The e-dealer said: "There are too many private schools in the area, and not enough decent state schools." I can agree with your first point, but as to the second, surely having fewer private schools would mean that it would be even harder to get a place at a state secondary like Charter? I don't see the relevance of the number of private schools! Of course, if private schools were abolished altogether (?) then that would mean that richer people would have to send their kids to state schools, which might lead to a rapid improvement in them as a consequence. But that's a different argument!!