Ko Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Dulwich Hospital was the last remaining > pavillion-style hospital in England. > > The Dulwich Society were involved in trying to get > English Heritage to list it (on two occasions I > believe). > > There were options to keep the onion towers AND > have the modern hospital, options which may have > been financially viable, but the PCT wanted to > take the easy route and just demolish it ASAP. > > Unfortunately, it was all about politics, rather > than what could have been the best result > all-round. It reminds me a bit of what is > currently happening with the Harris Boys Academy. > > However, at the end of the day we should get a > good modern hospital. Its just that they could > have had this AND kept more of the historic > building. A real waste. Two points: 1. Haslar Naval / Military Hospital is also a pavilion hospital and very grand it looks. Sadly about to be lost to the military and probabaly also to the local community as an NHS facility which is what is has also been for many years. 2. As someone inviolved in the hospital refurbishment / replacement programme for 15 years I have to tell you that it is unfortunately a fact that refurbishing an old Victorian building costs as much as, if not more, than knocking it down and building a brand new facility on the same site. Economics drives the decision makers not sentiment. Add to this economic fact the additional fact that building new allows staff to develop new models of care. delivery and provides more flexibility - beautiful Victorian buildings with long narrow corridors, small rooms, poor natural light and lousy energy efficiency just don't work for modern healthcare - and you can see why old is not cool for the NHS. A better deal for the Dulwich Hospital if we wanted to retain the architecture would have been yuppy flats / alternative business uses with a new building funded from the proceeds of the sale.