I won both of my appeals. One was on the grounds of bad signage. The other came down to the independent adjudicator believing there was no malice aforethought on my part. A friend also used the same argument recently, and won. These were judgments against Southwark, Westminster, and Tower Hamlets respectively. Rowanofski, your position doesn't sound strong to me, though in borderline cases I would say the adjudicator will lend a kind ear to an honest individual with a clear argument who feels strongly enough about things to wade through the appeal process and turn up to the hearing at a possibly unfriendly hour.