Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Well without the SNP stringvest, the hunting ammendment might have had a chance of getting through. So the SNP have been very useful here for those opposed to the hunting bill ammendment.


I don't see how four English parliaments would work Loz, unless we adopt a US style two tier government. And given that the south east disproportionately generates tax revenue, can't see how that would help the rest of the country if those powers are devolved, like they have been in Scotland. It all just becomes too complicated, and I believe would further impoverish the North.


It's like a panic has set in because the SNP won a few seats. So now we have to change the rules! In five years the balance could change again. That's politics. All those people voting in Scotland for the SNP were voting for a presence in Westminster, a presence the SNP have every right to use in any way they want to. If Cameron or any party want a working majority, then they have to earn it through the ballot box, and not by changing the rules of parliamentary voting to suit themselves. Remeber the slogan from the independance vote? Better together was the cry from Labour and Tories alike. What they meant was better together as long as you don't kill our parliamentary bills. Cameron better get used to it.

Blah Blah Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Well without the SNP stringvest, the hunting ammendment might have had a chance of getting through.


Possible, but it was unlikely as it was a free vote. I'd have been surprised to see it pass.


> I don't see how four English parliaments would work Loz, unless we adopt a US style two tier

> government.


Well, yes, with devolution that is exactly the logical conclusions. At the moment we have two tiers in Scotland and Wales, and (sort of) one everywhere else. It's just a constitutional nightmare. And its not just the US that make two tiers work - Australia, Canada, Germany and many others do it too.


> And given that the south east disproportionately generates tax revenue, can't see how that would help the

> rest of the country if those powers are devolved, like they have been in Scotland. It all just becomes too complicated, and

> I believe would further impoverish the North.


That's quite easy to get around - you keep certain tax-raising powers with the national government who can distribute them as necessary. Australia manage this quite easily with rather wildly performing state economies. In fact, it makes the distribution far more visible and so, in theory, more equitable.


> It's like a panic has set in because the SNP won a few seats. So now we have to change the rules!


Actually, the West Lothian Question has been rumbling along for nearly 40 years. EVEL was actually an issue discussed before the election as you can see from that article I linked to. This is not in any way new.

Interesting Loz. You have pursuaded me it could work.


I just get suspicious when electoral, boundary, etc reform takes place as the party in power on the day invariably skews things to benefit themselves if they can. If change were a genuine effort to realise democracy, or to advance the economy etc, then I think I'd pay more attention to the detail. I take your point about the background debate having rumbled on for 40 years though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • 🎉 Parents, Summer is ALMOST HERE!  Don’t let your child miss out on an unforgettable summer of creativity and fun with Freedom Academy Performing Arts Summer Camps! Spaces are filling up FAST – secure your spot today! We’ve got something magical for every age: 🌟 Ages 5-16: The Magic of Aladdin! Join us for a full week of immersive rehearsals culminating in a spectacular, full-scale production of Aladdin! Learn to sing, dance, and act on stage – it’s an experience they’ll never forget! 🎶 Ages 3-6: Morning Fun with Your Faves! Little ones will adore our fun-packed mornings filled with games, singing, and dancing alongside Peppa Pig, Bluey, Duggee, Paw Patrol, Gabby & more! Each morning ends with a delightful mini-performance. Give your child the gift of performance, confidence, and fantastic memories! • Dance, sing, and act all week long. • Build confidence, make new friends. • At Kingsdale School, Dulwich. • Limited spaces remaining! Book your    star's spot today! • www.freedomacademy.co.uk/dulwich-camps ✨🎭🎤
    • Direct link (sorry duplicated!):  Today, more than 30 states from around the world will gather in Bogotá, Colombia, for the “Emergency Conference” to halt the Gaza genocide: the most ambitious multilateral response since Israel began its campaign of devastation two years ago. Bringing together a broad coalition of governments — from Algeria to Brazil, China to Spain, Indonesia to Qatar — the conference aims, in the words of Colombian President Gustavo Petro, “to move from condemnation to collective action.” At 10:30 Bogotá, 11:30 New York, 16:30 London and 17:30 Paris, we invite you to join this historic gathering's opening ceremony live from the Colombian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. You will hear testimony from Dr. Thaer Ahmed, who will recount his experience of working in Rafah and Khan Younis amidst Israel’s genocide. Rosa Yolanda Villavicencio, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Colombia, will detail her government’s concrete commitments to uphold international law. After she was sanctioned by the Trump administration, UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese will deliver a powerful message about the failure of the international system to protect the Palestinian people — and urge immediate and coordinated action by principled states. “Here in Bogotá, a growing number of states have the opportunity to break the silence and revert to a path of legality by finally saying: enough. Enough impunity. Enough empty rhetoric. Enough exceptionalism. Enough complicity,” Albanese will say. Today, the call from Bogotá will echo around the world. Join us. In solidarity,  The Progressive International Secretariat  
    • pm if you have any for sale
    • Yes, that was what I was thinking of, thanks!
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...