Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I generally tend to vote to ensure a strong opposition as I think that is what democracy is all about, having a voice to challenge those in power and keep them in check. Unless of course there is a specific issue which I feel one candidate can handle better than another. This is why I often vote differently for local elections than I do for general.


The idea that Labour is an opposition to Conservative and vice versa is a lie that, from my fresh naive perspective, has kept Britain in an ideological dictatorship for the better part of 30 years.


The only real ?oppositions? available in the European election were either far-left or far-right. Neither fit my personal ideology but for the reasons stated above I voted Green because the far-right option was too distasteful.

We'll they'll have to be spending cuts or raised taxes...and I think I know which one the electorate will actually go for. We, all of us, can't go on spending all this money on the Public Sector without having to pay for it properly and Flash Gordon didn't put any money away for a rainy day when the sun was out....cries of 'Tory Cuts' is just base, emotive nonsense of a pretty desperate goverment, we are going to have to cut or be taxed more. Effectively it's like we've had a cleaner, nanny, cook and gardener on about a ?35K income...not workable. We either need more income or one of them's going to have to go....and the completeley politically motivated envy taxing of ?150K+ earners won't pay for it all (if any, if many commentators are to be believed). So, more tax for you and I to be poured into an unqenchable public sector or cuts.......or we go bust. Labour doesn't appear willing to accept that this is the truth, certainly in public, and are doing their best to stop the tories doing anything about it too.
To add and show a bit of balance (maybe ;-), the Tory press will also be targeting the Public Sector pretty soon, (possibly with some justification)in terms of solid copperbacked pensions, salaries, job security, hours, holiday AND expenses . And Private Sector employees - who have born the brunt of the recession in terms of employment, seeing their private pension pots, if they have one, decimated (final salary pensions almost don't exist in the private sector) and with absolutely no chance of a guranteed job for life, in fact mainly massive job security - outnumber public sector wotrkers four to one. Imagine the Daily Mail - "Another 2p on my tax so tube drivers get a final salary pension, a ?35K+ index linked salary job for life, 8 weeks holiday and a final salary pension..." oh hang on a minute, they might have a point

James Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Jeremy which policies are you referring to re. the

> Greens? I switched from Labour to Green this time

> (like many others it would seem)



Citizen's Income is the main policy I disagree with. It is a non-means tested substitute for the dole, and given to everyone. It's Catch-22... if it's not enough to live on, then it's an inadequate solution. But if it is enough to live on, why bother working? They claim that people would still work because they enjoy it... I find this totally laughable.


Also, abolishing tax relief on private pension plans is a bad idea.


They support abolishment of all animal testing, including pharmaceuticals. They cling on to the crude assumption that all genetic manipulation is bad.


They have incredibly ambitious targets for emission reductions, but totally rule out nuclear energy. I don't think this has been thought through properly.


They have some progressive ideas, but so much of it seems completely naive to me.

The Citizen's Income thing sounds a bit dodgy. However being ambitious about renewable energy and banning animal testing are two things I wholeheartedly agree with.


It seems that being principled in politics is seen as naive. Personally I'd rather have people with principles in charge than the cynical, career-driven hypocrites that seem to populate the two main parties.

Jeremy, I voted for them as a mixture of protest and wanting to do something and it wasn't raining. I suspect they'll never get much true power in the UK and to a degree I don't care what they do in europe and there is a symbolic message in keeping 'green' up there somehwere. I quite like the concept of Citizen's Income...but agree with you on the others

On the whole, I'm sure it's positive that they have a presence in European parliament. As you say... keeping 'green' up there.


I like the fact that they have principles, but I disagree with a lot of their ideas. But James, if you agree with what they're trying to do, then that's great... each to their own.

Not trying to get into an argument with you Jeremy! I just think that we have lost all sense of idealism in British politics. If you're an idealist you're labelled naive and childish. Instead people are persuaded by arguments based on expediency and fear, and we end up with mediocrity.


I wish we had politicians with a little more charisma and vision. Next to Barack Obama, Cameron and Brown look like the two old men in the Muppet Show.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • I don’t think Reform will withstand the heat of any election.  Finding enough people to stand will be bad enough. Finding credible ones quite a bid tougher  I think yes this government is lacking in a long term plan and has not had a good first year. Today the least.   but the speed with which this was dealt with is a notable shift compared to last 14 years where months would drag by and we would constantly be told to draw a line under  if Labour called an election tomorrow, there is not a single party that could present a better alternative with any credibility. And that’s a low bar Reform are dangerous lunatics but more worrying is the descent of the Tories into the same swamp i also worry that England voters have contracted some melodrama virus after the Tories where we had 5 PMs in almost as many years  it’s ok for governments to be unpopular without needing to have an election every 1-2 years      
    • Well, I made £50 out of it and Alice owes me another bullseye, so I had a good day Clearly the thread has moved on, but just a final few words on Rayner (from me, at least). If she hadn't gone like this (with a chance to revive her career at some point in the future) there's plenty of other stuff loaded up and ready to be fired at her about the motivation, finances and machinations of her move down South. It's not pretty reading. Tawdry doesn't come close. I was born in Ashton Hospital and grew up in Tameside, I've got a lot of friends and family who weren't as lucky as me and didn't make it out, some close to her constituency party, and there's been a lot of bad feeling around 'Our Ange' for a long time. My favourite quote was: 'She should fuck off back to Stockport.' And that was from a party member. The writing was on the wall for her. Moving from Ashton (majority c6.5k, large Pakistani minority, but predominantly white working class and targeted by both the Independent Alliance and Reform) to Hove (majority c20k, neither of these issues with the electorate) was a pretty cynical move, and she's fucked it royally. 'The Honourable Member for Hove and Portslade' will be sleeping a lot easier in their bed tonight. This thread was never supposed to about Labour bashing, and I'm not sure it is. It's definitely descended into 'Whataboutery', and that seems to be the problem, in my mind at least, with British politics. It's playground stuff, he said/she said, blame-game bollocks. Watch PMQs and ask yourself if you'd accept this sort of behaviour amongst toddlers, let alone in an elected parliament. One thing that does stand out is the opposition to Reform across the board, and yet we seem to be sleepwalking towards a likely scenario where Farage could head up a minority Reform government. I've 'followed' politics since the late Seventies - mainly because the BBC News came on right after 'Roobard and Custard' or 'The Magic Roundabout' - and I can't remember an era where both major parties are so bereft of leadership, direction or ideas. There's a certain irony that we'll all be getting a test text on Sunday to warn us of an impending 'National Emergency'. Seems quite prescient.
    • But not old enough to remember the highest unemployment rate, inflation and interest rates in history in the early eighties under the Tories? A rather selective memory you have. There has never been a four-day week: it was a three-day week imposed by the Conservative government under the Blasted Heath.
    • I see that there was a government consultation started in July 2024, a response, and then a revision to the National Planning Policy Framework, and then to the Green Belt guidance in February 2025, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/green-belt .  It includes the updates but doesn't give the nescient much clue of what was materially changed. There will probably be some good, and less good, summaries to be found. 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...