Jump to content

Let's rewrite the rules of football........The Penalty Goal - Proposal # 1


Recommended Posts

Would Maradona's handball in 1986 or Henry's handball against Ireland be viewed as cheating? I'd say yes.


Yes and no. Yes, in the same way that accepting a throw-in when you know the ball came off you last or accepting a free kick when you know the defender didn't contact you is technically cheating. The cases of a striker telling a ref to not give a penalty because no contact was made when he fell over his own feet can be counted on one hand. Possibly one finger.


But, no, in that both of those happened in the heat of battle and I suspect both were secretly surprised when no whistle sounded. There is a big difference to that and going down clutching your face when no contact was made. That is cheating.


There is a big difference between 'got away with it' and 'setting out to purposely con the ref'.

Ultimately it's the responsibility of the ref and his linesmen to spot these things....and if they can't, use video technology that can.


Also when you are a player you have less than a split moment to decide what you do. Players tend to develop patterns that they do without thinking, for example one player will always try and bypass a half tackle whereas another will always go down. You just don't have the time to think - do I bypass or do I go down? It's the same with hand balls mostly too. Yes the Uraguay player deliberately hand balled on the goal line but in his mind it was an instant reaction to his head saying 'goal coming' - a nano second thing.....it's not always the heinous crime that we think. If anything, his celebration of the missed penalty was the unsportmanlike behaviour.

Possibly Loz - but also there is a big difference in cheating that directly results in a goal Maradona/Henry and that which is trying to win a foul/have a player sent off. I see the former as more serious.


I'm not in the "cheeky chappie tries to get away with it" camp when handball results in a team going out of the world cup.


Other than technology/5th official we can't help Maradona moments, but we can do something about the Suarez handball, the solution seems obvious.

There is some irony there given the current discussion Simon. Although most people on this thread think handling the ball in football is not cheating.


I approve of rugby's rule making bodies - they make changes when they think fit and are not afraid to experiment and choose not to adopt rules that don't work. I prefer this to the "warts and all" attitude FIFA allow to prevail in its administration of the rules of football.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Community payback already exists   https://www.gov.uk/community-sentences/community-payback
    • Thanks for that - none  of mine  have been Mordena - whilst vulnerable cat, think I will just take my chances… Will be having flu though - certainly not by choice - much prefer not to but in vulnerable group.. Avoided them until last year…. Luck of drawer if you are as sick as fog  or just sore arm … assume - god knows - that flu jab is same throughout country.       
    • Wow, that is what it costs for one prisoner. So they get full board and lodging, 24 hour  monitoring  in over populated prison, we are led to believe, minimum exercise, assume a tv in each cell provided - in USA it is together with wash hand basin and c toilet - some have showers as well.   Clearly this amount of money takes  into account overstretched and overworked prison officers, protection for them, counselling which is, in my opinion a bare minimum dealing with prisoners in all settings. Do if Sweden can look outside the box, why can’t we? Or are we just not bothered at all / read statistics some where that reoffending is normal and to be frank, with economy as it is at the moment re employment, cost of living and homelessness..not surprised they reoffend to get back inside - food provided, roof over your head - much better than street living, mixing with wrong crowd, trying to get roof over your head, find a job where 90 % won’t employ you as been inside..
    • @beansprout The Swedes seem to have a useful strategy with regard to offenders  which has reduced repeat offending.  I agree that prison time for minor offences is a complete waste of time. Even worse is that prisons are "colleges of crime" where inmates learn about how to be do crimes and worst of all, become exposed to drug taking. I wouldn't advocate having chain gangs as in the USA but some strategy for getting them into say manual work under supervision might be useful - especially if it came with a modest wag. This would be significantly cheaper than the £51,100 it costs per year for  keeping one in jail.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...