Jump to content

Recommended Posts

...in an attempt to thwart wealthy foreigners jumping the queue for a new liver.


Is this right?


Should the donated organs go to the most needy, regardless of status or depth of pockets or should the transplant system follow the rules of capitalism and let money do the talking?


bbc article

To answer Horsebox - the majority of UK's hospitals are managed and funded by the NHS - therefore NHS patients should have priority. That's the easy answer.


As with all transplants - donor / receiver compatibility is a major factor in deciding who gets what. Thus if there are, say, 70 potential liver transplant patients on the critical list and a donor organ arrives but it, doesn't unfortunately, match any of the potential recipients - what to do? Some of the factors in the decision making process will be:


a. The need to not waste the organ


b. The need to keep the surgical team in practice - it used to be that any team had to carry out a minimum no. of these specialist procedures a year to maintain and develop expertise.


c. The opportunity to "exchange" the organ with another hospital (abroad since the donor system in UK is very sophisticated and can match a donated organ to all / any on the list awaiting transplant)


d. The opportunity to earn revenue for the hospital - to be used for the hospital (not paid to the surgical team).


I've no doubt annaj can add a lot more background.


If all healthcare were privatised then the patient's insurer would normally stump up - because of the need to match the organ for compatibility money cannot, by itself, take anyone to the top of a waiting list for a transplant.

Hypothetically, private care involvement should have no bearing on allocation of organs from non-heart beating donors (Heart beating donors are a bit more complicated), as the Transplant team (who make the allocation decisions) are an independent NHS multicentre team with no personal involvement in the care of anyone awaiting an organ until they are allocated one. Hypothetically, private healthcare would only serve to get you a nicer bed to recover in, and transfer a wedge of your bank balance to a surgeon. Hypothetically.


So where can private healthcare upset the system?


I have no idea: My involvement with transplant services has been mostly at the non-heart beating donor end, a little around heart and lung recipients, and all NHS.


As for the overseas issue, I understand that if we don't have anyone waiting who is a tissue match but someone overseas is then it makes a lot of sense. And there are good chances that there will be an overseas tissue match when there isn't a UK one, because simple statistics are that there are a number of conditions, such as hepatitis, which result in the need for an organ transplant, which are more prevalent in other countries than here. If you have 100 times the number of people awaiting transplant, logic states a significantly increased chance that an organ will match someone from that group.


Money at any stage will not make you a viable tissue match to an organ that you are not, nor will it stop you from being the only match currently on the waiting list if you are potless.


I've not fully evaluated the evidence regarding this particular "scandal", and what evidence there is doesn't seem to be particularly extensive or objective. An independent enquiry seems useful.

As BN5 has already mentioned, tissue type has a big part to play - could well be that no one else (as poorly as him - remember he'd gone dry for 6 mths+ beforehand) matched the donor liver... should the donor liver have gone to waste??


The proportion of organs donated is low mainly because of the poor number of people making it clear before the time comes that they'd like to donate, but also because it's limited situations that organs can be taken (due to medical history/how the donor has died etc).


This is why the work done at Kings regarding living liver donations (the liver can regenerate itself) is so exciting and a very positive step forward.

  • 1 month later...

antijen Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> So why did George Best become top priority.


I think that this is a really interesting point. I have no doubt that George Best's tissue type, alcohol dependance etc were issues determining his suitability for transplant. But just because George Best opted for private healthcare, should that disclude him from his rights to NHS care or place on the waiting list for organ donation? He was a tax payer in this country. If he decided to pay for private healthcare, surely he would remain as eligable as any other citizen of this country for donor organs.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Nothing to do with the tories overspending whatsoever eh! Blame the last 10/11 years of blatant mismanagement, incompetence and willful deceit on the poor bastards that were left with the fall out of a complete car crash tory government.   One PM after another falling on their sword. Open corruption and piss taking throughout covid and a legacy of huge debt and destruction yet in your view it will be labour's 4 years in power that bankrupts us in 2029.  Another one that must think people are blind and stupid.  Rejoice rejoice. It's a pity he and his fellow clowns were completely annihilated at the ballot box. I mean they were doing so well after all 🙃🙃
    • Where did I say he did a good job? Yup and Corbyn was very close to Len McCluskey and funded by Unite wasn't he...they're all as bad as each other... Labour have to purge their party of the far-left - they're a disaster. Allan Johnson summed it up so well on election night in 2019....  
    • Thank you for the detailed advise @trinidad It is definitely damage we are concerned about. I don’t think Evri would agree to pay the bill to fix our gate or letter box if they were to be damaged as a result of their delivery drivers helper. Our doorbell can be heard from outside when rung so we don’t quite believe the aggressive simultaneous door/letter box banging is necessary. It can be quite a shock it is done very aggressively.  I’ll definitely action the steps you’ve kindly provided along with a phone call tomorrow. I do sympathise with the role drivers have and how busy they are, which is why we tried communicating directly with her but sadly we haven’t succeeded 
    • What outcome would you like? Disciplinary action? Not to have the driver back? Retraining? I know there is alot of pressure on drivers to deliver within a set day. if he slams the gate, is it evidence he is causing damage, or is the noise a irritant to yourself? You could put a sign up or buy a signing asking to close the gate gentle???? can you hear the door bell from the door? he might be ringing, not hearing and therefore knocking. In trhe notes section of the be livery page, there is a note section, although there is not 100 per cent these notes would be read as these drivers are constantly rushing.  I did a google search for you, i found this and you can try the envri website Contact Us | Evri   To complain to Evri, you can follow these steps: Contact Customer Service: Call Evri's customer service at 0330 808 5456 for assistance with your complaint.    1 Write a Letter: Address your complaint to Capitol House, 1 Capitol Close, Morley, Leeds, West Yorkshire, LS27 0WH.    1 Use the Official Website: Visit the Evri complaints page on their official website for detailed instructions on how to submit a complaint.    2 Email or Call for Specific Issues: For issues like missing or damaged parcels, you can email or call 0800 988 8888, which is free to call.    1 These methods will help you effectively communicate your concerns to Evri.   My driver is called anthony, he is brilliant to be honest. I cant fault him.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...