Jump to content

Recommended Posts

My 86 year old Mum has suffered from a hoarse voice/ dystonia for years - the family is fairly sure it's stress related. It's recently got a lot worse since she has been in a care home. She's also having to use a steroid inhaler ('clenil') for asthma which seems to exacerbate the problem. I noticed that side effects for it can be hoarse voice and anxiety (!!) Her GP is dismissive when both my Mum and I have tried to discuss the problem with him (she lives in a rural area without many facilities, and the GP is about to retire and seems less engaged with his patients these days but she refuses to change GPs). She has tried lozenges, lemon and honey and inhaling and I'm trying to encourage her to see an alternative therapist.

If anyone has experience of this problem, it would be good to have some advice, thanks.

My mate, his wife and two kids all have dystonia. He now receives regular botox injections as part of his treatment.


Lifted this bit from the web.


"There are several options for treating dystonia. The doctor will determine the course of treatment based on the type of dystonia and its severity. A recently introduced treatment is botulinum toxin, also called Botox or Xeomin. The toxin is injected into the affected muscle".

You need to establish how much is truly the dystonia and how much hoarseness could be from the meds. I would also consider whether the asthma has been properly diagnosed, and what other steroid formulations are available. This is something that usually requires the advice of specialist consultants. She could keep her GP, but she needs to push for a referral to a specialist(s). This would typically be an ENT. Correct evaluation is critical because the causes of hoarseness with dystonia vs steroids may be different. They may even be essentially opposed. So, treating a dystonia could worsen the steroid-induced muscle myopathy.


In the meantime, here are a few things to consider. Could she drop down on the dose of meds? If she is using an aerosol type inhaler, has she been given a spacer? For aerosol or dry powder inhalers, has she received correct support on inhaler usage to minimise exposure to the mouth and throat? Is she adequately rinsing and gargling after inhaler use?


Hoarseness is a known SE of certain asthma inhalers. It should not be difficult for any GP to recognise this and take adequate steps towards minimising the problem. If dystonia is complicating the diagnoses, then that's all the more reason to seek specialist advice. xx

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Thank you, I will be vigilant
    • @Sue said: nobody is blaming the child, they are blaming the person who should have been watching him g) do you really think it was acceptable for that person to find the situation funny? This is the point. Adults are meant to teach their children by example. It sounds as though the adult guardian/ father in this case did not react appropriately. Had a truly sincere apology been given,  I suspect the OP would not have posted on here. It is possible the OP snapped in the heat of the moment, but they were possibly startled because they were hit from behind? If we are startled it can be instinctive to initially react with anger. I also agree that it would be highly irresponsible to let any very young child ride or walk or do anything on a busy public street without supervision- most of all to protect the child. If in this case the child was out of the adult's line of sight that is perhaps another indication that the father needs a refresh in appropriate behaviour around a child, as well as his manners.
    • Malumbu,  if none of us were there, does that mean that nobody should post anything on here unless they have witnesses from the EDF? Why would someone post something like this if it  wasn't true? This is not about whether children should or should not be cycling on the pavement. There are specific issues. a) the child was out of sight of the person supposed to be caring for him b) he appears to have been  either not looking where he was going or was out of control of the bike c) if he did see that he was about to hit someone  he apparently did not give them any kind of warning  d)  a person was unexpectedly hit from behind whilst just walking along, which in my view makes him a victim e) does the title of the thread really matter as the issue was described in the first post?  f) nobody is blaming the child, they are blaming the person who should have been watching him g) do you really think it was acceptable for that person to find the situation funny? The OP was not complaining about the 4 year old. They were complaining about an adult's lack of supervision of a 4 year old who was not capable of riding a bike and who hit someone from behind with no warning. Also, apart from reading the OP more carefully, perhaps also choose your words more carefully. Jobless? Lunatic? Charming.
    • I have to say, I too am upset about the passing of DulwichFox. He was a real local character, who unlike me, managed to stick with ED despite all of the nauseous yuppification of the last three decades. R.I.P to foxy    Louisa. 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...