Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Is cake-stalling some kind of contemporary extreme sport?


Is the WI in the habit of trying to give local community organisations a "run for their money" or is that just the "young and trendy" ones?


Blue Mountain were there last year too. Their cakes are delicious, of course, but I think people really like home-made cakes at that kind of event.


As I said already I think there's a tremendous appetite for home baked goods. Hope you have fun!

Good stuff guys! Think the young WI thing is great - just a quick word of warning to maybe seek advice from WI headquarters about the raising money for charity issue if it were to come up on the day (I know you haven't said this) - it just that as the group is so new, you probably aren't yet legally consituted as an offical member branch. Therefore, technically if you were to say that the money raised from the cake sale is going to charity, it might not be strictly true. However, if the money is going to WI headquarters (to be then re-imbursed to you when you are a branch) then it's probably ok.


Sorry to be pendantic. I don't want to be a wet blanket but I've got alot of experience of fundraising and charity law and wouldn't want your enthusaism to be shot down if someone was to complain on the day. It's also that the WI do also raise funds for local causes through bake sales and the like all over so people might also get confused about the purpose of the stall. Just a gentle piece of advice - it's not really a WI thing to run against other local charities or try to give them a run for their money. Community service is a big part of the WI ethos/mission and can I suggest that maybe a percentage of the ED WI takings go to a local charity??? Just a suggestion - I'm not part of the group (although I might join) and I understand why you need the funds to get things set up i.e. for the branch membership to the main WI, etc, etc. But it would also set the community service ethos as part of it from the beginning.


In the past, I've asked for support from local WI branches to provide tea and coffee making support at charity/community events I've run and they come in and do their thing like a well-oiled machine!! They know their health and safety, they have proper big hot water boiling and they make a mean cup of tea - and all for free as volunteers! The WI is fab in my book!!!

Indeed ...


I don't think we need to have a custard pie fight about it.:)) I really do think the more the merrier and that people really do love a good sponge (though gingerbread people are extremely popular too).


Its great that there's a new willing and able force for the community good on the scene and I hope you get lots of people signing up...

Despite their old fashioned image, the WI have a long traditional of campaigning and community service alongside their role in promoting crafts and baking while providing a social network for members. Many branches also respond to local emergencies and crisis in local areas with blankets, first aid, food etc. I've always found the branches I've worked with really well organised and co-ordinated in their responses to the needs of local communities - ready to get stuck in and volunteer. And many of their political campaigns are around important issues such as Fairtrade.

Indeed Scruffy M. When this was first proposed I have to confess to a good deal of pooh poohing and a nervousness about the feminist implications of a celebration of all things domestic and an attraction to pole dancing. I had, however, heard good things about the WI already and looked them up and think that they're rather marvellous.


I do hope the ED branch works out. Its great to see some community action and there's lots of projects they could be involved in. I wish them the best of luck. (And am sure their cakes will be delicious)

Bawdy-nan - yes, I agree and if I didn't already know about the wider aspects of the WI, I would have had the same attitude! If this branch follows up with some of the campaigning and community service angle of the WI, I'll be in! Would be good to have some support and co-ordination of fundraising efforts for small local community groups and charities for whom even a few hundred quid will make a difference to the services they provide

Look - seriously - we just thought it would be fun to bake some cakes for the fair and have a bit of a presence so that people that don't use the forum will know that we are trying to set up a new group. I don't think we really have thought about actually coming out with a profit - it's not about that and we've not had a lot of time - if miraculously we do we will certainly check what we should do with the money.

Really looking forward to a fun day. Bawdy nan - maybe we should have hooked up earlier and we could have helped bolster your cake coffers!

x

Yes, I totally get what you are saying and I totally understand the challenges you face!! It's just that you could get questions selling cakes under the charity brand of the WI - that's all! And it's fair enough really for people to know if they are buying cakes under a charity brand where the money is going. But it sounds great and I'll definately drop in to get more info about what you are all up to.


And Bawdy - Nan looking forward to buying a cake to support the community nursery!

Bawdy-Nan - well done you for getting involved in the nursery fundraiser. (tu) I may even drop by and buy a yummy cake!


I understand that there has been a number of conversations with the people higher up in the WI about setting up and the cake bake has been discussed with them. We only met for the first time last week and there is a lot to do re admin, so the cake bake will just be a small affair which we first thought about last week.


Having met the absolutely lovely 'Annt', I am 100% sure that the quip about 'giving them a run for their money' was just light-hearted banter following on from previous threads on the WI!! :)) No one should desire to compete with a charity or something that is being done for the good of a community. I hope we all manage to sell our cakes and if any are left unsold, I am sure we can find a good cause to donate them to (old people's home etc who would appreciate the thought). By the way Scruffy Mummy - thanks for the tips. :)

Of course Ko :))


Though I do wonder whether there just might be some mileage in cake-stalling as a new extreme sport? Like paint-balling but messier? Maybe it could be part of big ED alternative sports day. Sack races, cake-stalling, buggy slalem, arm-wrestling for the honour of local business etc


Sounds like it could be fun.


It would be lovely to have a big ED fete or something, with stalls and games (like the fantastic arts fete that's held at the V&A)

I know about the issues concerning charity law etc, so that's why I definitely didn't say that we were raising money for charity. This is a very last minute effort by our fledgeling WI group to make a few cakes -we'll be very lucky indeed if we have enough money left over to make any kind of donation. The main reason for our presence really is to raise awareness that we are setting up a WI group. Maybe you'd fancy joining our 'wild' nights at the WI???!

To any of you WI wannabee's who have not read my recent email, we would like some more cake baking contributions please!!


Please let me know asap if any more of you will be making a cake for the fair on Sunday!!! or if you can help out on the stand????

Thanks ..Tracey

Hi Cupcake - that's great! Yes, bring them along before the 11am start on Sunday. Thanks x


Cupcake Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Hello - I am up for making a couple of lemon

> drizzle cakes - I assume I just drop them at the

> stall on the day?

Thanks Cupcake and Monica and everyone. That's great. Contributions are starting to look better.


BTW, I think I must've missed a few messages before as I was busy baking. I have to say that of course I was joking when I said something about giving someone a run for their money. I do hope we are allowed a bit of light-hearted banter in this forum??????!

Hey there. I am going down to the coast tomorrow, leaving 7am ( !) If you can get to mine by then, that's great - I'll send you a private message with my address. If you can't make that, and if no one else sees your message and suggests an alternative, you could just leave them in in my front garden (in a tub and a carrier bag as it is supposed to rain tomorrow!) Have fun in Somerset!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Last week we had no water for over 24 hours and very little support from Thames Water when we called - had to fight for water to be delivered, even to priority homes. Strongly suggest you contact [email protected] as she was arranging a meeting with TW to discuss the abysmal service
    • The is very low water pressure in the middle of Friern Road this morning.
    • I think mostly those are related to the same "issues". In my experience, it's difficult using the pin when reporting problems, especially if you're on a mobile... There's two obvious leaks in that stretch and has been for sometime one of them apparently being sewer flooding 😱  
    • BBC Homepage Skip to content Accessibility Help EFor you Notifications More menu Search BBC                     BBC News Menu   UK England N. Ireland Scotland Alba Wales Cymru Isle of Man Guernsey Jersey Local News Vets under corporate pressure to increase revenue, BBC told   Image source,Getty Images ByRichard Bilton, BBC Panorama and Ben Milne, BBC News Published 2 hours ago Vets have told BBC Panorama they feel under increasing pressure to make money for the big companies that employ them - and worry about the costly financial impact on pet owners. Prices charged by UK vets rose by 63% between 2016 and 2023, external, and the government's competition regulator has questioned whether the pet-care market - as it stands - is giving customers value for money. One anonymous vet, who works for the UK's largest vet care provider, IVC Evidensia, said that the company has introduced a new monitoring system that could encourage vets to offer pet owners costly tests and treatment options. A spokesperson for IVC told Panorama: "The group's vets and vet nurses never prioritise revenue or transaction value over and above the welfare of the animal in their care." More than half of all UK households are thought to own a pet, external. Over the past few months, hundreds of pet owners have contacted BBC Your Voice with concerns about vet bills. One person said they had paid £5,600 for 18 hours of vet-care for their pet: "I would have paid anything to save him but felt afterwards we had been taken advantage of." Another described how their dog had undergone numerous blood tests and scans: "At the end of the treatment we were none the wiser about her illness and we were presented with a bill of £13,000."   Image caption, UK pet owners spent £6.3bn on vet and other pet-care services in 2024, according to the CMA Mounting concerns over whether pet owners are receiving a fair deal prompted a formal investigation by government watchdog, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). In a provisional report, external at the end of last year, it identified several issues: Whether vet companies are being transparent about the ownership of individual practices and whether pet owners have enough information about pricing The concentration of vet practices and clinics in the hands of six companies - these now control 60% of the UK's pet-care market Whether this concentration has led to less market competition and allowed some vet care companies to make excess profits 'Hitting targets' A vet, who leads one of IVC's surgeries (and who does not want to be identified because they fear they could lose their job), has shared a new internal document with Panorama. The document uses a colour code to compare the company's UK-wide tests and treatment options and states that it is intended to help staff improve clinical care. It lists key performance indicators in categories that include average sales per patient, X-rays, ultrasound and lab tests. The vet is worried about the new policy: "We will have meetings every month, where one of the area teams will ask you how many blood tests, X-rays and ultrasounds you're doing." If a category is marked in green on the chart, the clinic would be judged to be among the company's top 25% of achievers in the UK. A red mark, on the other hand, would mean the clinic was in the bottom 25%. If this happens, the vet says, it might be asked to come up with a plan of action. The vet says this would create pressure to "upsell" services. Panorama: Why are vet bills so high? Are people being priced out of pet ownership by soaring bills? Watch on BBC iPlayer now or BBC One at 20:00 on Monday 12 January (22:40 in Northern Ireland) Watch on iPlayer For instance, the vet says, under the new model, IVC would prefer any animal with suspected osteoarthritis to potentially be X-rayed. With sedation, that could add £700 to a bill. While X-rays are sometimes necessary, the vet says, the signs of osteoarthritis - the thickening of joints, for instance - could be obvious to an experienced vet, who might prefer to prescribe a less expensive anti-inflammatory treatment. "Vets shouldn't have pressure to do an X-ray because it would play into whether they are getting green on the care framework for their clinic." IVC has told Panorama it is extremely proud of the work its clinical teams do and the data it collects is to "identify and close gaps in care for our patients". It says its vets have "clinical independence", and that prioritising revenue over care would be against the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' (RCVS) code and IVC policy. Vets say they are under pressure to bring in more money per pet   Published 15 April 2025 Vets should be made to publish prices, watchdog says   Published 15 October 2025 The vet says a drive to increase revenue is undermining his profession. Panorama spoke to more than 30 vets in total who are currently working, or have worked, for some of the large veterinary groups. One recalls being told that not enough blood tests were being taken: "We were pushed to do more. I hated opening emails." Another says that when their small practice was sold to a large company, "it was crazy... It was all about hitting targets". Not all the big companies set targets or monitor staff in this way. The high cost of treatment UK pet owners spent £6.3bn on vet and other pet-care services in 2024 - equal to just over £365 per pet-owning household, according to the CMA. However, most pet owners in the UK do not have insurance, and bills can leave less-well-off families feeling helpless when treatment is needed. Many vets used not to display prices and pet owners often had no clear idea of what treatment would cost, but in the past two years that has improved, according to the CMA. Rob Jones has told Panorama that when his family dog, Betty, fell ill during the autumn of 2024 they took her to an emergency treatment centre, Vets Now, and she underwent an operation that cost almost £5,000. Twelve days later, Betty was still unwell, and Rob says he was advised that she could have a serious infection. He was told a diagnosis - and another operation - would cost between £5,000-£8,000.   Image caption, Betty's owners were told an operation on her would cost £12,000 However, on the morning of the operation, Rob was told this price had risen to £12,000. When he complained, he was quoted a new figure - £10,000. "That was the absolute point where I lost faith in them," he says. "It was like, I don't believe that you've got our interests or Betty's interests at heart." The family decided to put Betty to sleep. Rob did not know at the time that both his local vet, and the emergency centre, branded Vets Now, where Betty was treated, were both owned by the same company - IVC. He was happy with the treatment but complained about the sudden price increase and later received an apology from Vets Now. It offered him £3,755.59 as a "goodwill gesture".   Image caption, Rob Jones says he lost faith in the vets treating his pet dog Betty Vets Now told us its staff care passionately for the animals they treat: "In complex cases, prices can vary depending on what the vet discovers during a consultation, during the treatment, and depending on how the patient responds. "We have reviewed our processes and implemented a number of changes to ensure that conversations about pricing are as clear as possible." Value for money? Independent vet practices have been a popular acquisition for corporate investors in recent years, according to Dr David Reader from the University of Glasgow. He has made a detailed study of the industry. Pet care has been seen as attractive, he says, because of the opportunities "to find efficiencies, to consolidate, set up regional hubs, but also to maximise profits". Six large veterinary groups (sometimes referred to as LVGs) now control 60% of the UK pet care market - up from 10% a decade ago, according to the CMA, external. They are: Linnaeus, which owns 180 practices Medivet, which has 363 Vet Partners with 375 practices CVS Group, which has 387 practices Pets at Home, which has 445 practices under the name Vets for Pets IVC Evidensia, which has 900 practices When the CMA announced its provisional findings last autumn, it said there was not enough competition or informed choice in the market. It estimated the combined cost of this to UK pet owners amounted to £900m between 2020-2024. Corporate vets dispute the £900m figure. They say their prices are competitive and made freely available, and reflect their huge investment in the industry, not to mention rising costs, particularly of drugs. The corporate vets also say customers value their services highly and that they comply with the RCVS guidelines.   Image caption, A CMA survey suggests pet owners are happy with the service they receive from vets A CMA survey suggests pet owners are happy with their vets - both corporate and independent - when it comes to quality of service. But, with the exception of Pets at Home, customer satisfaction on cost is much lower for the big companies. "I think that large veterinary corporations, particularly where they're owned by private equity companies, are more concerned about profits than professionals who own veterinary businesses," says Suzy Hudson-Cooke from the British Veterinary Union, which is part of Unite. Proposals for change The CMA's final report on the vet industry is expected by the spring but no date has been set for publication. In its provisional report, it proposed improved transparency on pricing and vet ownership. Companies would have to reveal if vet practices were part of a chain, and whether they had business connections with hospitals, out-of-hours surgeries, online pharmacies and even crematoria. IVC, CVS and Vet Partners all have connected businesses and would have to be more transparent about their services in the future. Pets at Home does not buy practices - it works in partnership with individual vets, as does Medivet. These companies have consistently made clear in their branding who owns their practices. The big companies say they support moves to make the industry more transparent so long as they don't put too high a burden on vets. David Reader says the CMA proposals could have gone further. "There's good reason to think that once this investigation is concluded, some of the larger veterinary groups will continue with their acquisition strategies." The CMA says its proposals would "improve competition by helping pet owners choose the right vet, the right treatment, and the right way to buy medicine - without confusion or unnecessary cost". For Rob Jones, however, it is probably too late. "I honestly wouldn't get another pet," he says. "I think it's so expensive now and the risk financially is so great.             Food Terms of Use About the BBC Privacy Policy Cookies Accessibility Help Parental Guidance Contact the BBC Make an editorial complaint BBC emails for you Copyright © 2026 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...