum emotional roller coaster, and eventually I discovered that my thyroid was barely functioning. I'm sure that not all people who have underactive thyroid experience anxiety and vice versa, but it is a good thing to have checked just in case (and also all those B vitamins). I hope you can get some help, in any form. You are certainly not alone.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • The suspense is killing me. And I don't even like Tesco 🤣 and I can't remember the last time I used an ATM 🤣
    • If you like very good quality South Asian food then Babur in Brockley is offering a well priced, for what it is, Christmas day menu with sensitively priced reductions for a more limited children's menu. They also have a compelling wine list and their specialist cocktails are phenomenal. Not traditional Christmas fare, but then that might be an additional recommendation. 
    • The Dulwich Wood House is advertising a four course meals for £105 per person
    • Dear families,   My name is Eleanor. I’ve worked in NHS Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services for the past eight years, and I’m about to begin an Infant Observation course in preparation for psychotherapy training. I’m looking for a baby to observe as part of this training.   The observation involves me visiting a baby and their parent for one hour a week over two years, with the aim of deepening my understanding of early emotional and developmental processes. Taking part is a generous contribution to the training of future child psychotherapists — ultimately supporting the mental health of children and families.   Both of my own children were observed as babies, which I found to be a really positive experience. Having an observer gently witness my babies’ development helped me notice their weekly changes in a new way, and I came to appreciate the calm, consistent presence of a trained observer. I was sad when the observations ended!   If you — or someone you know — is expecting a baby due before the end of February*, I would love to hear from you. You can contact me at +44 7977 910018 or [email protected].   Best wishes, Eleanor
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...