Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I'm sure I'm not the only fan of Ben Goldacre on the forum, what with the high incidence of Guardian reading tendencies about these parts (and, I hope, some of the raw common sense that he alludes to the need for), and so I thought I'd share the good word, so to speak.



This is the ?missing chapter? about vitamin pill salesman Matthias Rath. Sadly I was unable to write about him at the time that book was initially published, as he was suing my ass in the High Court. The chapter is now available in the new paperback edition, and I?ve posted it here for free so that nobody loses out.


Although the publishers make a slightly melodramatic fuss about this in the promo material, it is a very serious story about the dangers of pseudoscience, as I hope you?ll see, and it was also a pretty unpleasant episode, not just for me, but also for the many other people he?s tried to sue, including Medecins Sans Frontieres and more. If you?re ever looking for a warning sign that you?re on the wrong side of an argument, suing Medecins Sans Frontieres is probably a pretty good clue.


Anyway, here it is, please steal it, print it, repost it, whatever, it?s free under a Creative Commons license, details at the end.



So here it is.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/6057-bad-science-the-missing-chapter/
Share on other sites

Actually, I'm being flippant.


I'm sure that some guys might interpret some of my postings as being 'angry', but they're not, of course. Generally they're intellectual brigandry. I'm exploring ideas ;-)


This issue (Matthias Rath and vitamins) makes me really angry. I become verbally incompetent.


This kind of dishonorable behaviour (touting snake oil) is genocidal, and it takes a particular kind of psychopath to pull it off. Waterboarding is not good enough.


It is not reasonable to lay the blame for embracing thse ideas at the door of Africa. If you haven't been there it would be difficult to explain the desperation and lack of education that these guys face in making everyday decisions.


It was characterised to me once as 'these guys will follow a guy running down the street shaking a chicken', and whilst essentially a belittling generalisation, it says a lot about Rath. He was a guy running down the street shaking a chicken. Nevertheless, he had the knowledge and insight to recognise the error in his ways, and dismissed it when he chased his ego.


And then he killed millions. Many more than Reinhard Heydrich. It's right under our noses.


I share the frustration with mega-pharma that feeds his followers, but lemon juice is not the solution.

Huguenot Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Actually, I'm being flippant.

>

> I'm sure that some guys might interpret some of my

> postings as being 'angry', but they're not, of

> course. Generally they're intellectual brigandry.

> I'm exploring ideas ;-)

>

> This issue (Matthias Rath and vitamins) makes me

> really angry. I become verbally incompetent.

>

> This kind of dishonorable behaviour (touting snake

> oil) is genocidal, and it takes a particular kind

> of psychopath to pull it off. Waterboarding is not

> good enough.

>

> It is not reasonable to lay the blame for

> embracing thse ideas at the door of Africa. If you

> haven't been there it would be difficult to

> explain the desperation and lack of education that

> these guys face in making everyday decisions.

>


Yes, but... Mbeki was educated at the University of Sussex.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • I did read the comments above It's not moaning, it's stating facts. Tell you what,  you can come and clear up the near daily fox crap and see how you like dealing with it, no didn't think that would appeal to you.  Do they control rodents?  Foxes are vermin.  It's an emotive topic for some, I realise that, however the facts are foxes are a pest.
    • Well why don't you read the posts on this thread suggesting humane ways of deterring them from your garden, and do something constructive about it, instead of moaning? As for culling - how do you think that should be done, exactly?  And yes, as said above, they control rodents. Would you rather be overrun by rats?
    • It's hardly likely someone was going to kill him just because they knew about him 🙄
    • I understand that dealing with mess in your garden is frustrating, but calling for culling & branding those who care as "idiotic" isn't just unhelpful, it's dangerously reductive. Urban foxes exist because we've steadily removed their natural habitat. They adapt, survive & yes sometimes that means scavenging in places we'd rather they didn't. But labeling them a "pest" overlooks the bigger picture, which is that they are part of our urban ecosystem & play a vital role in controlling rodent population. As someone above so accurately pointed out, dogs leave more waste on footpaths. A fox is a canine, just like dogs. So are you calling for the culling of pets too?
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...