BMX versus track bikes

[KikiMac]

Hi, our nearly five year old loves both BMX and track (and pavement!) cycling at the moment. He's just growing out of his Frog bike and we're trying to decide what kind of bike to go for next that will work for both settings. Any advice from knowledgable family roomers?

Thanks!

[Gubodge]

Both track cycling and BMX require such different styles of bikes I'm doubtful you'll find anything that really suits both. I'd recommend getting a good all-rounder like the Isla Benin and borrow/hire proper track-bikes or BMX bikes when you need to. If you do want to get a specialised bike I say aim for a BMX, which will be much more practical elsewhere than a track-cycle.

Track-cycles are fixed gear with no brakes and are not suitable for riding anywhere but on a velodrome. And I wouldn't be happy with a five year old riding on drop handlebars. He'd be less visible and have much less visibility. My 8 year old is longing for drops but I think it'll too dangerous for her on the roads until she's a good bit taller.