Huguenot Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > "Doesn't the fact that a fellow forumite feels > like this tell us something about our own > behaviour? No forumite should be made to feel that > his/her opinions are worthless - and Monica's are > as valid as anybody else's. This forum is about > inclusivity, not the reverse." > > I don't think it's reasonable to take this as a > blanket rule. > > Anyone who had a younger sister will be familiar > with tactical squeals of 'victim, victim' whilst > evil lurks beneath. > > There are plenty of adults who haven't grown out > of such manipulation, and more than a few on here > ;-) I agree. It is slightly irritating that someone uses their faith and arguments about cliques to close down debate about the appalling abuse suffered by thousands of children. I think the charge of insensitivity could be made against Monica for assuming her faith carries more weight than the voice of survivors of this sytemic abuse. How does she know whether DM herself, or people close to DM have not been abused by those in the Catholic church? Just because DM doesn't cry all over the forum, doesn't mean this topic doesn't cause her immense pain. It is more than insensitive to try to close down the voices of the abused by feigning pain at the discussion. Weigh it up. Pain of actual abuse v criticism of the institution who perpetrated it. Hmm, I know which hurt has more weight in my opinion.