Jump to content

Recommended Posts

If St Aidans Group had any role in the Solomons Passage fiasco - and it is listed on their website as one of their projects - then surely, their recent application for planning permission at Railway Rise must be put on ice by Southwark Council until a full investigation into the Solomons Passage demolition and relocation of residents - both homeowners and renters - is concluded? James Barber? Renata Hamvas?

I think you're confusing planning permission with the actual building of things.

Most developers get planning permission and then sell the scheme on. Or they bank it for a few years.

Developers rarely have in house construction and building capacity. They rely on contractors being professional.


So the system won't consider putting any planning application 'in 'ice.


I'd also suggest that the court system we have will mean many years of legal wrangles. Which is why it was such good news about the homes coming under NHBC insurance meaning that legal wrangles can happen in parallel and into the future without delaying actually fixing and replacing homes.

James Barber Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> Most developers get planning permission and then

> sell the scheme on. Or they bank it for a few

> years.

> Developers rarely have in house construction and

> building capacity. They rely on contractors being

> professional.

>

-------------------------------------------------------


This is of course what St Aidan's did with the Garden Centre, no doubt banking a decent profit while achieving nothing. Ten years on we have a demolition site. This ought to be taken into account when they apply for another development, but it won't.

We are now in the confusing position that number 2 and 3 Railway Rise are for sale, but the new proposal for redevelopment has now been issued. http://planbuild.southwark.gov.uk:8190/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=externalDocuments&keyVal=_STHWR_DCAPR_9565779


I think that the plans submitted are the amended plans they tried at the end of the previous process, which were rejected as the planners said that they could not go above the existing level. Maybe they thought they might as well make use of them.


The revised proposal isn't as bad as the original (it couldn't be worse) as it only appears to require partial demolition, apparently preserving the front of the cottages. At the back, the new three-storey extension will project further than the existing and will block out sunlight for number 1 from, I guess, mid-morning. The houses would look very different, with rather incongruous 'Juliet' balconies and a mansard roof. As well as these objections, the houses would seem quite cramped downstairs for 3/4 bedrooms and provide relatively little extra accommodation - both used as grounds for rejecting the original designs.

  • 2 weeks later...

The deadline for comments on the revised proposal for the (partial) demolition of the cottages at Railway Rise, by East Dulwich Station is this Friday 24 June.


You can see the application on the Southwark Planning website at http://planbuild.southwark.gov.uk:8190/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?activeTab=summary&keyVal=_STHWR_DCAPR_9565779. The reference number is 16/AP/1341.


The proposal is less dramatic than the previous proposal to completely demolish 2 and 3 and build a four-storey block. Nevertheless, I have objected on the grounds that:

- The new three-storey rear building is higher than the other house and is clearly out of keeping with the rest of the cottages.

- The proposal requires a substantial demolition of the cottages and a building in the garden.

- The substantial extension to three storeys would block the light for the neighbours.

- The new extension would overlook the neighbour, invading privacy.

- The proposal to fit three and four bedrooms leads to cramped accommodation.

  • 5 weeks later...
  • 3 months later...

Comments on the third application for planning permission on the cottages at Railway Rise are scheduled to close on Wednesday (sorry - this has rather snuck up on me.)


As history - this follows on from an initial plan to completely demolish 2&3 and build a four-storey block. That was rejected by the council and on appeal. A second plan followed for a three storey rear extension. That was rejected but has now gone to appeal. They have put in a third application, which extends the cottages back and builds a dormer roof to take then up to three storeys. I assume that the developer assumes everyone will gradually be worn down into submission.


If you wish to make a comment look at: http://planbuild.southwark.gov.uk:8190/online-applications/, using the reference number 16/AP/4028.


See attached picture for an indication of the scale of this (but note this is only one perspective which doesn't show how far back this goes).

"I assume that the developer assumes everyone will gradually be worn down into submission."


Certainly true ,but as someone who's been in a similar position I would say never underestimate the effect your objections will have on the final outcome .


There will of course be a development but it will be significantly better than the original proposal .

This is exacly what the developer will assume and mirrors the progress of the M&S development. In fact all objectors to currently contentious developments, inlcuding this and Greendale/ Dulwich Hamlets should pay close attention and make the effort to get Councillors much more involved as well as objecting. WIth M&S the right noises were made from time to time by our Councillor but in a desultory kind of way.

Thanks for letting us know about this Chazzle.


I've just put in an objection based on my view that these new proposals are damaging to the character and appearance of houses which are of regional and local importance (See earlier reference in this thread to the fact that 1,2 and 3 Railway Rise are possibly the only remaining examples of the houses built by the London, Brighton and Southern railway to house rail workers in the 1860s across the whole of Southern England. They are also some of the oldest houses in East Dulwich). I have also suggested that the scale of the development is disproportionate to the existing footprint and plot size of the cottages.

  • 4 weeks later...
  • 6 months later...

And finally - the third appeal is dismissed


http://planbuild.southwark.gov.uk:8190/online-applications/appealDetails.do?activeTab=summary&keyVal=_STHWR_DCAPPEAL_1697


So, two and a half years later, it could be that this is an end of this attempt to turn these homes into a (more) lucrative investment. Well, hope so!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Turn your used stamps into vital funds to support human rights around the world.   How it works: Simply send us your stamps and we'll then sort through them to sell or auction. We accept all stamps of all origin and value – both used and new. Foreign and commemorative ones are likely to be worth the most. Please leave at least half centimetre of paper around the stamps Send your stamps to: FAO Robin Sandow c/o The Post Room Amnesty International UK 2nd Floor, Peter Benenson House, 1 Easton Street, London, WC1X 0DW Recycle your stamps.AIUK.pdf
    • Also, if he enjoys design or drawing (alongside his maths & tech) he might like the Greenpeace competition for a poster (see Lounge post) - 5 days left to enter. Something more for some time at home, but ...
    • Deadline in 5 days! Important Dates 🗓 Submission deadline: 25 July 2025 🗳 Public voting opens: 7 August 2025 🚢 Winners announced: 15 August 2025   Time is running out! There are only 5 days left to submit your design for Greenpeace’s poster competition. This is your chance to help send a powerful, creative message across Europe: We must stop fossil gas, oil and coal and move toward a fossil-free future. No matter your skill level, everyone is welcome. Whether you're sketching by hand, designing on a screen, or crafting a collage, we want to see your vision. 🎨 The 3 winning designs will receive:     A printed full-size poster of your artwork     50 postcards of your design     An exclusive Greenpeace campaign t-shirt   How to enter     Design your poster     Use any style you like – hand-drawn, painted, digital, collaged. Just make sure it’s original and fits our message.     Submit your design     Upload a photo or file using the form on this page. You’ll need to include your name and contact email.     Vote for your favourites     After the submission deadline, we’ll shortlist poster designs that you can vote for! Share the voting page with your friends so you have a better chance to win.     Your poster in the European Parliament and on the Arctic Sunrise The top-voted design will be sent to all members of the European Parliament as postcards. The three designs with the most votes will be printed as posters and postcards, and will be part of the Arctic Sunrise ship tour this fall. As a winner, you will get printed versions of your poster and a Greenpeace t-shirt.    Direct link: https://www.greenpeace.org/international/act/send-your-poster-design/?utm_campaign=fff-ban-new-fossil-fuel-projects&utm_source=hs-email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=fff-poster-design-contest-3rd-email-2025-07-20&utm_term=2025-07-20-poster-design-contest-3rd-email-button-2&global_project=fossil-free-future Time is running out! There are only 5 days left to submit your design for Greenpeace’s poster competition. This is your chance to help send a powerful, creative message across Europe: We must stop fossil gas, oil and coal and move toward a fossil-free future. No matter your skill level, everyone is welcome. Whether you're sketching by hand, designing on a screen, or crafting a collage, we want to see your vision. 🎨 The 3 winning designs will receive:     A printed full-size poster of your artwork     50 postcards of your design     An exclusive Greenpeace campaign t-shirt The deadline is 25 July 2025. After that, we’ll shortlist the top designs and the public will vote for the winners. Don't wait and join today! Join the competition now 
    • Perhaps the OP already has, hence her question?
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...