Jump to content

Recommended Posts

citizenED Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Mockers - I was going to cite Parachutes (been

> playing it along with Bjork) but thought I might

> feel your wrath or disdain!


Ouch, am I that bad?


I think on this one i may have popped my head above the parapet before in support of that album, but otta is absolutely right in his assertion.


Back on track, Help She Can't Swim had a cracking debut a good follow up and then grew up and got jobs or something. Very disappointing. I guess it probably turned out that five or six musos buying their album wasn't going to pay for their dinner :(

okay - as populist as they come yet it was their 3rd album that was the first to really make it and their first to make the UK top 20....


ABBA - ABBA


*only mention them because they were just swedeing their way through Dancing Queen on 'TOTP 1976' on BBC3 - honest!*

Ridgley Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> My favourite is Goldfrapp Supernature takes me

> back to the 70s glam rock area:)



Supernature isnt her debut album, and besides she's .... was gonna say something rude, she aint my cup of tea, shall we say.

mockney piers Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Dare I moot Parachutes as a good debut without

> being shot down in flames?

> I haven't liked anything since, but that first one

> has charm.


I like most of Coldplay's stuff so am not going to shoot you down in flames, and parachutes was a great debut - still love "Yellow"


As for what I would add to the list of great debut albums


Definitely Maybe by Oasis - ok, I know they could be right idiots, but hard to deny the impact they had at the time. Still got a special place in my heart because it reminds me of some happy times.


19 by Adele - I know her second album has somewhat eclipsed this, but I think it was still a fine debut and she's got a lovely voice.


I'd agree with the people who mentioned the Killers first album - seen them live a couple of times and they are so good, and Mr Brightside was a total classic.


My most loved debut album is Expecting to Fly by the Bluetones. They are only just splitting up now and haven't really topped it in the 15 or so years since its release, but I've had many happy trips to gigs to see them and made new friends through doing so, so the album brings up lots of good memories.


As for great third albums - how about Paul Weller's third solo album "Stanley Road"? (and yes, I do know it's not the third album he was involved in - am old enough to remember both Jam and Style Council!)

pablogrande Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I forgot supergrass - I should coco

>

> And of course - the best of the Beatles


xxxxx


Best of the Beatles? How can that have been a debut album?!


Please Please Me wasn't it??


ETA: Memo to self: Get off this thread :))

maxxi Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> okay - as populist as they come yet it was their

> 3rd album that was the first to really make it and

> their first to make the UK top 20....

>

> ABBA - ABBA

>

> *only mention them because they were just swedeing

> their way through Dancing Queen on 'TOTP 1976' on

> BBC3 - honest!*


Interesting to see signs of the oncoming punk explosion with Eddie and The Hot Rods performance...they played the Marquee in Summer '76 with support act.......The Sex Pistols

mockney piers Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> >>"You could apply that analogy to the Floyd*

> album too.

> >>Both albums very much captured the zeitgeist."

>

> I could except I was born a couple of years

> afterwards.

> I was specifically referring to my own

> relationship with Stone Roses, what I was up to

> and the hazy days of coming of age that are now

> steeped in nostalgia for me.

>

> It doesn't undermine how critical that album was

> in terms of my development and relationship with

> music.


> It's just it's now long enough away for me to also

> be more objective about the songs themselves and I

> don't think they live up to the pedestal on which

> they've been placed (in my head) for so long.


Point taken, it would be interesting to know the age posters were when the albums they have nominated were released...I reckon 14-24 would be a common catchment age

OK this has now got complicated: Was going to have Ash's "1977" as a great debut - but there was apparently one before it. So I was then going to have Ash's "Free All Angels" as a brilliant third album. but because of that obscure first, that makes "Free.." a fourth album. Doh

This thread has lost the plot. And have you ever wondered how you get triangles from a cow.


Looked at my modern music to find that most of it is latter albumns, because my finger is no longer on the pulse.


But two more - Billy Bragg, Life's a Riot with Spy vs Spy and


Wait for it


Air Moon Safari


Oh and if you are going to talk about the Cure, which is so dated (both the early 80s stuff and curent stuff)


Siouxie and the Banshees, The Scream

Debuts:

The Ramones - The Ramones

The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses

The Who - My Generation


Defining third Albums:

Blondie - Parallel Lines

Bon Jovi - Slippery When Wet (I know, I know...)

Elvis Costello - Armed Forces (debatable)

(I'd also echo the earlier mention of Manic Street Preachers' Holy Bible, which leaves all their other releases for dust).

3 life changing debuts;


Spacemen 3 - Sound of Confusion


The Doors - The Doors


Jimi Hendrix - Are you Experienced



3rds


Prince - Dirty Mind


White Stripes - White Blood Cells


Bongwater - The Power of Pussy


Dinosaur Jr - Bug



6ths


Sonic Youth - Daydream Nation


The Kinks - The Kinks are the Village Green Preservation Society


Super Furry Animals - Lovekraft


Can anybody do 9ths?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Bumpkin I’d say feed and clean.    The RSPB say garden birds are low risk for avian flu but take precautions and clean feeders and birdbaths regularly.    Birds will be starting to nest soon and food you put out can at least feed the parents so they can feed live food to the young who can’t take seed yet.    It’s reccomended to wear gloves and clean feeders/birdbaths with mild disinfectant weekly. 
    • We had a take-away from Aroma Lab last night. I was impressed, utterly delicious stir fried tofu and sweet and sour chicken. Generous portions too… will definitely make a habit of eating their home-cooked food. 
    • I think that's a big assumption.  Many people vote for the candidate precisely because they are a member of a particular party and represent that party's policiies.  I personally didn't know who McAsh was in the last election, but I knew what party he represented.  When politicians don't act "morally" what are we to think of them and their motivations? But I think there will be people who want to vote Labour, don't know that McAsh has defected and accidentally vote Green precisely because they do vote for the name.  Yes, you could say they need to read the ballot paper more carefully but it's possible to see one thing and not notice another.
    • Morally they should, but we don't actually vote for parties in our electoral system. We vote for a parliamentary (or council) representative. That candidates group together under party unbrellas is irrelevant. We have a 'representative' democracy, not a party political one (if that makes sense). That's where I am on things at the moment. Reform are knocking on the door of the BNP, and using wedge issues to bait emotional rage. The Greens are knocking on the door of the hard left, sweeping up the Corbynista idealists. But it's worth saying that both are only ascending because of the failures of the two main parties and the successive governments they have led. Large parts of the country have been left in economic decline for decades, while city fat cats became uber wealthy. Young people have been screwed over by student loans. Housing is 40 years of commoditisation, removing affordabilty beyond the reach of too many. Decently paid, secure jobs, seem to be a thing of the past. Which of the main parties can people turn to, to fix any of these things, when the main parties are the reason for the mess that has been allowed to evolve? Reform certainly aren't the answer to those things. The Greens may aspire to do something meaningful about some of them, but where will they find the money to pay for it? None of it's easy.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...