Jump to content

Recommended Posts

The offence would be deliberate handball or unsportsmanlike conduct - both are yellow cards.


Intent can't come into it because any time a player commits a deliberate offence (against an attacking side) he does so believing that if he doesn't the opposition may get an advantage which could/may (in his opinion) ultimately/eventually lead to a goal - so he intends to deny them a goal scoring opportunity by his offence or he wouldn't do it*. Simple.



Unless he is Roy Kean of course.

Jah Lush Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> How is Oxlade Chamerlain's diving save with his

> hand not a sending off? Poor decision by the FA.

> Surely, if the referee had got the right man in

> the first place the decision would have stood.


It should have been a sending off, and the FA in with their usual level of wisdom, have fcuked up royally. Ox also told ref twice it was him not Gibbs. Unbelievable. Ref obvioulsy couldn't tell them apart. Bell end.

I'm not saying the rule is right, but it should categorically not have been a sending off.


The general rule is denial of a clear goal-scoring opportunity. More specifically, the rule for this situation (i.e. a handball) is if "the unacceptable and unfair intervention prevented a goal being scored". The ball was not going in so there was no goal-scoring opportunity denied, and no goal prevented.


The more interesting question is why the ref gave any decision at all, considering he had already signalled for a goal kick and the linesman wasn't flagging. Arsenal were in enough trouble as it was (2-0 down, or 3-0 as it should have been with a penalty and a yellow card for Chamberlain) without wrongly going down to ten.

Interesting Otta - I always laugh I see journalists (normally columnists, not the sports bods) write or hear people say things like us "long suffering Arsenal/Liverpool fans"; they are benchmarking against success try supporting a team outside the big 6 or so. We'd dream of their failure.


I've said before, but down in Cardiff in 2006 I really did think "that's it for me - I can't do this hurt anymore"....grdaually it crept back and being at Wembley for the play offs final was cathartic for me

???? Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> ...and I am lucky, any West Ham under 40

> presumambly can't remember us winning anything!

> (excluding play offs)

>

> and of course, we are relatively priveliged

> compared to most smaller clubs (and Newcastle :))


Agree - I think a lot hangs on your formative years. As a kid the 74-75 season was huge. Billy Jennings and Bobby Gould scoring hat-tricks for fun with Keith Robson scoring if they didn't; Mervyn Day before he lost it; results like 5-2, 5-3 and 6-2 and a memorable 1-1 at Anfield. Then the culmination in a proper 'fairy tale' Cup Final against St Bobby.

Moyes has come out and taken responsibility for Man U's decline. Shielding his players I guess.


I think he knows that he is going to be given time, so I think the fans need to accept he'll be there at least another year.


Why the hell diod he bring a whole new coaching staff in with him?!?!?!? (and an unproven coaching staff at that)

Otta Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Parkdrive Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > Bugger, bugger and thrice bugger

>

>

> So what the Hell is going on with Arsenal at the

> moment? Is it as simple as injuries to key

> players, or something deeper?


I wish I knew, the injuries certainly haven't helped, but in the last few games there have been too few players willing to give it their all for the cause. Failing to add to the squad in January didn't help when it was clear we needed fresh blood, so Wenger and the board should take the blame for that. Ah well, I've supported the buggers for 46 years so no turning back now.


I've seen a few reports today that SAF got abuse from the fans at yesterday evenings game for his selection of Moyes as his successor. And they say fans are fickle. ;)

Certainly not the best warm up for Man City coming to yours this weekend!


Just been looking at the remaining fixtures for the season. Not sure I can see many potential banana skins for Chelsea other than (hopefully) their trip to Anfield. City (as well as Arsenal this weekend) have to go to both Liverpool and Everton, other than those I can't see them dropping any points.


I think Liverpool are in with a shout, but they basically need to win every game thwey have left, possibly draws with Chelsea / City, but not sure that would be enough.

Parkdrive Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Bayern Munich are champions of Germany for a 24th

> time with a record seven games to spare after a

> 3-1 win in Berlin.

> Scary.


Philip Lahm completed 134 passes out of 134 attempted last night.


Ausgezeichnet.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Amazing. Now could you cut and paste an AI summary of the defence case for Andrew M-W? 
    • I would like to understand this promise by the Greens in greater detail and how it applies locally? Presumably road/pavement upkeep and renewal is as important for cyclists and pedestrians as motorists? I am not aware of plans to build new roads locally but there has been plenty of money spent on converting roads into pedestrian only areas. On the face of it this feels a slightly empty statement, when applied at local level. I'd love to know the Greens stance in hiring out parks for private use (given impact on park environment), I'd also like to understand their stance on fireworks- I will look to see if I can find anything. I don't know if a manifesto exists under the documents section of Southwark Greens, but you can only access that bit by signing in- which is disappointing. If anyone has a manifesto that reflects local priorities- could they post a link?
    • You are most likely correct in thinking that  Kinnock, Blair, Brown, Starmer et all knew it.  But they obviously thought that his skills, abilities and usefulness far outweighed the negatives. Here is a summary of the positives lifted from elsewhere:-   1. Strategic Architect: He was a primary architect of "New Labour," rebranding the party and shifting its core ideology to win the 1997 general election. 2 Master of Communication: Often called the original "spin doctor," he revolutionised how political parties manage the media. He famously created the "grid" system to coordinate government messaging. 3 Networking and Charm: Known as "Silvertongue," he possesses a peerless ability to charm and network with high-level global figures, including business leaders and heads of state. 4. Governance and Trade Expertise: Beyond strategy, he was considered a highly efficient minister, serving as European Commissioner for Trade and Secretary of State across multiple departments, including Business and Northern Ireland.  5. Reinvention: His capacity to adapt to changing political climates and rebuild relationships reflects personal resilience and strategic flexibility. With his skill and abilities, he delivered results for all his bosses. In the short time in Washington, he found a way to get on the right side of Trump - despite him  being critical of Trump in previous years. That said he is complex personality.  He can be simultaneously brilliant and arrogant, thick-skinned yet sensitive, and selfless for his party while appearing narcissistic in his personal dealings.  My OP asked if he would be accepted over the pond. It turned out he was because he got on famously with trump. He worked out the correct strategy to get on the good side of Trump and secured a better trade deal than the EU and other nations.    
    • Malumbu, do you happen to know what the current figure is for "trips into town made by walking, cycling and public transport"? 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...