Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I think different things suit different people.


Of course ideally one would always eat healthily and only just enough, and exercise more.


But we aren't all paragons of virtue.


Most people who go on a diet where they restrict their calories (by whatever method) on a 24/7 basis put all the weight back on again.


Many people can't stick to a diet because they miss certain things.


The 5:2 diet overcomes some of the drawbacks of other diets. Whether you choose to eat healthily or not healthily on any of the days is a separate issue really, I feel. Obviously a regime of fast food, fat and sugar is not going to improve your health.


Also once you are down to a reasonable weight, you can keep it to that level by having the odd "fast" day when necessary.


But if you're the kind of person who can always eat healthily and get lots of exercise, hats off to you :)

*Bob* Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> It's essentially a series of miniature-crash diets

> instead of one big one.

>

> The bravura aspect of this latest novelty diet is

> certainly making it appealing to men though - more

> so than other diets. 'Fasting' sounds so much

> cooler than 'dieting', of course.


Bravura? Well maybe for some. Fasting sounds horrible to me, I therefore had my metaphorical fingers stuck in my ears when a colleague (who has lost weight on this way of eating very successfully over the last two years) kept recommending it to me. When I finally listened, I though 'yes - I could do that quite easily'. And so has proved the case.


Let's call it a '2/5 way of eating' then if that helps - what does it matter of it works for an individual?


Bob - I take it you have never been overweight and find it easy to keep to a healthy diet on a daily basis - as Sue says, hats off to you :)

edcam Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> RosieH Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > edcam Wrote:

> >

> --------------------------------------------------

>

> > -----

> > > Yes, people forget that weight loss isn't the

> > main

> > > aim of the fasting diet. It's the all round

> > health

> > > benefits that are the point.

> >

> >

> > Yes - science suggest that the health benefits

> of

> > the 5:2 fasting diet are the same as a regular,

> > run-of-the-mill healthy eating regime.

> >

> > Who'd a thunk it?

>

>

> That's not true actually - where did you read this

> research?


In a health magazine. Why, where did you read yours?


I'd also refer you to the NHS: http://www.nhs.uk/news/2013/01January/Pages/Does-the-5-2-intermittent-fasting-diet-work.aspx

El Pibe Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> of course it's not forbidden, it's just that you

> did

>

> &lti&gtwords here

>

> and then copy and pasted it umpteen times, meaning

> some well meaning moderator type had to do lots of

> search and replacing for you.

> Just try and do it properly next time ;-P


xxxxxx


Don't understand, duh.


So far as I recall I didn't copy and paste anything, and even if I had the html would have been the same as if I'd typed it in separately, surely?


I can't show you what I used because it doesn't come out properly on its own, but it had this effect: words here


What I used was only what is showing up on your post, not the symbols that are showing up in your post when I edit.



And I checked it in the preview before I posted it, and it all looked fine :(


Can't look now obviously, because it's all gone. Sorry to have put someone to so much trouble, but

I've used every symbol I used before on here with no problem :(

StraferJack Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Days of not eating on diet = defensive and

> scrappy

>

> Back to eating days on diet = ooh I don't know

> what came over me!


Really? I feel uber alert and productive on low calorie days - probably because my stomach isn't slowing me down my digesting belly-fulls of grub.

What would happen if one simply adjusted their 5/2 regime to spread the '5' potentially piggy days out over, say '7'?


Actually, keep this to yourselves. I intend the release a book soon - I'm calling it 'Happy Sevens'. I shall be feted by This Morning and Closer magazine, become a multi-millionaire and end my days dead on a slab at exclusive clinic following a botched liposuction procedure.

Ha ,I started this diet after Christmas, the weight was dropping off and I was going around telling everyone how great it was. After a while I stopped as I felt I had lost enough but the weight continued to drop and I began to be very ill. It turns out I have an overactive thyroid. So now I can eat anything I like and still stay thin. However I think I would rather be a bit overweight than suffer the exhaustion this has brought.

suzisoo Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Ha ,I started this diet after Christmas, the

> weight was dropping off and I was going around

> telling everyone how great it was. After a while I

> stopped as I felt I had lost enough but the weight

> continued to drop and I began to be very ill. It

> turns out I have an overactive thyroid. So now I

> can eat anything I like and still stay thin.

> However I think I would rather be a bit overweight

> than suffer the exhaustion this has brought.


xxxxxxx


:(

RosieH Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> edcam Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > RosieH Wrote:

> >

> --------------------------------------------------

>

> > -----

> > > edcam Wrote:

> > >

> >

> --------------------------------------------------

>

> >

> > > -----

> > > > Yes, people forget that weight loss isn't

> the

> > > main

> > > > aim of the fasting diet. It's the all round

> > > health

> > > > benefits that are the point.

> > >

> > >

> > > Yes - science suggest that the health

> benefits

> > of

> > > the 5:2 fasting diet are the same as a

> regular,

> > > run-of-the-mill healthy eating regime.

> > >

> > > Who'd a thunk it?

> >

> >

> > That's not true actually - where did you read

> this

> > research?

>

> In a health magazine. Why, where did you read

> yours?

>

> I'd also refer you to the NHS:

> http://www.nhs.uk/news/2013/01January/Pages/Does-t

> he-5-2-intermittent-fasting-diet-work.aspx


Well the NHS are (quite rightly) unlikely to do anything other than play safe. And a "health magazine"? Neither of these amount to "science", soz.

*Bob* Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> What would happen if one simply adjusted their 5/2

> regime to spread the '5' potentially piggy days

> out over, say '7'?

>

> Actually, keep this to yourselves. I intend the

> release a book soon - I'm calling it 'Happy

> Sevens'. I shall be feted by This Morning and

> Closer magazine, become a multi-millionaire and

> end my days dead on a slab at exclusive clinic

> following a botched liposuction procedure.


Well that's easy - some of us don't live uniform lives. I am 'good' during the week but eat out or at dinner parties plus alcohol ++ at weekends. Next? (god almighty, this thread is going round in circles ad nauseum...).

There is a lot of evidence that refined carbohydrates, especially sugar and flour are the main cause of our obesity epidemic so reducing most carbs helps to smooth out blood sugar, reduce water retention, increase energy levels and shed loads of weight.


I lost 20 kilos in about 3 months cutting out all carbs except fruit and veg. My energy levels went back to how I was in my 20's and I no longer got lethargic after eating a meal.


It was hard to keep it up as I have no imagination when it comes to food and as my old habits crept back in, so did the weight and general lowering of energy levels.


I've decided to get back on track and go back to a strict low carb (except fruit and veg) diet again and see if I can get my weight back down.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • While it is good that GALA have withdrawn their application for a second weekend, local people and councillors will likely have the same fight on their hands for next year's event. In reading the consultation report, I noted the Council were putting the GALA event in the same light as all the other events that use the park, like the Circus, the Fair and even the FOPR fete. ALL of those events use the common, not the park, and cause nothing like the level of noise and/or disruption of the GALA event. Even the two day Irish Festival (for those that remember that one) was never as noisy as GALA. So there is some disingenuity and hypocrisy from the Council on this, something I wll point out in my response to the report. The other point to note was that in past years branches were cut back for the fencing. Last year the council promised no trees would be cut after pushback, but they seem to now be reverting to a position of 'only in agreement with the council's arbourist'. Is this more hypocrisy from 'green' Southwark who seem to once again be ok with defacing trees for a fence that is up for just days? The people who now own GALA don't live in this area. GALA as an event began in Brockwell Park. It then lost its place there to bigger events (that pesumably could pay Lambeth Council more). One of the then company directors lived on the Rye Hill Estate next to the park and that is likely how Peckham Rye came to be the new choice for the event. That person is no longer involved. Today's GALA company is not the same as the 'We Are the Fair' company that held that first event, not the same in scope, aim or culture. And therein lies the problem. It's not a local community led enterprise, but a commercial one, underwritten by a venture capital company. The same company co-run the Rally Event each year in Southwark Park, which btw is licensed as a one day event only. That does seem to be truer to the original 'We Are the Fair' vision, but how much of that is down to GALA as opoosed to 'Bird on the Wire' (the other group organising it) is hard to say.  For local people, it's three days of not being able to open windows, As someone said above, if a resident set up a PA in their back garden and subjected the neighbours to 10 hours of hard dance music every day for three days, the Council would take action. Do not underestimate how distressing that is for many local residents, many of whom are elderly, frail, young, vulnerable. They deserve more respect than is being shown by those who think it's no big deal. And just to be clear, GALA and the council do not consider there to be a breach of db level if the level is corrected within 15 minutes of the breach. In other words, while db levels are set as part of the noise management plan, there is an acknowledgement that a breach is ok if corrected within 15 minutes. That is just not good enough. Local councillors objected to the proposed extension. 75% of those that responded to the consultation locally did not want GALA 26 to take place at all. For me personally, any goodwill that had been built up through the various consultations over recent years was erased with that application for a second weekend, and especially given that when asked if there were plans for that in post 2025 event feedback meetings (following rumours), GALA lied and said there were no plans to expand. I have come to the conclusion that all the effort to appease on some things is merely an exercise in show, to get past the council's threshold for the events licence. They couldn't give a hoot in reality for local people, and people that genuinely care about parkland, don't litter it with noisy festivals either.   
    • Aria is my go to plumber. Fixed a toilet leak for me at short notice. Reasonably priced and very professional. 
    • Anyone has a storage or a display rack for Albums LPs drop me a message thanks
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...