Sean - Firstly not an argument just clarification, schools do provide meals for all pupils and they are paid for by the parents, those that are on benefits and i'm guessing some lower income families don't have to pay - this is a seperate non-visible arrangement, when I was young you gave in 'dinner money' so those who got assisstance stood out!. However, people can opt out and provide a packed lunch too and many do. So it is there for all but not universally free and choice about what your kids eat seems a reasobnable option in the 21st century, my little girl tends to alternate. Packed lunches were also an option even when I was at school (although the food was dire then and it is not at all now at my girls school). As it happens I tend to philisophically support universal benefits but the current fiscal situation is dire on all levels, and we will need to have big cuts and some small ones too (yes I know it's global, ask greeks...and the irish too!) to be blunt I'm quite happy paying for my kids meals when fire escapes in Southwark tower blocks still remain unsafe. It DOES look like an attempt to buy votes in all honesty - yes I know I grind axes - but I suspect it won't work as I reckon many Southwark parents will kind of feel like I do. We will see.