By happy coincidence, we went there last night to check it out. I never went to the old Magdala and so only have Mrs *Bob*s description to go on: "dated, in a bad way" as opposed to being "old fashioned/traditional in a good way". As for the new Magnolia, we both liked it, maybe a lot more than we thought we would. Putting aside the "not those again" lightshades over the bar and run of wallpaper around the bar, we actually thought it was firmly out of Bishop territory and all the better for it. It feels modern without being wanky and plain without being boring. There's an obvious leaning towards eating, but that 'side' of the place is the best bit. Really liked the canteeny look and feel of it, and it's great to have somewhere where there are actually tables which can sit larger groups to eat comfortably - and boasts plenty of space between the tables too, which is a real luxury. The 'bar' side suffers somewhat from this bias, feeling more like a waiting area to get into the canteen part, but then I suppose that's kind-of what it is. Will it 'work' being slightly off the beaten track? If the food's good enough (we didn't eat) then I think it deserves to. Hope so anyway.