We are trialing a dedicated East Dulwich COVID-19 Area on the forum here - please keep it useful.

Forum Sponsors

www.stevenvaughan.co.uk

http://avakitchens.co.uk

www.takeflightacademy.co.uk

Advertise here

The East Dulwich Forum
Would you recommend your East Dulwich doctor, dentist or butcher?
messageJust got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?attachment
Posted by LanaJade 03 May, 2019 12:51

Got a pesky fine, I was stopped on a box junction right at the end as I misjudged the space thinking the van ahead would move forward more. I'm just wondering if anyone has experience in winning the appeals? I will attach a photo of the fine .



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit was 2019:05:03:12:55:35 by LanaJade.

Attachments: IMG_20190503_125244-864x1152.jpg (147.9KB)   IMG_20190503_125239-864x1152.jpg (160.4KB)  
messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by LanaJade 03 May, 2019 12:59

I'm a new driver 3 months.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by HelBel65 03 May, 2019 13:05

Doubt you'll have much luck as it's there in black & white. Others may think differently, or know more about Southwark.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by d.b 03 May, 2019 13:06

Half your car is in the box junction. Doesn't look like an appeal would get you anywhere.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by dougiefreeman 03 May, 2019 13:10

Visit [forums.pepipoo.com]

It’s free to register - and there are a ton of experts there to help you with making your case.

You have absolutely nothing to lose by appealing so it is always good to do it.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by MarkT 03 May, 2019 13:23

LanaJade,
put it down to experience. Fight the fights that are worth fighting. I can't imagine that anyone would have an ideological objection to yellow boxes.
MarkT

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by researcher 03 May, 2019 13:46

Have a look at the judgments in Newman, Gillingham & Essoo & Khan, and Banks, all at [www.londontribunals.gov.uk].

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by seenbeen 03 May, 2019 13:59

"Do not enter the box unless your exit is clear"- if I recall

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by HelBel65 03 May, 2019 14:16

seenbeen Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> "Do not enter the box unless your exit is clear"-
> if I recall

Correct.....LanaJade, I sympathise, because it's often hard to judge and (probably) most of us have got it wrong in the past and learned the hard way.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by edcam 03 May, 2019 14:16

No point appealing, it's valid.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by RichH 03 May, 2019 14:23

Appeals are generally successful when penalties are issued in error, where there's an element of doubt, where there are extenuating circumstances or, occasionally, where there's been a recent change of policy that may not be widely known.

Unfortunately I don't think any of those apply here. Don't feel too badly about it though, it's a fairly easy mistake to make. For each of your 3 months driving I've been driving over a decade and I get caught out like that now and again.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by Passiflora 03 May, 2019 22:12

Do feel for you as looks like just the end of your car is in the yellow box, not half.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by LanaJade 03 May, 2019 23:26

Thanks for the replies, I think I'm going to just pay the fine sad smiley be extra careful in the future. sad smiley

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by malumbu 04 May, 2019 17:18

System is flawed in that there is zero tolerance for some offences which may be fairly benign or due to genuine mistakes, but bugger all enforcement for some of the more serious stuff. I've had my fair share of fines - some justified others disproportionate wh4en a telling off would suffice such as a bus lane in the early hours when there was no traffic (mentally I'm thinking bus lanes are for normal traffic) but still no excuse, but alienates you as a responsible driver.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by sjsl 04 May, 2019 19:39

I got caught in Norwood on a yellow box (so beware out there). I had entered a yellow box because I could see the traffic was moving and calculated I wouldn't be stuck there – I actually stopped for about 5 seconds with my back wheels still in the box (it's all on camera) waiting a polite distance from the car in front to move forward. I was causing no obstruction. If I had known I was being filmed I could have closed up very tight to the car in front and got away with it sad smiley but that isn't grounds for appeal, you have to keep moving apparently.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by Chick 06 May, 2019 13:05

Appeal it. You weren't blocking anyone,

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by teddyboy23 06 May, 2019 17:56

I got a ticket about a year ago ,in the yellow box outside peckham bus garage .Sam as you my back wheels ,and boot.in yellow box.I appealed saying I wasn't blocking buses going into the terminal,or buses coming out .I wasn't causing an obstruction to any other traffic.got caught out when lights other side of box changed red,not enough space to move further forward ticket was cancelled

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by jimlad48 06 May, 2019 21:25

teddyboy23 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I got a ticket about a year ago ,in the yellow box
> outside peckham bus garage .Sam as you my back
> wheels ,and boot.in yellow box.I appealed saying I
> wasn't blocking buses going into the terminal,or
> buses coming out .I wasn't causing an obstruction
> to any other traffic.got caught out when lights
> other side of box changed red,not enough space to
> move further forward ticket was cancelled

you were lucky - I was done in the same spot a few years ago for identical reasons - thought I had space, but car in front of me stopped short so I couldnt clear the box. They upheld the fine annoyingly as a bus couldnt get out, but its made me paranoid ever since!

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by LanaJade 06 May, 2019 22:18

Hi thanks for this, If I appeal and it is not unheld would I then need to pay the whole fine and miss out on the "half price" fine within 14 days.

teddyboy23 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I got a ticket about a year ago ,in the yellow box
> outside peckham bus garage .Sam as you my back
> wheels ,and boot.in yellow box.I appealed saying I
> wasn't blocking buses going into the terminal,or
> buses coming out .I wasn't causing an obstruction
> to any other traffic.got caught out when lights
> other side of box changed red,not enough space to
> move further forward ticket was cancelled

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by Passiflora 07 May, 2019 00:19

Yes, you would need to pay the whole fine.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by Chick 07 May, 2019 09:35

If you appeal you don't have to pay the full fine but you must appeal within the time limits.


Passiflora Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Yes, you would need to pay the whole fine.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by researcher 07 May, 2019 11:25

LanaJade Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hi thanks for this, If I appeal and it is not
> unheld would I then need to pay the whole fine and
> miss out on the "half price" fine within 14 days.

Have a look at London Councils' "Understanding Parking Penalties" [www.londoncouncils.gov.uk].

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by teddyboy23 07 May, 2019 15:54

On a lighter note.about 7 months ago the road where I live was resurfaced.in a couple of places the new tarmac came right up to the edge of the pavement.anyway parked on one of these spots returned later that day ,to find a PNC on my car.upon opening it I was being fined for parking in front of a dropped kerbanyway couldn't take any photos on my phone as the camera wasn't working as I wanted some evidence to support appeal.so went to Argos bought a £50 digital camera took several photos of the road and my car .took the camera to asda old Kent road .down loaded photos £7 writ my appeal out .put in envelope with photos ,then sent by recorded delivery £6_80..got a reply within 2 weeks ticket had been cancelled.so all in all I spent £63_80 to get a£65 pcn callelled .👍



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit was 2019:05:07:16:39:34 by teddyboy23.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by spoiltdog 08 May, 2019 22:44

Went to Alleynns Head for a meal week ago ,got ticket in the car park ,£50.00 within 14 Days or £100.00,tried ringing Parking Company just goes to Payment only,no one to speak to. Went to see Landlord of Alleynns Head,who got it cancelled in front of us .So massive thanks Rob ,

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by ruffers 11 May, 2019 21:48

Just pay the fine, take it on the chin, and learn a lesson.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by JohnL 13 May, 2019 13:22

seenbeen Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> "Do not enter the box unless your exit is clear"-
> if I recall


Yes - I almost got caught once when the car in front stops sooner than you expect - luckily he moved again and I didn't have to stop. Much more conservative now. smiling smiley

No way out though - stop in the box and you're done.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit was 2019:05:13:13:24:09 by JohnL.

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by peckham_ryu 13 August, 2019 16:59

I just had a letter from TfL, cancelling a fine they had issued me for stopping in the box junction next to Peckham bus station. I had definitely stopped in the box, it goes to show it is worth putting in an appeal.

TfL’s letter says:
Quote:
Due to an operator administrative error relating to the above penalty charge, the representation has been accepted and the penalty charge has been cancelled.

It also then says that on this occasion they decided to “exercise discretion”. So it’s not necessary a black and white thing. When I filled in the “representation” box I had simply said that if I had stopped in the box, it must have been because somebody changed lanes in front of me and blocked my exit, and anyway it was not possible to tell from the one photo whether I or not I was just moving slowly and could I please see photos from 10 secs before and after. All a bit speculative, but I don’t make a habit of deliberately clogging up box junctions so I’m glad I don’t have to pay a fine this time smiling smiley

messageRe: Just got a penalty charge Camberwell new road . Worth appealing ?
Posted by Chick 13 August, 2019 18:15

Good.


Back to top of page
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Donate                   Terms of use                  Help & FAQs                   Advertise               RSS rss feed               Copyright 2006 - 2018 East Dulwich Forum