It's not judging music though is it? That's for A&R men, who make real decisions. This is PR - for the telly. The 'music judging' comprises less than ten stock scripted lines. This year's faves are: "By any standards, that was world class" "I just didn't get it" "You're pitching was a bit off" ('Pitching..?!' wtf?) "I don't think you get enough appreciation" "You're a tryer" ("Nailed it" has, of course, been banned following overuse last series)