Good, and honest points being made here. At the end of the day, if someone said I generally don't find black girls attractive, that is not racist. They may also say I don't fancy brunettes either, but I love Asian girls... It's just about what one person finds pleasing on the eye I guess. The original train comment could be called racist, because effectively he/they were suggesting that as a race, black girls are not pretty, and the "for a black girl" bit suggests that a half decent white girl would still be a better choice. I do agree with Jeremy however that it was more rude and sexist than anything else. You just wonder why they would think it was acceptable to make that kind of comment on a train. I don't really believe in "types". I used to think my type was definitely brunette, and have married a blue eyed blond, via various hair and skin shades along the way to finding her. I have fancied them all for one reason or another. One could argue that at the end of the day, it's just because we smelled right to each other!