Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Wondering if any of you kind folks can help on this matter. We occupy the first floor of a 2 flat house with a share of freehold which states that our responsibility for the freehold would include all repairs that take place from our flat and upwards (roof, etc) with our neighbour on the ground floor responsible for any repairs from his flat downwards. He may have possible subsidence and is looking to get a survey which he thinks both flats are responsible for as he feels the subsidence will affect the entire house we both occupy.


My question is: Are we responsible for splitting the costs for this survey if he detects subsidence in his flat?


Many thanks for any help you can provide!

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/73446-subsidence-help/
Share on other sites

Check your building insurance policy as there should be subsidence cover. But bear in mind that any call to your insurer will result in a potential claim and will possibly affect your insurance cover. To establish whether it is subsidence first would be best. Have you seen the crack? It would have to be very large crack not a fine line crack.


If it is established it is subsidence then your insurer would appoint a loss adjuster, they will make there recommendations and monitoring any movement, cracking. Will look at the surrounding areas for trees etc. It can be a long process but should all be covered under your policy apart from the excess.

The terms of your lease seem very unfair. You are responsible alone for the roof yet you could equally claim that a leaking roof affects the entire building. I've always had shared responsibility for any major work. Worth investigating whether this could be changed.

Firstly - simonethebeaver is right, it's a very unusual lease, usually all major works such as roof or strucutral problems would be shared.


Secondly - you should probably go straight to your buildings insurance (i.e. the shared policy between you and the other flat). They will appoint someone to investigate the issue. I don't see the need for a third party survey.

  • 3 weeks later...

First you should find out what has caused this, since there can be human issues such as damaged drains or natural issues like the land it's built on (https://www.pinterest.com/pin/433471532862838082/)


If it is caused because something human (and by the lower flat) I'd say don't drop a dime at all, but if it is due to something natural like the land or trees I'd say you should help out.

That does sound an unusual lease - surely it's more likely that a property will need work to a roof as opposed to drains ?


Have you seen the lease ? Your solicitor or whoever dealt with your sale should have gone through it with you ,may have given you a copy or might have a copy on file if you ask .

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Just a review for Andy. I have now used him for various jobs for 5 years or so. An absolute and complete star. Always goes above and beyond, never cuts a corner, and always prices incredibly fairly. If you need a handyman...he is your man. Could not recommend more highly.
    • Don’t know about cafes but the Victoria and Montpelier pubs always have always encouraged people working during the day.
    • Thank you Saied for the amazing work! I will see you in a few months.
    • If you care about the decline in the swift population please support the lovely Hannah Bourne-Taylor in her campaign to mandate 'swift bricks' in all new properties   From her website: What are swift bricks? Zero maintenance and sustainable, swift bricks are bricks that sit flush to the wall that provide a cavity nesting habitat for swifts and other cavity nesting birds. Surveys show species include House martins, starlings, House sparrows, nuthatch, blue tit, coal tit and wren. Why swift bricks are urgently and uniquely essential Without swift bricks there is no guaranteed nesting habitat for birds reliant on building cavities anywhere in the UK – and there never will be. We are inadvertently destroying their oldcavity nesting sites through renovation, demolition and insulation, while climate mitigation measures mean modern buildings will never provide natural homes for birds. https://hannahbournetaylor.com/ Don't be such a pompous bore. She is doing something to improve the world around us, what does it matter what social class she is from? The despicable Michael Gove offered support then did nothing. The current government, despite supposed concern for the environment, also failed to support the campaign. She took the trouble to write back to me when I asked a question. But carry on poking fun at honourable people while our surroundings decay.   
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...