Interesting tale Snorky - I agree the petition sounds a bit daft but the thing is that if the freeholder of the Oglander has indeed 'relaunched' and 'revamped' it as you say, then he simply hasn't managed to effectively convey that to potential customers. What's the point in spending loads of cash on a refurb if the blinds are permanently closed (during the day, why?) and you can't see what kind of "experience" awaits inside? You don't exactly have to be Philip Green to work that one out. I live nearby, I love beer and crisps and so should be a regular there but I simply don't fancy the place. I went in once and the look on many of the faces of the "same crowd" was pretty similar to the one the owner apparently adopted on meeting the "middle class female busybodies" you mentioned - ie "Who the f... are you?". Pool balls pretty much stopped mid shot as eyes looked round. Hmmm what a pleasant half hour that was, must recommend the place to friends. Sorry but the argument that it's too far off the beaten track doesn't hold. The Bellenden area is now chock full of people wanting a nice pint in a good boozer - The Gowlett isn't exactly positioned in a prime position but has managed to become an award winning, friendly (albeit smokey) pub, with simple, good food. The whole La Plancha/Tapas idea at the Oglander was all very well - but for a start the sign is over the wrong bit of the building! What is it? A "local boozer"? Tapas Bar? Both? Neither? Haven't a clue and I walk past it every day. The BRG are well meaning but I agree with others here that they seem to want to complain about anything going - I suspect the main force for the petition came from residents on Maxted and nearby roads who don't fancy the idea of flats.... The Oglander is a wasted opportunity, the building is great but the money spent on it hasn't been done so effectively. It is a shame to hear about a local business apparently failing - but ultimately people don't got there for a reason. The idea that they should be doing so out of some kind sympathy is bizarre.