Otta Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > The fact is, Jews suffered something totally > unique in halocaust. There have been genocides, > but the number of people that were systematically > slaughtered in death camps is unlike anything > else. > > To suggest that the architect of that slaughter > had gone mad, but before that was some sort of > friend and supporter to the Jews is staggeringly > insensitive. > > And even now he will not back down one step, and > this shows that he is a nasty little toad that > needs shutting down. I am not defending Livingstone, but I don't think it's true that he said Hitler 'was a friend and supporter to the jews'. He suggested that Hitler supported, at one time, the relocation of German Jewish communities to Israel. I don't know, but I suspect this was what he was trying to get at.. that support for the idea of Zionism doesn't necessarily indicate support of Jewish people,their rights and freedoms, in the same way that being critical of Zionism, the policies of Israel, or the continued expansion of the state into modern day Palestine (through the expansion of illegal settlements) is necessarily antisemitic.