Minders a bit cheaper Will also often take a child who is slightly unwell On the other hand if the minder is sick herself, there is no cover I had a lovely minder for child no 1 (who then did one morning Pw also at puddle duck) It was like leaving him with a grandmother, if we had had one, and he learned so Much ... She gave him so much 1:1 attention I do think babies under about 18 months look totally confused in nurseries - sharing a key worker with other children and moving out of the baby room to a new key worker often at 12 months. There is research that this isn't the best environment ESP for boys. From aged 2 children do seem to appreciate the nursery setting far more, but even then it could be a long day - a minder will usually take children out to a group or park each morning then spend the afternoon napping and playing at home In a minder's home with low turnover your child will also have older children in the 'sibling role' and as a new mother a good experienced minder can be a source of useful advice and reassurance (I learnt about toilet training from mine and also used to pop round often on days she didn't have him, to show her odd rashes etc!) If you find the right one, it is great. Remember you can get proper references/speak to other families who used her It can Also be a very good solution eventually for wrap around school care/accessing 5 free mornings at nursery at aged 3+ etc