Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Evening,


Just came back from a protest that was happening outside the Zippo Circus Peckham Rye.

The protest was against the treatment of horses (making them stand on two legs gives them hip and tendon damage / pain).


The scary stuff was actually the lack of freedom that there was to protest. There was a group of 6 police men with a van. They were all very friendly - however our freedom of speech amounted to:

- no banners - no pictures - protesting in an area away from the entrance in a 5 metre by 5 metre space - the threat of instant arrest if a member of public complained about us / said they had been harassed or disturbed.


For someone who would never wish to be arrested or cause any disturbance I was quite shocked by this and left immediately - I wouldn't want to risk losing my job, even though I strongly believe animals shouldn't be abused for human profit.


Any sensible thoughts on this?


Thomas

I can understand where these protesters are coming from. For example, I believe fox hunting is banned in this country as well as bull fighting in Spain. What I don't get is why now? Zippos Cirus has been entertaining audiences around this side for years. Seems out of the blue to me.

If you aren't happy than make a complaint to the police complaints commission. I hope you got the number/s of the policemen.


But I have to say, I think you should be kept away from the entrance. There is a line between protest and harassment, and parking your protest at the entrance counts as the latter in my book. But I am very surprised they can have a 'no banners' rule, especially if you were away from the actual area that the circus has rented.

It's quite right that you were kept away from the entrance. Loz is right, chanting/shouting while people entered would be bordering on harassment.


I totally respect your right to protest, and I admire the way you take a stand against something you feel is wrong, but at the same time you have to realise that most people don't have a problem with performing horses in a circus.

It's frightening the extent to which the right to protest has been systematically attacked in this country. Did the police say they had issued a Section 30?


If I get down there tomorrow I may do so as a legal observer. Clearly the police saw this protest as a soft target for their threats.

Wow so many people have time to and love a good moan about things which should be poitive on here.....local butchers, children' entertainment, shops closing, shops opening7!!!

I say supprt the local shops, support local kida entertainment, etc

Is there much of a difference between horses performing in a circus and dressage as an olympic sport? Come Brazil horses will need to be air freighted over, which from the little I know (knowledge taken from a a 1980s TV movie) they find very stressful. Where to draw the line?

Where are you getting your information that Circus performance causes tendon damage?


Should people also protest against the Lipizzaner horses?


What about military/royal horses? They commonly develop spavin and degenerative joint disease. [information presented in a lecture series on veterinary imaging techniques at University of Wales, Aberystwyth: Institute of Rural Sciences, 2007]


Equids in Britain, whether they be working animals or companions, have some of the highest legal standards of care of any equids in the world. If you really want to make a difference to the lives of equids, why not spend your time and money volunteering for an organisation which treats working animals overseas in poor communities, where the lives of animals also make a difference to the lives of people? Seriously, working horses in Britain have an easy life compared to these: http://www.wspa.org.au/wspaswork/workinghorses/Default.aspx . Put in your energy where it will really make a difference. xx

Thanks guys.


Use of horses in sport / circus etc is the least of 'animal rights' worries, but still something I would take action on. Steveo's argument is like saying why bother acting against graffiti when we have people stabbed to death?


No police there today, and people flyering against the circus - perhaps the police just wanted to make their presence felt early on.


I would never chant or shout at a member of the public, thats not the way to get a message across and is disrespectful.


Not sure re. Section 30, what is that? The police said they do have the power to ban the protest outright, but were there to 'facilitate it.'



Thanks for the discussion,

Tom

The Zippo's horses do appear to be in good condition and therefore I would assume they are well cared for.

However what bothers me, is the amount of time they spend on the road in trailers, being transported from one venue to

another, and therefore they have limited freedom to be outdoors, grazing in paddocks.

Then again, is this any worse than race horses, eventers, hunters, show ponies, etc being transported from one competition/meeting to another. Not sure.

Thomas, Zippo's horses are extremely well cared for. Police horses work and travel more than Zippo's horses.


Two years ago I had the misfortune to run into a protestor as I went to the circus. I gave extremely good pointers as to why the horses at the circus are not being subjected to cruelty, in a polite manner. As I walked away the ignorant and rude woman had the audacity to say to me 'thank you for supporting cruelty to animals.' I then gave the stupid woman a dressing down on what defines cruelty (heard by all in the park no doubt) and suggested she go and stand outside Brixton nick where they keep horses (or at least used to) and try her luck there.


There is no doubt that creulty to animals exists but these protestors are extremists who quite frankly have picked the circus because it's an easy target.


What does your photo show Thomas? A well groomed horse in a stable, because believe it or not that's what most horses sleep in. What your photo doesn't show is the fenced paddock area behind the stable where the horses have time every day to run around freely. Have you ever been to a riding school Thomas? Or any kind of farm where horses are kept? Stables and a paddock is pretty common accomodation for horses. And horses that train for dressage for example, carry out way more complex training and routines that what you'll see at Zippo's circus (as others have posted on this thread). The horses at most, travel twice a week (again not very much by the standards of working horses). Get a sense of perspective for goodness sake.


I will be going to the circus tm. Maybe I'll protest against stupid protests ;)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • While it is good that GALA have withdrawn their application for a second weekend, local people and councillors will likely have the same fight on their hands for next year's event. In reading the consultation report, I noted the Council were putting the GALA event in the same light as all the other events that use the park, like the Circus, the Fair and even the FOPR fete. ALL of those events use the common, not the park, and cause nothing like the level of noise and/or disruption of the GALA event. Even the two day Irish Festival (for those that remember that one) was never as noisy as GALA. So there is some disingenuity and hypocrisy from the Council on this, something I wll point out in my response to the report. The other point to note was that in past years branches were cut back for the fencing. Last year the council promised no trees would be cut after pushback, but they seem to now be reverting to a position of 'only in agreement with the council's arbourist'. Is this more hypocrisy from 'green' Southwark who seem to once again be ok with defacing trees for a fence that is up for just days? The people who now own GALA don't live in this area. GALA as an event began in Brockwell Park. It then lost its place there to bigger events (that pesumably could pay Lambeth Council more). One of the then company directors lived on the Rye Hill Estate next to the park and that is likely how Peckham Rye came to be the new choice for the event. That person is no longer involved. Today's GALA company is not the same as the 'We Are the Fair' company that held that first event, not the same in scope, aim or culture. And therein lies the problem. It's not a local community led enterprise, but a commercial one, underwritten by a venture capital company. The same company co-run the Rally Event each year in Southwark Park, which btw is licensed as a one day event only. That does seem to be truer to the original 'We Are the Fair' vision, but how much of that is down to GALA as opoosed to 'Bird on the Wire' (the other group organising it) is hard to say.  For local people, it's three days of not being able to open windows, As someone said above, if a resident set up a PA in their back garden and subjected the neighbours to 10 hours of hard dance music every day for three days, the Council would take action. Do not underestimate how distressing that is for many local residents, many of whom are elderly, frail, young, vulnerable. They deserve more respect than is being shown by those who think it's no big deal. And just to be clear, GALA and the council do not consider there to be a breach of db level if the level is corrected within 15 minutes of the breach. In other words, while db levels are set as part of the noise management plan, there is an acknowledgement that a breach is ok if corrected within 15 minutes. That is just not good enough. Local councillors objected to the proposed extension. 75% of those that responded to the consultation locally did not want GALA 26 to take place at all. For me personally, any goodwill that had been built up through the various consultations over recent years was erased with that application for a second weekend, and especially given that when asked if there were plans for that in post 2025 event feedback meetings (following rumours), GALA lied and said there were no plans to expand. I have come to the conclusion that all the effort to appease on some things is merely an exercise in show, to get past the council's threshold for the events licence. They couldn't give a hoot in reality for local people, and people that genuinely care about parkland, don't litter it with noisy festivals either.   
    • Aria is my go to plumber. Fixed a toilet leak for me at short notice. Reasonably priced and very professional. 
    • Anyone has a storage or a display rack for Albums LPs drop me a message thanks
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...