Jump to content

Recommended Posts

This topic came up in dicussion with my GIS tutor in the context of preparing historical maps of East Dulwich schools.


I have tried to make this short and not too technical.


John K



[1] The Office of National Statistics maintains a data set of the "official" positions of all schools in England.


[2] The official position is called a "centroid".


[3] The centroid is defined by a National Grid Reference to many decimal points, sufficient to maintain the Ordnance Survey's nominal 2cm [sic] positional accuracy.


[4] Southwark schools now use "as the crow flies" calculations to determine catchment areas.


[5] It is a simple matter to have GIS software draw a "buffer" [circle] of a specific radius from the centroid.


[6] The buffer would be the same as the Southwark declared catchment area.


[7] Southwark schools deviate from the official centroid when calculating catchment areas.


[8] No opinion is expressed on the legality of this deviation.


[9] Where there is more than one school entrance Southwark schools choose a school entrance in place of the official centroid.


[10] No opinion is expressed on the legality of choosing a school entrance as a different centroid to modify a

catchment area.


[11] It is a simple matter to create a new centroid data set and draw a new buffer based on the chosen school entrance.


[12] When a child can be outside a catchment area by as little as one metre where the centroid is based in regard to

the school entrance can be important. It can be the difference between the left-hand and right-hand gate post.


[13] Southwark Council [Planning Department] should have access to basic GIS software than can calculate the buffers.


[14] Mapping buffers would provide objective evidence as to the alleged East Dulwich "black holes".


[15] Mapping buffers would help parents in assessing the accuracy of a failed school application on the grounds of being outside the catchment area.


[16] In 2011 there is no reason why Southwark Council should not be using GIS for these important calculations.

I don't know about Southwark but Lewisham state on their website:


"How do you measure home-to-school distance?


We use a highly accurate computerised measuring system based on national Ordnance Survey maps.


You can use electronic tools such as our find your nearest school pages, or Up My Street (follow the link on the right) to get an estimate of the distance between your home and local schools.


Important note: you should only use these tools as a guide, as they are not as accurate as the measuring system that we use.

"


As long as the c ouncil abides by the stated method, I don't see how legality could be challenged

  • 2 weeks later...

I was too technical.


Just two points:


[1] Southwark Council's assertion that its GIS calculation trumps anything done by a citizen is false.


[2] There are at least three potential legal grounds to challenge a catchment area determination. I'll leave this for the EDF lawyers to explain.


John K

but edhistory, your previous post was arguing that southwark council should use a GIS system, now we have established that it does, you seem to have started arguing the opposite.


You also seem to have an issue with LAs using the school main gate as the pont of measure, but I am not sure you are aware of the Admissions Code -


"2.37 Distance between home and school is a clear and objective oversubscription criterion and is often used as a tie breaker in oversubscription criteria. It has the benefit of ensuring that children will not have a disproportionately long journey if access to their nearest school is not possible. Admission authorities must explain clearly how distance from home to the school will be measured including the points at the school and the child?s home from which distance is to be measured (for example, the main school gate, the front door to the home, how flats will be treated). "

chantelle Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> bottom line - how can a parent measure the

> distance of their house from the school gate?


You would need to ask southwark for the official measurement from their system

In answer to your question Chantelle, quite conveniently for Southwark LA (and no doubt their legal team), only they will be able to tell you the actual distance measurement (down to the last metre) that they will then use to calculate your home's distance to your chosen schools. This is because while they use a commercially available GIS software system called Hometrack SMART, Southwark themselves decide where to plot the point in each school from which each distance measurement to applicants' houses are made.


I have found all this out after our child missed out on a Sept '11 reception place by a mere 3 metres (which was by far our closest community school). We did extensive research into how Southwark undertakes its distance calculations and contacted the GIS company (Hometrack) directly.


While the GIS software uses underlying large-scale Ordnance Map Data and the GIS software itself is incredibly accurate (partic in calculating crows flies distances), Southwark are able to select the measurement point in each school. I have found that in the case of our school, this point is different from the point used by publically available school locator websites - including Southwark's own public school finder site!


If you use Google Earth to calculate crows flies distance, then the results will also probably be different (even if you know what point Southwark are actually using) as Ordnance Survery data automatically discounts building heights and also has a margin of error of at least -/+ 1m.


Finally (and quite crucially), the point at which the SMART GIS software uses within houses to calculate distances to the school is arbitrarily placed within houses. This means that in some houses, the point could be at the front door and in others it could be in the middle of the house or even the back door. We live in a long, thin house - so the 3 metre difference between us and the furthest successful applicant to our child's school could have been easily absorbed by our living/dining room!


We used all of this information in our appeal to Southwark (which we have yet to hear back from Southwark on) - however we have now secured a place at a faith school for our son so will not proceed with the appeal. I am still very annoyed at the system however and do think the use of crow flies measurements as unfair and quite ridiculous.

smb12's post is accurate.


It also deals in passing with the three known grounds for challenging a Southwark Council GIS generated catchment area decision.


One additional point:


It is not only Southwark Council that has access to commercial GIS. I have used ArcGIS to generate maps. In 2011 there are probably surveyors and civil engineers living in East Dulwich who have access to commercial GIS packages. Southwark Council determinations are now subject to citizen validation.


John K

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Hi all, Im a Southwark council leaseholder and live downstairs in a ground floor flat, there is one flat above me, it's a house with individual front doors leading from the street into the shared pathway. My neighbour told me he has had a ring doorbell installed, no discussion as to how I would feel being on camera everytime I go in and out or in my front garden. I was told it's only for deliveries and doesn't record and only activates when pressed, however I don't know this and I feel really uncomfortable everytime I'm out in garden or on doorstep talking to people. Everytime I walk in/out, it lights up and in the eve it has a  infra red  light. Now I've read up that as he said its only for deliveries, he could set it so it only activates when pressed, however it activates with its motion sensor. Had he said to me about getting it installed, I could have had the opportunity to ask about it recording etc but nothing except it's being installed and when I arrived home it was there. I don't like being horrible to people however I feel I have not been considered in his decision and I feel very uncomfortable as, some times I have to stand on doorstep to get signal for my mobile and I really don't like the idea of being watched and listened to. Has anyone got any advice as I'm beginning to get angry as I've asked about it once and was told it only activates when pressed. I believe this is not true. I know southwark council say you need to ask permission to make sure the neighbours are OK with it, I don't really want to go down that road but I don't know how to approach the subject again. They also put a shed approx 3 foot from my back room window, these places are built so my window faces their rear garden and there upstairs window  faces mine. They said it's there temporarily, that was over a year ago and it does affect the light, plus I'm hoping to sell up soon and the view from window is mainly a dark brown shed. When I've mentioned this, I was told they have no where else to put it, whereas originally they said its only temporary, Also the floorboards above are bare and I get woke early morning and at night, the thudding is so bad my light shakes and window rattles, so I mentioned this and asked if they have rugs, I was told when they get the boards re sanded they will get rugs, I should have asked if they could get rugs and just take them up when boards being done, which I would have done had it been me living above someone, their attitude was I can just put up with it until they are ready. so they had the floor boards done, and the workmen was hammering screws, yes screws, in the floorboards, I spoke to workmen to ask how much longer and they said yes, are using screws to make less noise! I could hear the cordless screwdriver, not an issue but for every screw there were at least 8 whacks, the owners had gone out to avoid the noise  so I  spoke to workmen as the noise was unbearable, the sanding, not an issue at all, people need to get things done to their home and I'm fine that on occasions there will be temporary noise. now I have a nice crack on my bedroom ceiling, I mentioned this to owner but no response, he said there were alot of loose floorboards and it will be much better now, not so noisy, as though I don't know the difference between squeaking floor boards and thudding, and nothing was mentioned re the crack or that they now have rugs, which if it were me, I'd be trying to resolve the issue so we can get on with feeling happy in our homes. so I'm feeling it's a total lack of consideration. these places are old and Edwardian and I've lived here over 40 years, had 4 different neighbours and it's only now the noise of thudding is really bad and the people before had floorboards but nothing like this. As you can probably tell I'm really wound up and I don't want to end up exploding at them, I've always got on with neighbours and always said if there's a problem with my dog, pls let me know, always tell me, however I feel it's got to the point where I say something and I'm fobbed off. I know I should tell them but I'm angry, perhaps I should write them a letter. Any suggestions greatly appreciated and thank you for reading my rant. 
    • Sadly, the price we now all pay for becoming a soft apologetic society.
    • Exactly the same thing happened to me a few years back; they were after my Brompton. Luckily there were only 3 of them so I managed to get away and got a woman to call the police, then they backed off, but not after having hit me in the back of the head first. Police said next time just give them what they want, but I sure as hell wasn't just going to hand over my bike to them!
    • In case anyone is renovating or stripping out an old kitchen, I am looking for a base kitchen unit or carcass to house an oven for a temporary set up kitchen.   Also looking for a run of worktop at least 180 cm long if anyone is disposing of something like this, I would be happy to collect.   thanks   Mila
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...