Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Cyril Smith's post mortem diagnosis of paedophilia highlights the troublesome pastime of appropriating modern afflictions to describe historical lifestyle choices.


From the same hat I've pulled gluten intolerance and peanut allergies.


Are there other diseases that simply didn't exist in the 70s?

I'm afraid "gluten intolerance" or coeliac condition has been around slightly longer than that. It's facile to suggest that something didn't exist just because it wasn't a well-known condition then or that diagnostic techniques have improved as medical science has advanced.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coeliac_disease#History

Are there other diseases that simply didn't exist in the 70s?

-------------------------------------------------------------


Aretaeus of Cappadocia discovered coeliac (celiac) disease in 2nd century


While a role for carbohydrates had been suspected, the link with wheat was not made until the 1940s

by the Dutch paediatrician Dr Willem Dicke.


The link with the gluten component of wheat was made in 1952


So it has always existed but not understood.


Related article:- http://askville.amazon.com/discovered-Celiac-Disease/AnswerViewer.do?requestId=10919424


Fox.

Well eczema has been around since the dawn of time - Emperor Octavius Augustus had it.


The Egyptians talked of asthma, and King James VI of Scotland wrote a counterblast to tobacco.


Coliac disease appears in historical references too.


Nut allergy - now that's an interesting one, I can't find many historical references. Peanuts were used as cattle feed after WW2 due to food shortages and there are a few papers suggesting a link between milk consumption and nut allergies where the cattle have been fed nuts...given that peanuts (shell and all) aren't a traditional choice of cattle, there could be something in this...


Edited to add: nut allergy is a real life-threatening allergy! So not something to be written off as a fad.

Lowlander Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> Nut allergy - now that's an interesting one, I

> can't find many historical references.


> Edited to add: nut allergy is a real

> life-threatening allergy! So not something to be

> written off as a fad.


Brazil nuts have tried to kill me since the late 60's


They had a bloody good try in my mid 20's


Oooh those defibrillators are a bugger, like being kicked repeatedly by a donkey. Then to top it all, your fingernails and your fillings feel like they're super heating and trying to fly off/out of their sockets.


It's a right laugh "appropriating modern afflictions" I can tell you.

AA was formed in 1935 and the term "alcoholism" was coined in 1849. Although the problem certainly is on the increase, the condition has been around for much much longer than that.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholism#History


Dyslexia was identified in 1881 and given its current name in 1887. Again - the condition probably existed long before that.

Stress / Depression. When a colleague in my old job went off with stress, the look on the face of another colleague (man in his 50s, proper Welling boy) was absolutely priceless.


"Stress didn't exists when I started working, and why should you miss work cos you're a bit fed up? It's a bloody nonsense!". He said.

Huguenot Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> David Mc, it's a joke. It's supposed to be

> facile.

>

> Clearly these diseases have been knocking around

> for a while. It's about attitudes not clinical

> diagnosis.

>

> Glad most people got it ;-)



Banter !


(that's the one was trying to think of)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Our camera caught two folks doing this. One of them led me to believe the delivery driver was in on it as he left the package in a very odd place that the thief (who arrived about 10 minutes after from a direction where he could not have seen where the driver left it) went straight to it and took it - but he then dumped it halfway down the next road as clearly packets of freeze-dried food for a DofE award wasn't to his liking (karma sucks!). The second time a guy pulled his bike up in broad daylight, walked down to our door, opened the box, threw the empty box down and stuffed what he had found in his backpack and brazenly waved at the camera and then cycled off. Police asked us to upload his picture but we never heard anything back.
    • I hear that Landells Road has had a spate of parcels being taken,
    • In the 1960s my husband went to a private day school, Although he was a bright child having won a couple of scholarships to other private schools, his father chose this particular one. He went from 11 - 14 years and left as unhappy with the set up which was based on ethnicity. All boys with both parents English were placed in the A stream regardless of academic ability, Boys with an Irish background were placed in B stream. All others were C streamed - this included boys with a Black or Asian  background, mixed race or mixed European background. His schooldays came to an end when he wished to learn Latin and he was told that no boy in C stream could participate in this subject. His father (not English) was very upset at this and withdrew him from the school and sent him  to a country boarding school.  The experiences he had with his schooling culminated in a breakdown of his mental health and several months in Maudsley. He had low self esteem and it took several decades for him to understand that it was the school system and not his ability which had failed him
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...