Jump to content

Is William Rose an organic butcher, as advertised?


froggy

Recommended Posts

  • 2 years later...

I have just made a google search to find a local organic butcher and William Rose, who advertise their 'free range and organic meat', came up high in the search list. Over the years I have popped in to William Rose on a number of occasions, but have come out empty-handed, as I have each time been told they have 'just run out' of the organic meat.


I have spoken to several friends who use William Rose and they have all been of the understanding that the meat they buy from this butcher is organic, as the shop sign suggests, and not just free range.


As I only use organic meat, I decided to called them this time, thinking that I could pre-order, so that I wouldn't risk them being sold out of what I wanted again, but was now informed that they don't sell either organic beef or pork, but do sell some whole organic chicken. I explained that it is organic meat, not chicken, that I am interested in and was to my surprise told there isn't much demand for organic meat!!

When I then suggested that their advertising and sign are in that case misleading, the person I spoke quickly backtracked, got very het up and insistent that they in fact do sell organic meat, as they occasionally have some pieces of lamb available.


After the call I thought I would see if I could find any recommendations for a proper organic butcher on the forum and was interested to find these messages from over two years ago about William Rose, who clearly are quite happy to continue to benefit from people 'misunderstanding' their advertising.

I would suggest that, if people don't fully understand the difference in farming methods between meat that is described as free range (but not organic) and that which is organic, a more honest butcher, less willing to cash in on the misunderstanding rather than perpetuate it, would be happy to explain this difference to their customers and would have a shop sign that properly reflects what they sell.


And if anyone can recommend a butcher that sells organic meat reasonably locally, I would very much appreciate it.

I don't think there are any butchers locally who sell exclusively organic meat but am happy to stand corrected. I doubt it's a plentiful enough resource for a small trader to stay fully stocked, thus the fact that they run out of things.


If it's crucial to you then ordering online is probably the best way to go for organic meats (Abel & Cole have a few options for example.)


I'm surprised that there are people who think everything William Rose sells is organic as they don't claim that to be the case.

I use William Rose, and have never felt misled. They are happy to chat about the meat they stock, and have good knowledge of where it's from etc. I'm sure if you wanted a specific organic meat they would do their best to source it for you. I image it would be a lot more expensive than standard meat, so can understand why they wouldn't stock it all the time as there's probably not a huge demand.

anna123 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I have just made a google search to find a local

> organic butcher and William Rose, who advertise

> their 'free range and organic meat', came up high

> in the search list. Over the years I have popped

> in to William Rose on a number of occasions, but

> have come out empty-handed, as I have each time

> been told they have 'just run out' of the organic

> meat.

>

> I have spoken to several friends who use William

> Rose and they have all been of the understanding

> that the meat they buy from this butcher is

> organic, as the shop sign suggests, and not just

> free range.

>

> As I only use organic meat, I decided to called

> them this time, thinking that I could pre-order,

> so that I wouldn't risk them being sold out of

> what I wanted again, but was now informed that

> they don't sell either organic beef or pork, but

> do sell some whole organic chicken. I explained

> that it is organic meat, not chicken, that I am

> interested in and was to my surprise told there

> isn't much demand for organic meat!!

> When I then suggested that their advertising and

> sign are in that case misleading, the person I

> spoke quickly backtracked, got very het up and

> insistent that they in fact do sell organic meat,

> as they occasionally have some pieces of lamb

> available.

>

> After the call I thought I would see if I could

> find any recommendations for a proper organic

> butcher on the forum and was interested to find

> these messages from over two years ago about

> William Rose, who clearly are quite happy to

> continue to benefit from people 'misunderstanding'

> their advertising.

> I would suggest that, if people don't fully

> understand the difference in farming methods

> between meat that is described as free range (but

> not organic) and that which is organic, a more

> honest butcher, less willing to cash in on the

> misunderstanding rather than perpetuate it, would

> be happy to explain this difference to their

> customers and would have a shop sign that properly

> reflects what they sell.

>

> And if anyone can recommend a butcher that sells

> organic meat reasonably locally, I would very much

> appreciate it.



You could always try Iceland

Edcam: perhaps I didn't explain myself properly - I don't mind using a butcher that sell some organic and some non-organic meat, what I do mind is a butcher that advertises itself as selling organic meat, but doesn't sell any.

Pickle: William Rose was definitely not offering to source any organic meat for me, in spite of advertising themselves as selling it.

anna123 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Edcam: perhaps I didn't explain myself properly -

> I don't mind using a butcher that sell some

> organic and some non-organic meat, what I do mind

> is a butcher that advertises itself as selling

> organic meat, but doesn't sell any.

> Pickle: William Rose was definitely not offering

> to source any organic meat for me, in spite of

> advertising themselves as selling it.i



There are many meat purveyors in Rye Lane that you could investigate. Sure they could source if asked.


Life must be very difficult in LL. Glad Ican be of some help

I imagine vegetarians scanning through this thread and muttering to themselves -- why this hairsplitting about whether it was drowned or choked or hit on the head, whether it had play-toys and sunny skies? -- ALL meat is murder!


This from someone whose favourite utterance at breakfast is "Pass the bacon".

spider69 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> You could always try Iceland


From Iceland's website:

>


Maybe not organic, but if you're going to buy meat, Iceland's probably as good as any other shop. It's mainly snobbery that stops some people from walking through their doors.

No, I just copied text into my post, like so :-)


"We are very proud that, as long ago as 1986, Iceland became the first UK supermarket to remove artificial colours, flavourings and non-essential preservatives from our own brand products ? 19 years before Marks & Spencer. Also in 1986, Iceland became the first UK supermarket to remove monosodium glutamate (MSG) from our own brand products. We banned mechanically recovered meat from all Iceland brand products in 1990, and in 1998 we became the first national food retailer anywhere in the world to ban genetically modified ingredients from all our own brand products: a commitment which every other major UK retailer then followed. We removed hydrogenated fats (manmade trans fats) from all Iceland brand products in 2006."

I didn't suggest they had the best, but just countering the lazy "Iceland is sh*t" meme. Look around Sainsburys, Co-op etc and you'll see lots of rubbishy food for sale. Most people aren't looking for the best steak but maybe a couple of chops, in which case I suspect Iceland isn't noticeably different from most other retailers. I say this as someone who doesn't eat meat, but my family are voracious carnovires :-)

You said it's "probably as good as any other shop", so you kind of did suggest they had the best!


But yeah, it's quite possible that their fresh meat and veg is of comparable quality to other supermarkets, but the selection is very small. And the fact remains that the majority of their food IS complete utter shit, so the reputation is probably deserved.

Jeremy Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> You said it's "probably as good as any other

> shop", so you kind of did suggest they had the

> best!

>

> But yeah, it's quite possible that their fresh

> meat and veg is of comparable quality to other

> supermarkets, but the selection is very small. And

> the fact remains that the majority of their food

> IS complete utter shit, so the reputation is

> probably deserved.





So you agree with DavidH that Iceland is slumlike, something he has not yet explained.


Am sure if they raised their prices through the roof ED would flock there as it was edgy and a new experience.


Grow up or prove the reputation you mention is deserved

StraferJack Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> These look nice. And their website is very upbeat

> about ingredients. Wonder what's in them

>

> http://groceries.iceland.co.uk/iceland-party-24-pi

> ece-sandwich-platter/p/5558

>

> Oh.....

>

> http://twitter.com/gracedent/status/41016097117360



> 5377/photo/1


After Bobs wine choice who cares.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Latest Discussions

    • Rant ahead: You're not one of them but unfortunately, there's a substrate of posters here that do very little except moan and come up with weird conspiracy theories. They're immediately highly critical of just about any change, and their initial assumption is that everyone else is a total fucking contemptible idiot. For example: don't you think that the people who run the libraries will have considered the impact of timing of reconstruction on library users? (In fact, we know they have - because they've made arrangements at other libraries to attempt to mitigate the disruption). After all, these are the people that spend their whole working week thinking about libraries and dealing with library users (and the kids especially). You don't go into the library game for the chicks and fame - so it's fair to assume that librarians are committed to public service and public access to libraries, including by kids. Likewise the built environment people (engineers, architects, construction managers, project managers, construction contractors, subcontractors or whoever is on this job) are told to minimise disruption on every job they do. The thing that occurs to us as amateurs within 30 seconds of us seeing something is probably not something a full time professional hasn't thought about! Southwark Council, the NHS, TfL, Dulwich Estate, Thames Water, Openreach - they're not SPECTRE factories filled with malevolent chaosmongers trying to persecute anyone. They're mostly filled with people who understand their job and try to do their best with what they've been given - just like all of us. Nobody is perfect or immune from challenge, and that's fair enough, but why not at least start from the assumption that there's a good reason why things have been done the way they have? Any normal person would be pleased that their busy, pretty, lively local library is getting refurbished, and will have more space and facilities for kids and teens, and will be more efficient to run and warmer in winter. But no, EDT_Forumite_752 had kids who did an exam 20 years ago, and this makes them an expert on library refurbishment who can see it's all just stuff and nonsense for the green agenda and why can't it all be put off... 😡😡😡
    • I completely misread the previous post, sorry. For some reason I thought the mini cooper was also a police vehicle, DUH.
    • This has given me ideas for the ginger wine I love, that no one else likes!      
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...