JetSetWilly Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > so are you therefore proposing a school for the > children born of "middle income professional > families" in the ED area, because you don,t > believe that throwing all children of all > abilities in together works in all areas. you want > a school that is right for ED, the people who live > in ED and aimed at their childrens abilities. > > what in effect you are proposing is selective > education for the choosen ones and the rest can in > effect get stuffed. you make a very broad > assumption that a) all families in ED fall into > the middle income professional bracket, b)that the > children of these families will be of a suitable > educational standard to go to this proposed > school. > > so for the bright children from the families in ED > who don,t quite meet the level of the middle > income professional bracket, where do they go, or > are they suitable to attend by association. > what about the children of the middle income > families who don,t quite come up to standard, what > happens to them, as according to your beliefs > throwing children of all abilities in together > dosent work in all areas, or are you of the belief > that it will work in ED. > > while we all want the best for our children, what > you are proposing is selfish, middle class > elitism, that will in effect educate the children > born of families, lucky enough to have parents > earning enough to fall into your middle income > bracket, and the rest can again get stuffed. your > idea is flawed, ill thought through, and you need > to go back to the drawing board and brush up on > your homework. No. He's suggesting that schools for this area shouldn't just be Academies - which have poorer records and I suspect negligble mixtures of different classes as, hey surprise, middle class 'socialists' on the whole don't follow their 'heatrfelt convictions'- to the detriment of their kids educaton.. And maybe we can then get some schools that benefit EVERYONE who lives in our area....where does MM ever say these schools would be fpr middleclass kids only? It may be an unpalatable truth but 'middleclass' schools do tend to do a fair bit better than those in more deprived areas for a whole host of reasons including 'pushyness', apirations, home environment, discipline ...which is nothing to do with inherent differences in intelligence. Go and ask motivated, singleparent working class mum's with bright kids if they'd like a bit more than the 'acadamies' available locally I'd put away your sociology text book and go and look at some Ofsted reports...