Jump to content

Recommended Posts

definition of crass: "adjective - showing no sensitivity"

I submit "If you don't like my comparison with cancer research, then tough." as evidence m'lud


Definition of explanation: "noun - a statement or account that makes something clear"


I submit "If those events are subsequently (even many years later) shown to have had a cause which was not "supernatural", that has no bearing whatsoever on any other unrelated event." as evidence m'lud.


Advice, stop digging.

El Pibe Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> definition of crass: "adjective - showing no

> sensitivity"

> I submit "If you don't like my comparison with

> cancer research, then tough." as evidence m'lud

>

> Definition of explanation: "noun - a statement or

> account that makes something clear"

>

> I submit "If those events are subsequently (even

> many years later) shown to have had a cause which

> was not "supernatural", that has no bearing

> whatsoever on any other unrelated event." as

> evidence m'lud.

>

> Advice, stop digging.


xxxxxxx


Yes - that would be my advice to you.


Plus to learn some elementary logic and then to apply it to what you write on here.

a) Some academic research into the subject has (and possibly still is) looking for evidence other than anecdotal.


b) El Pibe's argument:


Event x was thought by a person who experienced it to be paranormal. It was subsequently shown not to be.


Therefore events y and z, also thought by those who experienced them to be paranormal, WILL ALSO subsequently be shown not to be.


Fatal logical flaw.


ETA: And I'm sick of being patronised on here.I have done postgrad research and I'm not stupid.

Back on topic. Has anyone ever heard the story of the haunted boating lake area in Dulwich Park? Numerous people have mentioned seeing a lady in Victorian clothing walking around the boating lake very early in the mornings. Are there any people locally who have witnessed/heard of other peoples accounts on this particular ALLEGED (for the pedants on here) haunting?


Louisa.

I think we can all agree that there has been academic research on the subject, which has yielded no positive results. I think we can also agree that El Pibe's argument, if it were intended to disprove all paranormal observations (which it wasn't), would constitute a faulty generalisation.


We're still left with anecdotes vs grounded cynicism...

No love. I've made my arguments quite clear.

That was a hypothetical situation representative of the logic involved.


There is no evidence of supernatural (ghosts, goblins, gods) phenomena.

There is no evidence of paranormal (telekinesis, telepathy, prescience) phenomena.


Therefore any "explanations" of experiences are conjecture, based upon personal feelings and beliefs.


Until anyone provides a shred of evidence then I'll assume the real explanations of any experience to be mundane, based upon physical (or psychogical) reasons.


Take my ghost. I could have said "I know what I've seen and you're all close minded" but my instinct was to question my sanity.

Eventually it was explained perfectly well as as an acute sleep disorder. Bob's your uncle.


Again, until a fact is produced in support you've only your own logical fallacies, and complaints about personal insults (there were none) to fall back on.


So waiting, facts...

Dear Sue,


I posted again because some post were very eccentric. Being insulted by some one who thinks as you do is quite a compliment.


Cheers.








Sue Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Chick Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > This whole thread is barking.

>

> xxxxxx

>

> Charming as always.

>

> Closed-minded as always.

>

> Prejudiced as always.

>

> :(

>

> ETA: Guess you had to have another dig as nobody

> bothered to comment on your station "joke" on the

> first page?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Sounds like one for trading standards 
    • The Herne Hill Forum is raising money to replace the much-loved but decrepit wooden children’s trains outside Herne Hill station. The new train benches will be made of stainless steel with seasoned oak slats to sit on. The design is based on the Lord Nelson Class engines which passed through Herne Hill Station between 1926 and 1962 and the Pullman carriages in service at the same time. The trains will be painted green, the livery colour for Southern Railway in the 20s and 30s. Youngsters peering inside the carriages will glimpse some unexpected passengers: penguins commuting to work, an owl in a flap, a ghost on its way to Halloween, a fox and his friends, a heron migrating back to the hill and a bear checking tickets have all been smuggled on board. The carriages themselves will be clad with painted wooden boards for local artists and school children to repaint when necessary. The quality of the materials and the design should ensure the trains’ longevity but also come at a price. To cover the costs, the Forum has launched a crowd funding campaign and if all goes well, the new train benches should be installed by the spring.  Back the project here: https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/p/herne-hill-train-benches (Admin, we know this is not ED but we didn't feel it was right for the Lounge so have put it here, given many ED-ers use Herne Hill. Apologies if it's in the wrong place!)
    • Exactly. I had to then scale down the rest of the ingredients. It's happened twice that I know of. 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...