Brexit View

[keano77]

?Only, it isn't. Even if we accept "the purpose" of the act is as you say, nothing you raised impacts his ability to comply with the law.?

What if Boris wrote the letter and attached it to a carrier pigeon that regrettably didn?t make it out of England due to confusion during a pheasant shoot?

[pk]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> ?Only, it isn't. Even if we accept "the purpose"

> of the act is as you say, nothing you raised

> impacts his ability to comply with the law.?

>

> What if Boris wrote the letter and attached it to

> a carrier pigeon that regrettably didn?t make it

> out of England due to confusion during a pheasant

> shoot?

What?s the point of writing this rubbish?

[keano77]

You are worried about rubbish?

Tell me one thing that has been achieved since the Remainers won the Supreme Court case and Parliament was re-convened.

One thing please pk

[JohnL]

I think Merkel is saying the restrictions of the GFA mean NI must remain in a customs union

[Sephiroth]

"Michael from Dulwich" on LBC right now making a right tit of himself

[pk]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> You are worried about rubbish?

>

> Tell me one thing that has been achieved since the

> Remainers won the Supreme Court case and

> Parliament was re-convened.

>

> One thing please pk

parliament has had a (limited) opportunity to ask questions on brexit planning and yellowhammer and the country had an opportunity to hear the same

tell me one thing that makes talk about pigeons anything other than rubbish

[keano77]

?parliament has had a (limited) opportunity to ask questions on brexit planning and yellowhammer and the country had an opportunity to hear the same?

Wow!

?tell me one thing that makes talk about pigeons anything other than rubbish?

Treat it as an allegory pk - a device to simplify a broader matter. Stepdown is concerned that Boris must obey the law. What does the Act say about non-delivery? Perhaps you can advise

[pk]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Treat it as an allegory pk

i'll treat it as pointless rubbish, thanks

[keano77]

You?re welcome

[stepdown]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> What does the Act say about non-delivery?

This may help you understand the Prime Minister's obligations under the act:

[keano77]

Does it explain how Boris will obey the law but not ask for an extension?

[diable rouge]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> You are worried about rubbish?

>

> Tell me one thing that has been achieved since the

> Remainers won the Supreme Court case and

> Parliament was re-convened.

>

> One thing please pk

Sovereignty of Parliament over an Executive that tried to shut it down and silence scrutiny, i.e one of the constitutional pillars of our democracy. As achievements go that's quite a biggie.

As for parliamentary specifics, a number of Acts that otherwise would've been lost had prorogation not been annulled, one being on domestic violence...

[stepdown]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Does it explain how Boris will obey the law but

> not ask for an extension?

No serious analysis supports this as a possibility.

[diable rouge]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Does it explain how Boris will obey the law but

> not ask for an extension?

Suggest you read this, it's why Johnson/Cummings are now shitting themselves...

https://davidallengreen.com/2019/10/the-128-chilling-words-in-the-scottish-case/

[Sephiroth]

If keano and glen haven?t figured out they are rubes on the wrong side of history by now, it?s unlikely they ever will

(Confession: I briefly held out on the idea that keano might actually be open to evidence. I was wrong. So wrong)

[keano77]

diable rouge Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> keano77 Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > Does it explain how Boris will obey the law but

> > not ask for an extension?

>

> Suggest you read this, it's why Johnson/Cummings

> are now shitting themselves...

> https://davidallengreen.com/2019/10/the-128-chilli

> ng-words-in-the-scottish-case/

I don?t click on links. Is he a remainer?

[keano77]

Sephiroth Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> If keano and glen haven?t figured out they are

> rubes on the wrong side of history by now, it?s

> unlikely they ever will

>

> (Confession: I briefly held out on the idea that

> keano might actually be open to evidence. I was

> wrong. So wrong)

There is no evidence we haven?t left. Plenty of guesswork about what might or might not happen from the people who didn?t see the financial crash staring them in the face.

[Sephiroth]

A country brought to its knees. By people as incurious and dumb as keano

Out with a whimper, not a bang

[pk]

I?ve probably missed it elsewhere, but

Keano - what do you think should happen now?

[keano77]

Honestly Sephiroth and pk I?ve no idea what will happen.

The current thinking seems to be the EU will give us an extension until next summer to allow a confirmatory referendum to take place which is being planned by Remainers who might introduce a bill for this as early as next week.

Unless of course Boris has a dastardly plan

[pk]

But what do you think should happen?

[keano77]

Does it really matter what I think should happen?

[pk]

It doesn?t matter at all

But it?s a discussion forum and it?s a topic on which you seem to have a lot to say

So I think it?s a fair question

and I answered your question, it?d be rude not to

[diable rouge]

keano77 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I don?t click on links. Is he a remainer?

No, he's actually a long-term Eurosceptic dating back to Maastricht. He's a legal commentator and primarily comments from the perspective of law and policy...and watching panda videos (in-joke)

[JohnL]

So whats going to be in the Queens speech next week and should it be voted down ?.

Just wondering if a pledge is made in the Queens speech to ask for an extension or alternatively NOT to ask for an extension what should remainers hope for and if the Queens speech is voted down is that automatically an election ?.