In all experience, everywhere, overlordship breeds discontent and rebellion, not acquiescence and malaise. It wasn't the English who defeated the Irish, it was the church. If you want someone to blame, look a little closer to home. My mother in law asked of me the other day, without so much as a hint of irony or sadness, 'so piers' she said 'do you think now times are bad, people will return to the church'. The sense of glee was irrepressible. The 19th century saw the church, who had always seen the Irish flavour of Catholicism as difficult, as an opportunity to tie in a sense of identity and nationalism with a strict version of worship reserved for Ireland. It was very successful and managed to galvanise, in many ways, a united national self image and destiny, something tellingly in ireland's quest for self-determination, no one had hitherto achieved. But I would say from personal experience, that that particular breed of Catholicism was too much and has coloured everything else in th country and better explains the traits you describe. The good news is the grip lessens with each generation, and fingers crossed, my mother in law's vision for Ireland won't be realised. And what's with that weird tolling bell death hour on the telly??!?! Freaks me out every time.