Jump to content

Sign my Avaaz petition if you believe fare evasion should not be a criminal offence


Recommended Posts

http://www.avaaz.org/en/petition/Par...tters/?nWIoPbb


I see so many threads on prosections for fare evasion in all sorts of forums. I have started this petition because I think giving someone a criminal record, and often young people, for dodging a small amount of money for a fare, is just not right.

As I explain in the petition I do not condone fare evasion and support all the methods currently used to deter it. However I just think it's fairer for rail companies to recover their loss with fines or through civil courts, rather than give someone a criminal record that affects their employability and ability to live and travel abroad.

Like other travel offences (parking fines/ speeding fines) the offence itself shouldn't warrant harsh penalties


Such is the ubiquity of offences tho I can see why the crime itself is being treated ever more harshly. If fewer people did it, and it was an occasional offence then maybe


As it is everyone thinks they are a special case

Yeah totally agree it is a problem but I would suggest that train companies employ more staff to sell tickets, and if people get aggressive or rude to train staff get British Transport Police involved and charge them with assault. However from all the internet research I've done I've read so many stories of regular commuters getting prosecuted for incorrect tickets or inattentiveness when swiping Oyster cards etc. I don't see how this is different to people being too busy and forgetting to pay their gas bills etc., for which the provider have no ability to initiate a criminal prosecution.

Torn on this. On one hand, it is essentially theft when done on purpose. But there are many incidents where 'evasion' is accidental or due to faulty equipment or lack of facilities.


But aren't you given the opportunity to pay the fine and it goes no further? Doesn't it only go to court if you don't pay the fine?


But, it doesn't matter anyway as your petition seems to have been withdrawn.

Loz Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Torn on this. On one hand, it is essentially

> theft when done on purpose. But there are many

> incidents where 'evasion' is accidental or due to

> faulty equipment or lack of facilities.

>

> But aren't you given the opportunity to pay the

> fine and it goes no further? Doesn't it only go

> to court if you don't pay the fine?

>

> But, it doesn't matter anyway as your petition

> seems to have been withdrawn.


Regarding this people are often prosecuted if they object to the fine and ask the inspector to just sell them a ticket. Magistrates Court deal with 90% of crimes, including quite serious ones like burglary and robbery, so it just isn't helpful to society if they have to deal with dozens of train fare prosecutions each week.

Like loz I'm torn at some level as well


I have been caught out by leaving travel card at home and feel the punishment was disproportionate


But mostly I see people trying it on. I don't think more ticket inspectors are the solution


People need to cop on and behave


When the bendy buses were knocking about, I would tap in and 80% of the time people I was with (people I knew and trusted) would ask me why I did it. Only a few stops


Yeah I know. I'm a square.

It's fair enough being a square. I have posted this on a few forums and the overwhelming response presume I'm trying to get all fare dodgers off the hook. No, I'm just saying the punishment or the debt recovery shouldn't give the rail companies preferential treatment to other utility companies who also operate public infrastructure.

The terms of engagement are different to other utility companies tho surely?


You don't give a means of payment , you don't get leccie or water


But you can easily try and get a free ride on buses and trains. And so many people do, the honest person who occasionally messes up is collateral damage.


But the blame is firmly on the law breakers and not the transport companies


It would be different if they were so authoritarian with very few attempts at a free ride. But that isn't the case

Water and electricity are considered basic human necessities and utilities companies are not permitted by law to cut people off from them easily, ie for a few missed payments. This is particularly the case for water.

So therefore people can game that system if they frequently change their address, or if say they are foreign students who will leave after a year so bailiffs would never be able to track them down. This hasn't led to use of criminal law to recover debts in those areas.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Hi  I really thought I'd seen a more recent post on the forum about home education meet ups. I can't find it though. Hope some of these might provide leads. https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/137603-home-schooling-advice-anyone-wants-to-do-it-together/#comment-1092093 Very old post but group seems still to exist: https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/92044-home-education-local-group/#comment-954837 You could try contacting this forum member: https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/325368-classroom-support-for-home-education-community/#comment-1621064 Two of these left for right now: https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/events/event/1025-🌟-teens-11-try-painting-sculpture-street-art-at-holiday-workshops/
    • Thanks for your reply. I’ve subscribed to Ancestry a few times in the past but felt I wasn’t using it enough to warrant keeping up the subscription.    
    • Hi, I saw your post and just wanted to say that the incident you’re referring to did happen in the late 1980s at Dawson’s Heights. The person involved was named Carl Salawa, and he had just turned 18 years old at the time. Like you, I haven’t been able to find any news articles or official reports about it, If anyone remembers anything more about that time or incident, I’d really appreciate hearing about it. Thanks for sharing what you were told—it means a lot to know others remember.
    • Was anyone else disturbed last night/early hours this morning by the party going on in someone’s garden on Crystal Palace road. Can’t see what house exactly but it’s around number 43 - 41… it was happening quite frequently last year. Seems it’s starting again! Very inconsiderate.  
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...