Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Lions 37-man squad

Backs: Lee Byrne, Rob Kearney, Shane Williams, Leigh Halfpenny, Ugo Monye, Luke Fitzgerald, Tommy Bowe, Tom Shanklin, Jamie Roberts, Brian O'Driscoll, Keith Earls, Riki Flutey, Ronan O'Gara, Stephen Jones, Mike Phillips, Harry Ellis, Tomas O'Leary.


Forwards: Jamie Heaslip, Andy Powell, David Wallace, Stephen Ferris, Alan Quinlan, Joe Worsley, Martyn Williams, Alun Wyn-Jones, Paul O'Connell (capt), Donncha O'Callaghan, Simon Shaw, Nathan Hines, Gethin Jenkins, Adam Jones, Andrew Sheridan, Phil Vickery, Euan Murray, Jerry Flannery, Lee Mears, Matthew Rees.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/6056-the-lions-announced/
Share on other sites

Ellis is certainly a good footballer but can he place kick? I'm not sure. Lee Byrne might be a better bet in that eventuality - his left boot is monstrous. But yes, I'm sure in the event of injuries we might be able to fly someone out. Just don't let it be Charlie Hodgson!


I'm worried mainly about the forwards tbh. With the exception of Habana (and he's been a bit ropey this last year) the SA backs don't scare me, but their forwards are terrifying. Botha, Spies and Burger are probably the best players in the world in their respective positions. I'm not sure any of the Lions players can claim that.


I'll be watching closely. Hopefully, given the lack of time differences between us and SA some ED pubs should be showing matches.

the place kicker concern is covered, i think, but just 2 fly halves doesn't seem enough. lions tours are becoming notorious for a spot of back-nobbling in the midweek game before the first test (par example) and one similar incident leaves us having a test game-plan that involves a no 10 wrapped in cotton wool.


the forwards appear to be a pack of bruisers, plain and simple. certainly likely to keep the traditional dirty springbok shinnanigans at bay, but if the boks decide to forget dirty fouling at the breakdown and break from the fringes, we could be in trouble. I think O'Connell and O'Callaghan can hold their own in the engine room, with a big scot on the bench if it needs more bulk, but the back row is the potential weak spot: agree that Croft is conspicuous in his absence, as is Ryan Jones, where as Worsley may have had a great 6 nations but his inclusion as a big-bosh merchant points to a gameplan not based on a mobile backrow - the same goes for Andy Powell, who I've personally never been a massive fan of. Any blind-side break of decent quality will involve simple man-for-man numbering off and then has Habana in waiting as the last man, and with any space at all I don't see lil'williams stopping him.



Still, McGeechan won the last tour to South Africa in '97 and took what looked like a strange squad at the time.

Only 2 specialist fly halves does seem a bit risky and I'm never keen at the idea of non-specialists covering that position (which presumably they will look to Flutey to do at a pinch). But they can always fly players out to join the tour, I suppose.


I would worry a bit at O'Callaghan starting. I like him and his physical approach but he seems to get into a lot of pointless scrapes at the moment. If he has a short fuse then he can expect to get some attention. Giving away penalties (esp at altitude) and yellow cards will be very costly. But then again I've got a soft spot for Simon Shaw and I can see him being an effective starter and then replaced at 50 mins or so. Hines and Wyn-Jones are good picks too. Second row is probably one of the few areas where the Lions have quality throughout.


I like Croft too but I don't think he is physical enough and the pack is picked to be very competitive and hard, rather than expansive. Ryan Jones' form has not been good enough of late to merit a pick, although he must have been close particularly given that Shane Williams hasn't been tearing up trees in 2009. Incidentally I can't see Williams starting, at the moment.


The squad highlights the problems in the domestic sides in that we're not blessed with a true openside other than Martyn Williams, a world class 9 or a 10 that offers a non-kicking game. It will be fairly grunty stuff, as bignumber5 says, with the pack being not particularly mobile, and the 10 kicking for territory. Can't blame the management though. In these days of professionalism chucking together 30 blokes and taking on a true Test side is not easy and certainly no place for Baa Baas style rugby.


Who would you pick in the centres and at front row? Tricky ones - Flutey was much improved during the 6 nations and he does create space in the manner that Darcy does for BOD. But arguably Roberts and Shanklin are the form centres! For the front row I think Sheridan is lucky to tour but I'd go for Gethin Jenkins and Murray propping with Flannery hooking (if he can keep his temper).


BBQs and Lions - bloody marvellous! We'll get hosed 3-0 but I'm looking forward to it nonetheless.


We should try and keep up the Lions banter through the tour.

afternoon, brendan - i wondered when you'd be along ;-)


not a bad idea about o'callaghan as a post-half time impact player, starting hines or shaw. only front row cert for me is gethin jenkins. will take everyone else on merit. back row seems to point towards Williams at 7 and Powell at 8, 6 up for grabs.


for the backline i'd like to see Ellis-o'gara-monye-flutey-o'driscoll-halfpenny-byrne as a link up of exceeding gas (maybe phillips for ellis) in an early provincial game. just to see. That's one of the things i love about the lions: if you agree with even part of the squad, it becomes like pub-talk fantasy-football type stuff, and you get to try all the options in the midweek games!

I think this Six Nations was pretty poor - I don't think there are any players in that Lions squad that will overly worry the Springboks. I don't see any match winners in the Lions. Maybe if it was last summer with an inform Shane Williams, Gavin Henson & Co but not this year. Unfortunately, I have to forecast a 3-0 beating.


Should be Saturday afternoon kick-offs so at least the games can be enjoyed with a beer rather than an orange juice..

  • 1 month later...

Bit of a bump...


So then fellas, excited about tomorrow? Almost possible to draw any conclusions from the first two or three games given the rotation that will happen. Nevertheless I am very excited. Could be a big rugby weekend with Super 14 final followed by the Lions, then Eng v Barbarians and some 7's thrown in too!


Looking forward to seeing Earls have an early chance - he's a talented lad. And hopefully Robinson will be raring to go and smashing through the gain line.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • I dont get complaining if nothing is broken? If you dont like the parcel service just buy your products elsewhere which ship with a different company. simple fix🤷‍♀️
    • It happened again tonight. This time a group of kids ( I hate saying that, because it makes them sound less intimidating than they are), threatened to throw a water bomb at me. When I dared them, they started lobbing them. Then they started saying they were going to kill my dog and one of them jumped over the fence of the Japanese Garden and took a running kick at my dog, who got out of the way. He jumped back over the fence, then came back, came within a meter of me and threw a water bomb really hard at me.  I can't be sure it was exactly the same crowd as last time, though I suspect the male ring leader could be.  The police came and were amazing - as was the park warden - and are fairly confident of the identity of one of them and think they may have tried to arrest him before.  There were maybe as many as 15 of them, aged 16-18, all Caucasian, girls and boys (girls being just as aggressive as the boys). The ring leader is a slight man, dark hair / eyes, possibly with facial hair about 5'6", petite, wearing an all-blue tracksuit.  So please be careful when you're in the park around 6.30 / 7pm. The local SNT have been informed. 
    • Hello, I have lots of jam jars and also bigger jars. Happy to swap for some plums. I'm home tomorrow afternoon or Friday during the day. I'm at 24 Blossom Court , Sumner Rd  SE15 6FU , tel 07958533429
    • But I don't think that was what you meant, was it? But he can hardly be held responsible for what somebody else did!
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...