Jump to content

Not many people appear to know this but Parmesan isn't vegetarian.


Recommended Posts

I?m not vegetarian and I don?t come from a vegetarian home but vegetarianism has never been something incomprehensible or strange. If someone says they?re vegetarian they don?t eat animals, end of, whether it is an oyster, fish or a yeti.

wee quinnie Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> On a related issue to my previous posting...

>

> If you think the cheese thing is nitpicking, it's

> really awful when you get to someone's gaff and

> they serve you fish or something because that's

> "vegetarian"! In case you're wondering, when it

> has happened to me, I haven't told them, and just

> eaten it....

>

> Obviously stupid of me to assume that people know

> what vegetarian means in the simplest form. Mind

> you, when I lived in Australia and told people I

> was veggie, quite commonly, the first question

> asked would be "Do you eat chicken?"!!!!


hi wee quinnie, totally agree with you. You'd think people would know what was truly vegetarian and what wasn't (esp restaurants, cookbooks and former mother-in-laws!) :)


How many times do I remember being served 'vegetarian' noodles with prawns, quiche, ( You can pick the ham out dear, that will be okay won't it? My ex's mum asked me, a look of horror on her face when I said, no).


Oh yes, has also been assumed ( when I was veggie) that fish and chicken is 'ok'! Er ... no!


Hate all those 'fake' meat products you seen now tho.

Sean, those people are NOT vegetarians. They may not be that fussy about what they eat, but I AM that fussy about the English language. I agree with Woof on the "don't eat meat" front - that's them, not "vegetarian" flibbertigibbets.

ISTR that Parmesan is an official EU designation that can only be used for cheese made according to a traditional recipe that uses animal rennet.


In which case, the vegetarian substitute (made from rennet obtained from fungi or genetically engineered micro-organisms) cannot be called 'Parmesan'.


A quick Google reveals many brands of vegetarian Parmesan-substitute.

woofmarkthedog Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Isinglass is collagen/gelatin which is gathered

> from the swim bladders of fish

>

> It's used to clarify wine & commonly known a

> "Filings"

>

> ( & not a carrot in sight )


W**f, I'd heard this was the case with bitters but not lagers. Never knew about wine though. Does it apply to both red and white do you know? If it applies to red then I can hardly call myself a vegetarian any more I suppose. I'm not giving up red!

ah yes that story - but that was more of a Clarkson type "joke" than an actual recipe


It's boorish and silly but I'm not sure it's factually:


" it was discovered that Gordon Ramsay's soup deemed suitable for vegetarians contained chicken stock,"

SeanMacGabhann Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Rosie - I basically agree with you and WQ about

> what constitutes a real vegetarian

>

> BUT

>

> I doubt Jamie Oliver would be publishing a book if

> it was only going to sell to real vegetarians.

> s'true...


Yes BUT if it's strictly vegetarian you don't have to be a vegetarian to use it. For the benefit of the wider audience you could also go on to say that people who have diets that approach vegetarianism for whatever reason will find it easier/simpler to describe themselves as vegetarians and I don't see anything wrong with that.


PS If it's got a non-vegetarian cheese in it the Vegetarian society would not deem it vegetarian, and surely that's a reasonable definition of vegetarianism.

I asked my brother (the only veggie) what he wanted to eat at the wedding breakfast of my recent nuptuals. His response was - the normal will be fine - just swerve the bacon and make sure there are some veggie sausages knocking around.

Rosie - don't make me go all Jack Nicholson on yo' ass


WQ - agree with you completely in your PS. But the point about the book, although obviously true is moot. There wouldn't be enough non-vegetarians who would buy the book to make it viable. I reckon anyway

SeanMacGabhann Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

>. But the

> point about the book, although obviously true is

> moot. There wouldn't be enough non-vegetarians who

> would buy the book to make it viable. I reckon

> anyway


Dunno about that. Delia Smith,(who charmingly mentions in the veggie section of her Complete Cookery course "that Hitler was..guess what a vegetarian!"), brought out a veggie compilation a few years ago which was pretty successful - AND she endorses that parmesan style cheese I mentioned in my opening post.

I like my mum's definition.


At a Rotary Club Dinner in rural Goucestershire, in the 80s, after politely turning down chicken and fish, she lost patience and said (very calmy and in her lovely RP accent)


"I'm a vegetarian. I don't eat anything that f*cks" *



*Now, I know some pedant will now point out that fish don't techincally f*ck (fertilisation of the eggs happens outside the fish) but if you take f*ck in this context to mean reproduce sexually (as in by fusion of male and female gametes)then it's not a bad definition.

annaj Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> *Now, I know some pedant will now point out that

> fish don't techincally f*ck (fertilisation of the

> eggs happens outside the fish)


Except for live-bearing species, in which the male impregnates the female by inserting his gonopodium into her 'vent' (i.e. where the babies pop out) :)

katie1997 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I'm cross posting too ...

>

> fish bladders used to make beers and wine ...

>

> also in lots of other products, not all use the

> seaweed substitute so yes, animal gelatine too.


Wine fining is an interesting one. There should be no trace of the fining agent left in the wine, but you are right, a dead animal product can be used in the process (though more often than not a non-animal fininf agent is used). Gelatine and blood have been used as a fining agents as has, for the vegans, egg whites (quite common).


As I said, no trace of animal protein should remain, but I suppose it depends on how rabidly PETA your vegetarianism/veganism is.

annaj Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I like my mum's definition.

>

> At a Rotary Club Dinner in rural Goucestershire,

> in the 80s, after politely turning down chicken

> and fish, she lost patience and said (very calmy

> and in her lovely RP accent)

>

> "I'm a vegetarian. I don't eat anything that

> f*cks" *

>

>

> *Now, I know some pedant will now point out that

> fish don't techincally f*ck (fertilisation of the

> eggs happens outside the fish) but if you take

> f*ck in this context to mean reproduce sexually

> (as in by fusion of male and female gametes)then

> it's not a bad definition.


As a proud pedant I'd also point out that a cow, minced into little pieces, formed into a hamburger and shoved into a bread bun is not, technically or otherwise, capable of f*cking anything but my cholesterol levels.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Thanks for posting this JMK we have had 3 children at Charter East so have been involved with the school from the very early days and have watched the impact of inconsistent, unsupportive and at worst unprofessional and biased management on them over the years. Individual teachers have at times been great and as JMK says it is the overall structure that creates a toxic and punitive atmosphere which directly impacts some families more than others and these are the kids overwhelmingly that have an SEN.  The experience of these families is night and day compared with the families with children that can cope in this system.  
    • Another recommendation for Lukasz, he sorted out our bifold door. He came at the agreed time, found the issue very quickly, adjusted it, all very carefully and with attention to detail. And he was very reasonably priced as well. 
    • Well sure someone will correct me but years ago, in Singapore and I was quite young so not sure if it is true. but if you were caught stealing, your little finger or just the  tip part with nail was chopped off.  Stigma for  life as all know that was punishment for stealing… no questions asked.Totally agree it is barbaric but equally putting people  into overcrowded prison for minor offences is also not right. Tagging I guess would not work or maybe does… no idea at all.  Not so long ago, heard a talk about how European’s cope/deal with prisoners and how the suggest rate is higher and offences lowered greatly as in not going back to prison for same  or another offence.  The general gist was their approach was each prisoner mattered , was heard and listens to and a suitable package was tailored towards their needs. Not  b one package for all. Not cooped up for the majority of the day - encouraged as an example to cook, garden, grow food, other household stuff  plus study if wanted for courses, languages etc. and mental health, dependency on substance abuse also addressed. Can’t remember if they were paid c pocket money which clearly accumulated or could be used to  I purchase whatever in prison. If they can do it by experimenting and I think but not sure, at the time an English prison was learning why can’t this sort of program be rolled  out throughout UK - cut backs not an excuse - think of the millions lost by govt during Covid…  Maybe it is - no experience in the matter at all.   
    • Why have things got so complicated? I suppose a cat flap with a timer might be useful for people out all day but can't really see the point of them when its so easy to flip a simple mechanical lock. This is how my last cat flap operated but had to be replaced when cat wearing cone of shame tried to escape and broke it. The cat flap I have now is one of those linked to cats microchip but even then there is just a four way dial which allows different kinds of access - or not. Not that cat is bothered, refuses to use it and demands i open the door for her. This is bit of a rant because along with a new boiler I got a new electronic programmer which is really annoying as it takes 5 minutes to change a simple temperature whereas with old programmer it took 10 seconds. Hope you get sorted @oglander and enjoy your future servitude to your feline master.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...