Jump to content

Who is the greatest lyricist?

Peckhamgatecrasher

By Peckhamgatecrasher
in The Lounge

 Share

Recommended Posts

HonaloochieB

HonaloochieB

Posted
Posted

SteveT Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> PGC wrote:- Donovan? As in haunting, profound,

> heart-wringing?

>

> "First there is a mountain then there is no

> mountain then there is."

>

>

> Well yes, I thought he was worthy of a mention if

> only because of 'Colours' even though he was a

> drug imbibing 'head'.

>

> Chuck Berry is responsible for many big hits over

> a lifetime Johnny B Good and Roll over Beethoven,

> to name but a few.


Quite right SteveT, Chuck Berry is a wonderful musician and a lyricist par excellence, as it were.

But not perhaps the nicest of individuals who ever walked the earth, and I suppose why should he be?

Read his autobiography, it's amusing at times, but as dreadfully self-serving a tome as it's possible to write.

That whole, taking an under-age girl over county lines? A bit of a misunderstanding is all.


As Keith Richards (who not just idolised him, but pretty well built a career around him) remarked after he worked with him on the 'Hail Hail Rock 'n' Roll' film "I couldn't warm to the man if I was cremated with him".

PeckhamRose

PeckhamRose

Posted
Posted

Yes I have most of Joe Jackson's albums. Classics of their time. Interesting anecdote there HB!


And we have not had the wonderful lads from fIREHOSE ex Minutemen, yet, with the lyrics

"I am aware there are definite errors in my thinking. Example? Knowing I can't know."


And of course the whackily beautiful David Byrne "This is not my beautiful wife!"

*Bob*

*Bob*

Posted
Posted

first mate Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I have a question- why can't women write good

> lyrics? Or can they? If they can why no mention of

> any here?

>

> Answers? Theories?



No reason to expect the world of songwriting to be any different to any other kind of workplace.


That said, I'd guess that a majority of people prefer male 'voices' (ie both the words and the actual voices) in songs to female. They just do. Women are drawn to men for obvious reasons. And a lot of men just feel more comfortable with men singing.. perversely, even if they're singing (as they often are) about crying, love and other hurty stuff,


There's an A-level essay in there somewhere for someone.

Alec John Moore

Alec John Moore

Posted
Posted
If you twist my arm I'd have to settle for Joni Mitchell. Just because it is so hard to settle on one songwriter whose words have penetrated your consciousness in a telling way and she has such lyricism. However, that was a long time ago and far away. Currently? I'm listening to Elbow and some of their words seem quite apposite: "There's a hole in my neighbourhood down which of late I cannot help but fall." Could that be EDF? I feel a new thread coming on.
PennyDreadful

PennyDreadful

Posted
Posted

first mate Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I have a question- why can't women write good

> lyrics? Or can they? If they can why no mention of

> any here?

>

> Answers? Theories?


I mentioned Rennie Sparks of the Handsome Family - she's female (just has a deceptive name)!

But you've made a good point.

PeckhamRose

PeckhamRose

Posted
Posted

Good point.


So - Joan Armatrading.

Minnie Ripperton (did she write 'Lovin' You'?)

Janis Ian


All in my LP collection!


Corrine Bailey Rae, not, but I like her.


And let's big it up for that quiet shy type who nevertheless wrote a few great songs - Courtney Love.

????

????

Posted
Posted
But easties has some point in that in the main I like rock/pop music for the tunes and Some of the narrative....in reality, with a few exceptions, without the music the lyrics are poor and often pretentious, within a song they often work...I think Bowie is a good example of this say.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
  • Advertise Here

  • Latest Discussions

    • civilservant
      Excellent Christmas meal at Franklins!

      By civilservant · Posted

      thanks Jenijenjen and all - yes, i remember walking or taking the bus from the elephant (where i was working) to Camberwell to get there.  I think Tim - who's still at Franklin's -  was there in those days, and the woman who ran the cafe!  Other food places that i remember fondly are the ones in Neal's Yard (with the Hunkin sculpture that you could put a coin in ) and the basement lunch place at the Tottenham Court Road junction with Hanway Street... 
    • Sue
      Dawson Heights again

      By Sue · Posted

      Did you try the emergency number posted above? It mentions lift breakdowns over the festive period outside the advertised  times. Hope you got it sorted x
    • Sue
      Be careful in local shops

      By Sue · Posted

      People working in shops should not be "attempting to do the bill in their head." Nor if questioned should they be  trying to "get to an agreeable number." They should be actually (not trying to) getting to the correct number. I'm afraid in many cases it is clearly more than incorrect arithmetic. One New Year's Eve in a restaurant (not in East Dulwich but quite near it) two of us were charged for thirty poppadoms. We were quite merry when the bill came, but not so merry as to not notice something amiss. Unfortunately we have had similar things happen in a well established East Dulwich restaurant we no longer use. There is also a shop in East Dulwich which is open late at night. It used not to display prices on its goods (that may have changed). On querying the bill, we several times found a mistake had been made. Once we were charged twice for the same goods. There is a limit to how many times you can accept a "mistake".  There is also a limit to how many times you can accept the "friendly" sweet talking after it.
    • malumbu
      Bitey Fox.

      By malumbu · Posted

      Adapted not forced.  As have numerous species around the world.  Sort of thing that Attenborough features.  Domestic dogs another good example - hung around communities for food and then we become the leader of the pack.  Not sure how long it will take foxes to domesticate, but some will be well on their way.    Raccoons also on the way https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1j8j48e5z2o

East Dulwich Forum

Established in 2006, we are an online community discussion forum for people who live, work in and visit SE22.

Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...