Jump to content

Whare do we put negative feedback.


Ruchabo

Recommended Posts

I have within the last year followed up on three glowing EDF recommendations.

One, a plasterer, Micky Lawless, was excellent.

The other two, a carpenter/handyman and a plumber were appalling. I am currently in dispute with the latter who charged c?160 for an hour's work and still left me with the original leak in my bathroom. He acknowledges in writing, that he owes me the money, but two months after the work, has failed to pay it back to me.

Most of what I see on the this site is what apears to be a real over-hyping of certain businesses. I can't be the only one who's had such negative experiences. Either that, or people really do have more money than sense and don't notice a rip off when they see it. (alas too late for me!!).

Is there anywhere to insert ones negative feedback, that it won't get moderated off the site? An objective observer would say that many of the comments on this site are hagiographies, rather than reviews.

Yes I agree.

OP try to search for the thread if possible where you found the recommended business & post your feedback on there. I do sympathize with you as I got an 'electrician' off the forum a few years back & he was rubbish. He also threw some expensive Jim Lawrence hardware away without saying anything, just because he didn't use it. I still remember his name but the thread has long gone. Wish I'd put feedback at the time.

KidKruger Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> It seems customary to put balancing comments in

> the threads concerning the particular businesses,

> rather than create a new thread. I think

> reasonable comments won't be removed.


xxxxxx


They will be if the tradesperson in question complains and/or threatens to sue the forum.


Even if the comments are reasonable and even if the poster has proof of poor work.

  • 2 weeks later...

I can second your recommendation for Mickey Lawless he did a brilliant job and what a thoroughly lovely man.


However, on the whole I can say that the majority of the trades people I have used on the forum have been second rate to appalling....one thing to note when looking up trades folk is to check how many times the person recommending them have posted on the forum....I used an ED based plumber with lots of amazing reviews....after the event I checked the "rave" recommendations and noticed that they were first time or novice posters....mates I reckon!


I agree not enough policing.

faffy Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

I used an ED based plumber with lots

> of amazing reviews....after the event I checked

> the "rave" recommendations and noticed that they

> were first time or novice posters....mates I

> reckon!


xxxxxxxx


If it's the plumber I think it is, I don't think that they are necessarily mates, however this plumber specifically asks people to post a recommendation on here after he has done the job.


Probably most people he asks feel pressured into doing so, even if they've never posted on here before. They might think he won't work for them again if they don't.


I don't know how you could go about policing that.

Totally agree. I now don't believe forum recommendations as most I assume are written after considerable pressure by the tradesperson and therefore worthless.


A friend who has had similarly bad experiences now has a policy of adding to a thread with a comment such as "I had a different experience to these positive reviewers, please contact me direct for further info", which seems to be a good way of flagging a bad experience while avoiding being accused of publicly bad mouthing...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Latest Discussions

    • Try oru space with Michelle. Think it runs on Wednesday evenings. She’s great. I also think the new casa core place does one but haven’t tried it. 
    • The OP is simply asking a question? and as a few people on this forum seem to know about every subject posted 🙄 maybe that was the reason for asking?😉 It's been such a dry summer so far, maybe "some trees" are becoming less stable due to lack of rainfall and needed some safety pollarding work?  (another question🙂)  
    • No offence, but why not start from the assumption that the trees team in Southwark Council know what they're doing because it's their job and aren't a bunch of ecogenocidal maniacs looking for excuses to cut back trees? I'm not an expert but if they're not coming back to cut down the rest, then it seems like pollarding. It always looks ugly at first. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollarding
    • It looks like the branches overhung the entry way to the toilets. There's a lot of paranoia about at the moment about branch drop after a couple of sad accidents which have happened recently where beloved trees were propped up but still dropped branches then everyone jumps up and asks why nothing was done before. You might remember when the massive oak fell over in Peckham Rye by the skating park, thankfully no one was hurt.  I've noticed notices in almost every public space warning about branch drop and some trees have had barriers put underneath them etc. These things seem to come into vogue and then pass again.  I expect local authorities in their regular meetings have all been discussing their risk exposure and issues of corporate responsibility etc....and someone will have been assigned the task (and responsibility) of making everything all right. Perhaps this tree fell victim to that. I doubt there is malice and something they feel is safer/appropriate etc will take its place in due course.  I don't doubt cutting it back is an over reaction but at the same time we all bellow at them when things go wrong so there is a difficult path to navigate. It was a chestnut by the look of it, so not particularly rare I have plenty of saplings growing through my beds if they wish to replace like for like.   
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...