Keef Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Scholes is a good player, who like Gazza before > him, couldn't tackle, which is a weakness of his > game, but I don't think you can say he's > maliciously dirty. Oh course the alternative view is that if you know you can't tackle as long as you have a hole in your bottom, which is the case with Scholes, then you shouldn't try to tackle cos the chances are you will fail, catch someone, and either get carded or sent off, so the fact you already know this smacks of intent everytime he makes a daft attempt at a tackle. Ask Reyes if he thinks Scholes is a nice clean player.