Jump to content

Recommended Posts

OK, after an almighty mess caused by two politicians that just refused to talk to each other, surely new elections are the way forward. The Catalonian guy just has to use it as a referendum. If he wins, the Spanish PM is going to look like he's made a massive political miscalculation.


But it leads to so many questions.


- if the PM was so confident in the majority of Catalonians wanting to stay, why did he violently stop the referendum?


- if the Catalonian leader is so confident in the majority of Catalonians wanting to go, why doesn't he grab this new opportunity for a pseudo-referendum?


Personally, I think Catalonia would have been mostly happy with a bit more autonomy but it has now turned into a stupid game of brinkmanship.


As a side issue, I think it is a complete human rights violation that any constitution does not allow a region to break away, should they democratically (with a qualified majority) choose to do so.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/
Share on other sites

Well as we found out last year, a referendum has a tendency to lead to more problems than it solves. The binary nature of such a complex question cannot hope to cover all the issues.


In terms of Catalonia specifically, it's a funny one if viewed by outsiders. I've known a few Catalonians and I don't think most Brits would understand their fervent desire to be an independent nation. The sense of nationhood as Catalonians that runs through them is deep and abiding. I don't really understand why they wanted a referendum, because I can't see how they would be better off independent, but that goes straight back to the point I just made; a lot of us don't. However, I accept that many of them do.


The referendum was a terrible move, because Spain refused to recognise its legitimacy; ergo, it's no more valid than me asking three people outside Londis if they favour independence for SE22, getting two 'yes' votes, and promptly declaring seccesion from the UK. Hyperbole on my part maybe, but it makes my point - a referendum that is not recognised by higher authority is nothing more than a PR stunt.


Where Spain goes from here, I have no idea. I can't imagine it coming to violence, but then I don't see it being resolved amicably either. Likely the will thrash it out round the negotiating table, but yes, it's already gone farther than it should've.


Regarding the issue of any constitution allowing regions to break away, hmmm...I agree and disagree. How far can it go? Isn't the logical end of that collections of fiefdoms and city states? Would what became Germany (Prussia, technically) and Italy have been better of if Bismarck and Garibaldi never tried to unify them? Would the USA be better if Texas and California went through on their occasional threats to secede? Should Quebec really be ruled by Paris?


Ultimately we are stronger united than divided, and its human nature to band together in tribes. Yes, I think on the whole I agree that any constitution needs an opt-out clause, but they need to be really carefully written, and therein lies the danger.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189479
Share on other sites

JoeLeg Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> Ultimately we are stronger united than divided, and its human nature to band together in tribes.

> Yes, I think on the whole I agree that any constitution needs an opt-out clause, but they

> need to be really carefully written, and therein lies the danger.


Oh, I agree fully. Thus my 'qualified majority' stipulation. Anything of this magnitude (and like Brexit) should require an increased majority - say 60% or even two-thirds. That was Cameron's big mistake.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189517
Share on other sites

Spanish politics is not as clean as it is here, centrally or regionally. Both sides have been stubborn and unimaginative. The separatists' leaders may claim a pure, higher moral ground but they are - to an extent - taking advantage of latent nativism and legitimate regional pride (in language, culture, etc.) in their voter base to get what they want. The idea that Catalonia will become EU country 29 anytime soon is far-fetched because Brussels won't let it happen.
Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189606
Share on other sites

Loz Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> - if the PM was so confident in the majority of

> Catalonians wanting to stay, why did he violently

> stop the referendum?

>


Most of the "unionists" (or whatever the official name is) didn't

vote as advised by their parties as it was an illegal referendum

in their view.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189743
Share on other sites

How was it illegal? The Catalan government was elected democratically and they decided to have the referendum. Surely the Madrid government should respect this and have stayed out of trying to disrupt it. It looks like they were more worried about losing the referendum than a democratic result being arrived at.
Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189767
Share on other sites

EDOldie Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> How was it illegal?



From The Guardian...


Q&A

Why does the Spanish government say the Catalan referendum is illegal?



The Spanish government argues that any referendum on Catalan independence would be illegal because the country?s 1978 constitution makes no provision for a vote on self-determination.


The Spanish constitutional court, which has suspended the referendum law pushed through the Catalan parliament in September, is looking into whether the law breaches the constitution.


In March this year, the former Catalan president Artur Mas was banned from holding public office for two years after being found guilty of disobeying the constitutional court by holding a symbolic independence referendum three years ago.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189770
Share on other sites

EDOldie Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> How was it illegal? The Catalan government was

> elected democratically and they decided to have

> the referendum. Surely the Madrid government

> should respect this and have stayed out of trying

> to disrupt it. It looks like they were more

> worried about losing the referendum than a

> democratic result being arrived at.


The Scottish referendum was agreed by the UK parliament the Catalonia referendum was not (and at present couldn't be) agreed by the Spanish parliament. So any country recognising Catalonia agrees a precedent is set.


If this precedent was set then a lot of provinces etc. could unilaterally work towards independence.


I'd say get a referendum that is recognised by all sides (which means changing Spanish law).

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189786
Share on other sites

Nigello Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> By clean, I meant corruption-wise. You have to

> agree that the UK is, relatively speaking, freer

> of the kind of corruption that plagues Spain,

> Italy, former Soviet Bloc countries, etc. True, it

> must exist but it is of a scale and type that is

> different.


Actually global anti-corruption campaigners frequently rank the UK as the most corrupt nation on earth, because the City of London and the property market are used to launder trillions of dollars of crime money each year with successive governments afraid to challenge it for fear of upsetting vested interests. It is true that we don't have to suffer the low-level corruption endemic in other countries and cultures - bribing policemen not to ticket us etc - but until we've cleaned up the financial sector it ill behoves us to give ourselves too many pats on the back.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189790
Share on other sites

JohnL Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Loz Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

>

> > - if the PM was so confident in the majority of

> > Catalonians wanting to stay, why did he violently

> > stop the referendum?

> >

>

> Most of the "unionists" (or whatever the official name is) didn't

> vote as advised by their parties as it was an illegal referendum

> in their view.


Not quite an answer to my question.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189881
Share on other sites

Loz Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> JohnL Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > Loz Wrote:

> >

> --------------------------------------------------

>

> > -----

> >

> > > - if the PM was so confident in the majority

> of

> > > Catalonians wanting to stay, why did he

> violently

> > > stop the referendum?

> > >

> >

> > Most of the "unionists" (or whatever the

> official name is) didn't

> > vote as advised by their parties as it was an

> illegal referendum

> > in their view.

>

> Not quite an answer to my question.



No idea - logically better to ignore it. Machissmo maybe.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1189889
Share on other sites

Loz Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> JohnL Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > Rumours Catalan President has flown to Brussels

> > (in exile)

> >

>

> Rebellion, sedition, and provocation charges?

> Ridiculous. If a Catalan equivalent of ETA rise,

> they will only have the Spanish PM to blame.


Quite - and such a group could be far larger and better funded than ETA ever was.


The Spanish PM's judgment is questionable, I think (quite apart from his well known love of the torturing of bulls to death for entertainment). Instinctively he seems to prefer macho displays of strength and power. I hope he at least has learnt a lesson from the backlash which came from when he sent in the thugs for the 'referendum'. Violence is far more likely to trigger further violence.


I imagine Nicola Sturgeon is now appreciating that Spain meant what it said about vetoing Scotland being admitted to the EU, had Scotland left the UK. Spain is extremely sensitive about this subject because of the separatist movements in the Basque, Galician and Catalan provinces.

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/172118-catalonia/#findComment-1190166
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Here you are, intexasatthemoment (you seem to have been in Texas for a very long time!) We went to three of the recommended places yesterday,  as they were all in the same road (just near Wallington)  and I needed to give the car a run to avoid another slap on the wrist from my garage (and another new battery). Here's my findings. BARNES Parking We thought we would go here first as it was the earliest to close on a Sunday (3pm). There was no apparent entrance or anywhere to park. One notice said do not park on grass verge, and another one said staff cars only! Flittons was opposite but I'd already passed the entrance, so I had to drive down the road, turn round at the next available place (covered in signs saying do not park here) and park in Flittons car park! Plants Barnes  specialise in hardy perennials, so that was basically what they had, but an excellent selection, and many more unusual plants (or at least, plants you probably wouldn't find in a garden centre), eg Corydalis,  lots of different varieties of Epimediums, Trollius, some lovely Phygelius, lots of different ferns). The plants were divided into sections according to whether they needed sun or shade or could cope with both. They had a particularly good selection of  shade loving plants. There was really useful information above  each group of plants, which meant you didn't have to look at individual labels. All the plants looked in good health and  very well cared for. They don't produce a printed catalogue, but they  said their plant list was online (I haven't looked yet). I assume most of  the plants they have at any one time are when it's their flowering season (if they flower). I wasn't intending to buy anything, though was very tempted, but I'd definitely go here again once I've sorted out my overgrown garden. Other Stuff Don't think they sell pots, compost, etc. No cafe/tea room and I didn't see a loo, but Flittons is just over the road. FLITTONS  Parking Easy to park Plants Sorry, but mostly terrible. There was one section with vegetables and the rest was flowering plants. There was a general feeling of delapidation. Some of what was on display was actually dead (surely it would only take a minute to remove dead plants) and a lot of the rest was very poorly maintained, eg gone to seed, weedy, apparently unwatered, or with a lot of dead leaves. There was a notice asking for volunteers to work there, so I can only assume they can't afford to pay staff. Other stuff There was a notice to a play barn (?) saying invited people only, so I think they must host kids' parties or something. They redeemed themselves with a cosy little cafe with savoury stuff, nice cakes, iced chai and oat milk, and a loo. Also a selection of books and CDs on sale for charity. If you want an Andrews Sisters CD, you can find one here. There is a small shop with gift shop type stuff and a display of the history of Flittons, which apparently is family owned since the sixties (I think it was). I suspect that the arrival of Dobbies down the road must have greatly affected Flittons' fortunes, which is sad. DOBBIES  Parking Easy in theory once you had navigated a rather narrow entrance, but it was very busy so it took a while to find a space. Plants  Lots of plants, well maintained but I imagine their turnover is high. Lots of nice bedding plants for hanging baskets, window boxes etc  to cater for all tastes (ie some of it wasn't mine, but fine if you like those horrid little begonias (my opinion only) but they did have some nice (in my opinion) stuff as well. I was tempted but decided to buy from North Cross Road market. Fair selection of climbers, various different Clematis etc. I'd be happy to buy plants from here. The prices seemed reasonable and they were in good condition. Other stuff  It's a big garden centre with all that entails these days, so a large area selling garden furniture and storage, tools, animal collars, pots, all the usual stuff you would expect. Very helpful staff. There's a cafe which we didn't check out, charging points for electric cars, a Waitrose (no idea how big, we didn't look). Only on our way out did we see that there was a drive through "express section" for compost etc, which was annoying as I wanted compost and hadn't seen any anywhere,  but I was getting tired by that time. Just Down the Road A ten minute drive away is Wilderness Island, a nature reserve in Carshalton, which is well worth a visit. We heard eleven different kinds of bird (according to Merlin) and saw a Kingfisher flying down the tiny river!
    • The swifts & bats are alive & well around Upland Road. A beautiful sight & sound in the evenings. Just be sure to leave plenty of water out for them, as they are at high risk of dehydration & struggle to take flight at ground level.
    • Loads in upland road last night…
    • We saw quite a few yesterday evening  while sitting in the garden (Ulverscroft Road) (plus a bird of prey which hopefully wasn't after the swifts). The life of a swift is absolutely amazing, as is the distance they travel in a lifetime! I googled it last night!
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...