ImpetuousVrouw Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > ???? Wrote: > -------------------------------------------------- > ----- > > To answer Sedgewicks original point. > > > > There were pagan and other religious ceremonies > to > > celebrate the winter solstice throughout > history > > and way before christ. Traditionally the depths > of > > winter when it was often frozen, the days are > very > > short , so there was little time or need to do > > anything on the land, and the harvest surplus > was > > starting to go rotten (ditto grain for the > > livestock was running low) so it was a good > time > > for slaughtering and stuffing one's self with > > surplus before the lean times approaching > > (coincidentally christianity invented Lent for > > this). Christianity just tagged on to a pagan > > festival. > > > > The real question is why do Christians continue > to > > celebrate Christs birthday at a time of the year > > > when both historically (Herod's census wasn't > in > > December) and astronomically (the star) its > been > > proven wasn't his birthday? > > > So you were listening to Radio 4 this morning too? er, no, I never listen to Radio 4...it's hardly a revelation is it???