Jump to content

Football Focus

jenniejenjen10

By jenniejenjen10
in The Lounge

 Share

Recommended Posts

'bout now

'bout now

Posted
Posted

I'm not sure the ref last night was to blame. From his view it looked pretty nasty, he consulted the linesman and off he went. I think with challenges like that 4 out of 10 times the player walks, last night was just one of those times. Of course it was a game changer and of course it was a huge game but those are the breaks.


Some might even call it Karma.


( spoken from the P.O.V of neutral tellybox watcher)

Otta

Otta

Posted
Posted

It's hard to know exactly what the ref saw, it was dangerous play without doubt, but could the ref have seen clearly that his eyes were always on the ball (as they keep saying in the news)?


Having seen lots of replays, I think he deserved a yello, and I do have sympathy for United. I don't think the ref deserves a load of abuse though because he never saw the replays, he saw a bloke go flying in with foot way high.

El Pibe

El Pibe

Posted
Posted

"Why were you not supporting a fellow English team in Europe?"


That's really my problem, they're not really English teams in the true sense anymore, just English brands. Likewise Real *spits*, and I'm a bloody Madrile?o!!!


Last night was just watching a couple of All-Stars accrued by rich organisations, it leaves me utterly cold.


I can't get excited about them unless it's some sort of underdog like when O'Neill's Leicester City had a good run in the cup winners a few years back.

red devil

red devil

Posted
Posted

El Pibe Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> That's really my problem, they're not really

> English teams in the true sense anymore, just

> English brands. Likewise Real *spits*, and I'm a

> bloody Madrile?o!!!



What do you mean by 'true sense'...the number of English players?

Surely football is just a reflection/extension of the world/society we now live in. Is England even English in the 'true sense' anymore?..

red devil

red devil

Posted
Posted

Otta Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> RD, were you honestly cheering Chelsea in kast

> years final?


Nope, and I could give you lots of reasons why I didn't. I wasn't saying it was wrong not to support a fellow English team, just asking 'bout now why he/she wasn't...

El Pibe

El Pibe

Posted
Posted

"What do you mean by 'true sense'...the number of English players?

Surely football is just a reflection/extension of the world/society we now live in. Is England even English in the 'true sense' anymore?.."


Basically yes, though it's a simple yardstick.


What really matters is in the players' hearts. What it means to represent the club.


Basically if a club doesn't manage champions league football for a couple of years, how many players would be scouring the clauses in their contracts to go and 'represent' someone who is playing champions league football.

If that's the majority then the club is merely a conduit of mercenary talent, albeit quality mercenary talent.


As for the rest of it, I'm not sure what you mean, are you saying that the world has fully globalised and national identity is meaningless? I don't think so but possibly a subject for another thread, but to your last point, to relate it back to the first point, I think it still boils down to how much it matters.


Noone doubts Mo Farah's Englishness when you see how much it meant to represent his adopted home. Zola Budd, not so much, it was a means to an end.


That's why the modern game leaves me cold and I'd rather watch a good game of hurling these days.


But given your points about the changed world and football's place in it, why then do you think it right someone should support an English club over a foreign one, it's kind of cake and eat it?


Personally spoeaking I'd support, say Fenerbahce over man u or chelsea, because to my eyes it looks like they care more ;-)

red devil

red devil

Posted
Posted

El Pibe Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> What really matters is in the players' hearts.

> What it means to represent the club.


You singled out English clubs, does this also apply to Spanish, Italian etc clubs too?



> But given your points about the changed world and

> football's place in it, why then do you think it

> right someone should support an English club over

> a foreign one, it's kind of cake and eat it?


I never said that. See earlier response to Otta's question...

Alan Medic

Alan Medic

Posted
Posted

Regardless of the harshness or otherwise of the red card for Nani, many teams win games being a man down. I don't think United adapted to the change Real made by bringing on Modric and for a while looked all over the place and lacking composure. Saying that RVP has not been scoring recently and Rooney is more miss than hit as he showed with his effort near the end.


Having heard Keane talk about how it was a red card (he's the expert), it finally got me off the fence to decide he's an effin eeget.

Jah Lush

Jah Lush

Posted
Posted
You make some good points there Doc. I thought Modric bossed the midfield when he came on. Everything went through him and he scored a cracking goal - the little mercenary bastard. Van Purse-Strings was practically anonymous through and as for Roy Keane's comments before and after the game you'd never have thought he once played for Man Utd.
El Pibe

El Pibe

Posted
Posted

absolutely it does, you could say it all really started in Italy, spread here and has infected Spain, though Barca still has a special something about it with its great youth setup* and the fact its owned by the fans.


Fair enough if it was just a question, it did seem like you were implying they should. TBH there wa no criticism implicit in my post, I'm just saying how I feel thses days, this may be more a reflection of changes in me (fatherhood, mid life crisis, recent bereavements) than in football of course.


*and yes, I acknowledge that Man U does this well too, though few make it to first team stalwart as did the generation petering out now

'bout now

'bout now

Posted
Posted

red devil Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> 'bout now Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

>

> > Some might even call it Karma.

> >

> > ( spoken from the P.O.V of neutral tellybox

> > watcher)

>

> Karma for what exactly?

>

> Why were you not supporting a fellow English team

> in Europe?


I don't support United and I don't support Madrid, not that difficult to ascertain is it?


And the Karma comment was a mischievous little prod alluding to the seemingly endless stream of teams claiming to have been victims of dodgy refereeing at Old Trafford.


But you knew that anyway.

red devil

red devil

Posted
Posted

'bout now Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I don't support United and I don't support Madrid,

> not that difficult to ascertain is it?


Can I ascertain then that you would never support any English team in Europe apart from the team that you support?



> And the Karma comment was a mischievous little

> prod alluding to the seemingly endless stream of

> teams claiming to have been victims of dodgy

> refereeing at Old Trafford.

>

> But you knew that anyway.


Actually I didn't, hence the question. Some would say your mischieviousness undermines your professed neutrality...

'bout now

'bout now

Posted
Posted

Yes RD you can. I support West Ham for my sins, as you know. The Champions League is a club competition and as far as I'm concerned has nothing to do with nationality, its just a chance for me to watch Football at the professed highest level.


And I apologise for the mischief but in the grand scheme of things it's only football innit.

red devil

red devil

Posted
Posted

'bout now Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Yes RD you can. I support West Ham for my sins, as

> you know. The Champions League is a club

> competition and as far as I'm concerned has

> nothing to do with nationality, its just a chance

> for me to watch Football at the professed highest

> level.


Fair enough. I'm not bothered if people don't want to support Man Utd when we play in Europe, especially rival fans, I was just curious as to what your reasoning was, with you not being a traditional rival fan.

Apart from the usual suspects I'm happy to 'support' any English team in Europe. I feel it's good for our game if our clubs do well in Europe...each to their own.



> And I apologise for the mischief but in the grand

> scheme of things it's only football innit.


*Bill Shankly turns in his grave...*


ETA: typo, got a sore head today...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

East Dulwich Forum

Established in 2006, we are an online community discussion forum for people who live, work in and visit SE22.

Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...