Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Cowardly probably not, but I do tend to think that unless mental illness is the cause, it is bloody selfish.

I have lost a friend to suicide, and he really had no control, he was experiencing severe delusions, and stepping in front of the train may have been the only we he could take control of his life, perversely.

I know a few others whose lost ones didn't have that excuse; the consequent pain, frustration guilt and anger never really go away, and that I find selfish, it's the ultimate **** you and last word rolled into one.

spadetownboy Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> wht is it being assumed this person suffered from

> depression,just because someone decides to take

> their life it dosent mean they suffer from

> depression or any type of mental illness for that

> matter. i do appreciate that sometimes it does go

> hand in hand but there are numerous other reasons

> why people commit suicide and not just because

> they are depressed.


Well said - clinically speaking, "depression" is a problem with serotonin reuptake at a presynaptic level, the mood being a direct result of that. It is possible to be extremely sad/low/lonely/isolated or any of the other frames of mind that would induce an individual to feel that suicide is their only option without being depressed. The assumption that low mood and suicidal ideation are only characteristic of clinical depression is a common assumption but a fundementally flawed one.


None of this makes it any less sad that that a life has ended, but I don't think it makes the location a "sad place". When I first qualified as a nurse I worked in cancer care - the wards where I was saw about one death per week, but they were places where some people found closure, and others found hope. Hey, if you live in one of the many Victorian conversions of ED then an elderly Victorian probably died in your home, as was the commonplace for advanced disease in that period. Your house is not a sad place because of this. As Mufasa says in the lion king, it's the circle of life!

I agree with you there Sean. I can think of three or four people that I knew who commited suicide years ago and the feeling is definitely one of anger at the selfishness of such an act in their cases apart from one. A friend of mine had a nervous breakdown and quite frankly went quickly downhill soon afterwards and was diagnosed as a paranoid schizoprenic. He hung himself at the age of 25. It was ten days before his body was discovered. It still fills me with great sadness as he was such a lovely bloke before his illness.

I suspect in a lot of / most cases the person doesn't really think about the people they're leaving behind at all. However, how can people call this selfish?!?!?!?


If you're in the sort of place where you're ready to take your own life, you haven't come to that conclusion lightly.

Without wanting to bring the whole day down... I cited 'cowardice' because people can't always face the consequence of their actions eg Fred West (one name that springs to mind). Again, I'm not saying that this person was culpable in any way, just that there are more reasons than depression for choosing this course of action.
But surely to take this course of action you must be depressed, whatever emotions, feelings or situations lead to you becoming depressed. We're not talking 'clinical' depression in the case of a chemical imbalance but a state of mind where one is despairing, sad, hopeless etc. Is that not depressed?

Maybe I phrased my sentence incorrectly when I said it would be a 'sad place'. It will be a place that will feel different to me. His soul will not have been a happy one. No one taking their own life can possibly leave on the earth a happy and full-filled soul; no matter how much they wanted to kill themselves.


And yes, elderly Victorians or indeed Victorians of any age have probably died in my house But then again, their deaths were before my time so I have no knowledge of them. Different to being in the park last night, to actually have run past the Japanese pagoda, only to find out the news this morning. That does make me sad. I can't remember seeing anyone, but it goes though my mind...did I pass him somewhere else in the park? Was he sitting on one of the benches, was he taking a walk down one of the avenues?....it makes me feel odd in a way I can't describe.

I think generally any selfish act, whatever it be, will have some rationalisation and justification behind it. That doesn't mean it isn't selfish.


I had to spend an entire christmas trying to persuade my own father from topping himself about 4 years ago. He's prided himself on being super-rational all his life and figured he had all the reasons why he should do it completely worked out.

The most goulish christmas day of my life was spent alone with him in his flat trying to keep the cons of each method well outweighing the pros, "think of the poor driver of the train, you wouldn't want to make another person suffer now would you" etc.


Eventually the treatment he was on was increased and he (more or less) regained his senses, but in his eyes he'd have been right in every way had he gone through with it.

Objectively of course it would have been a spectacularly selfish act leaving everyone else to pick up the tatters. He was rational enough to know that, but refused to see it no matter how much I pointed it out.

Like I say, selfish.

I once attended a training session on this subject by a psychotherapist. He put forward the thesis that actually when suicide was illegal on the grounds that it was "murder" it wasn't such a ludicrous suggestion. He suggested suicide was inevitably an act of agresssion - often towards a parental figure; so that in taking one's life, an act of revenge is undertaken. This was backed up by transcripts from his patients who revealed that their suicide fantasies included being watched by the parent as they killed themselves.

But that does not mean we should ever underestimate the pain these people are in. Or where their problem stems from.Sadly far too many people don't access the help they need - or indeed know what help is available to them, hence the tragic loss of life - both for them and those left behind.

See now that's just a bit nasty!


I'm still not sure I can go along with the selfish thing though. One could argue that it's selfish to expect someone to carry on their unhappy life just so you don't have to be sad...


I guess it's one of those things that's so awful, whichever way you look at it there are no winners, and there will be a lot of hurt.

Life isn't always happy bunnies. I can tell you right now I'm in a pretty s****y mood, but you persevere. The fact that dad pulled through shows that it would have been futile topping himself.

Read the book of Dave and it's pretty obvious that Will Self hit rock bottom and was suicidal at some point. But if he'd done it, given in to the idea of the futility of life, we wouldn't have had his quality contribution to Shooting Stars.


Genuine medical reasons aren't clear cut, particularly mental illness, severe depression and chronic (terminal) pain. I just say there but for the grace of god* go I, but to say "One could argue that it's selfish to expect someone to carry on their unhappy life just so you don't have to be sad" sounds a little flippant, especially if they come out the other side stronger for the experience.


All just my opinion obviously, I'm no expert in ethics, psychology or religion.


*or flying spaghetti monster

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • What was he doing on the stage at Glastonbury? Or on the stage at the other concert in Finsbury Park? Grinning like a Cheshire cat whilst pissed and stoned 20 somethings on the promise of free internet sung-- Oh Jeremy Corbyn---  What were his policies for Northern mining towns with no jobs or infrastructure? Free Internet and university places for youngsters. What were his other manifesto pledges? Why all the ambiguity over Brexit?  I didn't like Thatcher, Blair or May or Tony but I respected them as politicians because they stood by what they believed in. I respect all politicians across the board that stick to their principles. Corbyn didn't and its why he got  annihilated at the polls. A socialist, anti imperialist and anti capitalist that said he voted for an imperialist and pro capitalist cabal. He refused to say how he'd vote over and over again until the last knockings. He did so to appease the Islington elite and middle class students he was courting. The same people that were screaming that Brexit was racist. At the same time the EU were holding black and Asian immigrants in refugee camps overseas but not a word on that! Corbyn created and courted a student union protest movement that screamed at and shouted down anyone not on the left . They claimed Starmer and the centre right of labour were tories. He didn't get elected  because he, his movement and policies were unelectable, twice. He turned out not to have the convictions of his politics and died on his own sword.    Reform won't win an election. All the idiots that voted for them to keep out Labour actually enabled Labour. They'll be back voting tory next time.    Farage wouldn't be able to make his millions if he was in power. He's a very devious shyster but I very much doubt he'd actually want the responsibility that governance requires.
    • The purge of hard left members that were part of Corbyn's, Mcdonnel's and Lansmans momentum that purged the party of right wing and centrist members. That's politics. It's what Blair did to win, its what Starmer had to do to win. This country doesn't vote in extreme left or right governments. That's partly why Corbyn lost  We're pretty much a centrist bunch.  It doesn't make it false either. It's an opinion based on the voting patterns, demography and statistics. Can you explain then why former mining constituencies that despise the tories voted for them or abstained rather than vote for Corbyns Labour?  What is the truth then? But he never got elected!!! Why? He should have been binned off there and then. Why he was allowed to hang about is an outrage. I hold him party responsible for the shit show that we've had to endure since. 
    • Depends on what the Barista says doesnt it? There was no physical confrontation with the driver, OP thinks she is being targetted when she isnt. These guys work min wage under strict schedules so give them a break unless they damage your stuff
    • CPR Dave, attendance records are available on Southwark's website. Maggie Browning has attended 100% of meetings. Jon Hartley has attended 65%.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...