Jump to content

Recommended Posts

i stopped a man wearing a white poppy yesterday in peckham ,i hadnt seen them for years i was beginning to think id dreamt them .......he got them in hausmanns bookshop in kings cross ,they mark and remember the loss of human life in war but do not condone war they say peace in the middle he kindly gave me one :] but good on you poppy man

It does, but also because they flourished in the churned and untilled fields after the war, symbolising both the loss of blood and renewal/hope for the future. The white poppy emphasises peace for the future.


This poem had much to do with it too.


In Flanders fields the poppies blow

Between the crosses, row on row,

That mark our place; and in the sky

The larks, still bravely singing, fly

Scarce heard amid the guns below.


We are the Dead. Short days ago

We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,

Loved, and were loved, and now we lie

In Flanders fields.


Take up our quarrel with the foe:

To you from failing hands we throw

The torch; be yours to hold it high.

If ye break faith with us who die

We shall not sleep, though poppies grow

In Flanders fields.


John Mcrae

I have never heard of a white poppy before, and certainly never thought that wearing a red poppy means that you are seen to condone war... surely something that noone in their right mind would do. For me the point of the poppy is to remember those who made the ultimate sacrfice for us, as well as those we were injured etc, in wars and to provide support for them or their families. The point of the white poppy, as it says on the website above, is to

'symbolise the belief that there are better ways to resolve conflicts than killing strangers'
Therefore aren't they are serving two different purposes... and two purposes which are not mutually exclusive - you can believe that there are better ways of resolving conflicts than killing people, as well as wanting to show your gratitude and provide support to the people and their families who have made such sacrfices for our benefit... The red poppies raise money to help those people and, whilst i fupport what the white poppy stands for, I would worry if they were to take away from that as it seems invaluable...

*Bob* Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Does anybody find the white poppy thing

> annoying/offensive?


Not so much annoying as uninformed.


I believe the traditional red poppy fulfills both stated aims - remembrance and a desire to avoid future conflict. Certainly never, never to celebrate or applaud war.


I've not yet met a soldier / sailor or airman that looks back on their war as something to be recommended. They may have pride in what they achieved, sadness for friends lost and wounded, nightmares about waht they saw / did - but never something they would want their sons, daughters, friends or others involved in again.


Neverthless in the best traditions of liberty - I applaud anyone's right to say what they wish - even if I don't agree with it.

I've long said to people that if you want to understand the emotional power of the Service of Remembrance, try to attend it in a military chapel. The Flowers of the Forest, The Last Post, and the Reveille, surrounded by old troopers and their colours, will stay in your heart forever.
I know what you mean. When I was growing up we would go to the service at the MOTH chapel with the veterans who would sing the hymns and play the last post etc. It was very moving. It is probably one of the things that has made me grow up to be of the opinion that remembrance day should be a reminder to us that war should be avoided at all costs.
Growing up in the 60's and 70's war was mostly glamorised on the TV, Cinema and in various war cartoon books so the true awfulness never really hit home. Then as an Air Cadet, Remembrance weekend and the various parades were a big thing but largely because as a 14 year old it meant access to beer at the NAAFI afterwards! Reading "Birdsong" had a much bigger impact on me and IMO really sums up what Remembrance is all about. Schools should introduce it in English or History perhaps.

hello

hey im sorry if i appear uninformed or self indulgent i hope im neither ......i just didnt express my self very well? but thanks mockney piers for the mc crae poem

and i any one is interested 'the regeneration trilogy 'by Pat Barker is a truly astounding work . i wish id never mentioned white poppies !

at least it started some debate

ps im wearing white and red poppies on my coat .

and i am againt war and 'killing strangers as a way of resolving conflict'

luddite Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> hello

> hey im sorry if i appear uninformed or self

> indulgent i hope im neither ......i just didnt

> express my self very well? but thanks mockney

> piers for the mc crae poem

> and i any one is interested 'the regeneration

> trilogy 'by Pat Barker is a truly astounding work

> . i wish id never mentioned white poppies !

> at least it started some debate

> ps im wearing white and red poppies on my coat .

> and i am againt war nd iling straners as a way o

> resolving conflict


Anything that keeps this debate in people's minds is a good thing. I attended a REmembrance Day Parade today - over 1000 people, many serving and retired personnel. What was very marked was the number of medals worn by people much younger than I am. It was a measure of the numer of wars and conflicts that our servicemen and women have been involved in over the last 15 years - and in contrast to similar parades in the 70's and 80's when only retired WWI, WWII & Korean War vererans had medals.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Miranda Sawyer of the (once) Observer has done a piece on festival on Insta which might be of-interest.  Councils are private companies, imo. They make money for themselves, imo.  I do not think by law that they have to follow anything brought up by a consultation, this is for 'face' only - hence, LTNs and everything else.  
    • My understanding is the "free event" is 100% Gala, nothing to do with the council. Obviously Gala will still make money from the food & drink that they are trying to coerce punters into buying on their social media posts. Their costs will be negligible due to already having the infrastructure in place for Gala. So Gala are trying to appear community minded by providing this "free event", but the real goal is to set a precedent for a fourth day's festival - which surely no one could possibly object to?!? - in preparation for applying (again) for two three-day festivals spread over two weekends. It's only another two days, right, and the site & equipment is already there, so why would anyone object?!? More money for the council, much more money for Gala, win-win right? But yet another week of our park taken away from us, too, and another 18,000 people trampling & littering the park, and another week of disturbance for the native birds & wildlife...
    • Meson Don Felipe on The Cut was my go to place for many years. Though it's now many years since I was there. 10-15 minute walk from the Tate. If you go can you tell me what it's like nowadays?
    • Doubt you would have got much change out of £150.00 for battery and certainly having forked out for it, best to use your car. I recently sold  my car via webuyanycar.com - very pleasant experience & was roughly what I was expecting. Pop your bangers reg jnto their website to get an idea of price - they do send e mails once a fortnight/month just as an aid for you. Easy enough to delete - don’t even have to read valuation. They literally buy any car - if you can’t get it to them, they will charge you to get it there or recommend a co that will do it for you. Must say, mine was a 2014 reg and whilst a bit suspicious, paid extra to get money into my account as needed it for next car but was assured funds had I not gone down route I took would be in my account within 5 days. I now live in the country - every time I have been back to Dulwich and surrounding area, normally get a fine for driving at wrong time or parking at  wrong time so if I drive now, park in West or East Dulwich and do everything else by public transport and walking.  Were I still to be living in ED then before I left was pondering this very issue but since I have been back regularly for health reason I no longer drive but take the train and then buses, walk or Uber. Much cheaper than running a car and had I stayed, that would have been the course I would have taken. I don’t go out everyday, have an allotment or job to go to or family so in my case, would be cheaper not to have a car.  Was truely shocked   at the cost of second hand cars…..but where I now live only has a smattering of buses so no choice but to have wheels to get from A to B etc.          
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...