Jump to content

Recommended Posts

"Just watched Ken Loach's "Wind that shook the Barley". Still reeling from it. Powerful or what?"


I found it so documentary that it left me feeling rather cold and underwhelmed, which is odd as the likes of Kes and Land and Freedom are among my favourite all time films. I know that's his general style, but this time it felt somehow too detached. Perhaps Loach was too preoccupied with portraying the 'reality of empire' as commentary on today's events that he didn't manage to get under the skin of events a little short of a century ago.


Perhaps it was the subject matter, I know that most people who manage to sit through the half hour discussion on collectivisation versus private ownership in Land and Freedom are literally bored to tears, and the Town Hall discussion in the liberated town which closely echoes that scene, discussed a matter with very little relevance for me personally, but I'm sure would be of much greater interest to someone from a 'priest infested backwater'.


Regardless of my feelings I agree it's a film well worth watching; my missus was certainly moved by it "you see" she said at the end "can you understand why everyone hates you now?" - On second thoughts....

My defences weren't up at all. I rather thought she missed on the even-handedness that Loach offered; there was a certain muted sympathy for troops who just wanted to go home, brutalised by years in the trenches.

He also portrayed the grey areas, the divided society well. It was far from the black and white portrayed in L&F (bad fascists, bad stalinists) so was a more sophisticated political statement for that.

Like I say, it did it all correct on the surface, just failed to get under the skin.

But as I also said, perhaps that was just me.

im with you on this one mockney the wind that shakes the barley did nothing for me just about watchable and entirely predictable the whole way through, maybe as sean has already mentioned the defences were up before the show started but how it won the palme d,or i,ll never know, its not even a patch on michael collins, which deals with the same subject matter in a far superior way.

anyway enough of that,recent recommendations from the spade are flyboys-set in the skys above france in ww1 quite predictible but none the less very enjoyable with great biplane action sequences and days of glory, about a group north african soldiers fighting for france against the boche in ww2.

Re; "wind that..." Generally agree with all the comments on it which is why I didn't give it whole-hearted recommendation in my original post. I just said it was powerful - and that I was reeling from the rather bleak and numbing quality of it. Not quite in the same league as Land and Freedom.


I just seen "Million Dollar Baby" Clint Eastwood and Hilary Swank. Like a quiet, brooding symphony of a film, with thunderous passages amid long, slow paced scenes. low key performances all round - Swank stunning - A film about boxing? no a film about lonely people falling strangely in love.

citizenED Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


I just seen "Million Dollar Baby" Clint Eastwood

> and Hilary Swank. Like a quiet, brooding symphony

> of a film, with thunderous passages amid long,

> slow paced scenes. low key performances all round

> - Swank stunning - A film about boxing? no a film

> about lonely people falling strangely in love.


Left the cinema in total silence after this film (apart from the odd sniff) - very powerful and very hard to take. Had intended to go out for a drink afterwards but didn't feel in the mood. Other films that have made me feel that way are 'Schindler's List' and more recently 'Pan's Labyrinth'

*Bob* Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Of course I like all the usual masterpieces, top-100 listers and supercool obscurities, but here are some of my 'guilty pleasures' instead.


The death of poor young Heath Ledger reminded me of a seriously guilty pleasure of mine.....


10 Things I hate about you :-$


But come on, it is Shakespeare :-S

Saw No Country For Old Men.


Much as I liked Fargo (and also loved Blood Simple when it came out), I've not been so fond of some other Coen productions, and this one was no exception. I don't find my-gun-is-bigger-than-yours simplistic Terminator-style antics a worthwhile way to spend an evening.

I have heard so much about the Romanian film 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days that I'm not sure if I want to see it or not


I enjoyed this article about it - but then absolutely GASPED when I saw a paragraph drawing parallels with one of the finest albums of the 90's about half way down


4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days


if only someone, SOMEONE out there had heard the album in question..

SeanMacGabhann Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I have heard so much about the Romanian film 4

> Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days that I'm not sure if I

> want to see it or not

>

> I enjoyed this article about it - but then

> absolutely GASPED when I saw a paragraph drawing

> parallels with one of the finest albums of the

> 90's about half way down

>

> 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days

>

> if only someone, SOMEONE out there had heard the

> album in question..



Hi Sean, had the album (I'm assuming you're referring to The Fatima Mansions rather than whatever one Papa Don't Preach was on, although a fine song in itself). I sort of followed the Mansions career but much preferred Microdisney.

HonaloochieB


Not JUST Mott the Hoople but Microdisney/Fatima Mansions too? Some kind of musical angel!


I loved Microdisney as I grew up in Cork but it was the Mansions which made me realise how broad "rock" music could be. I still think no-one has come close. Coughlan's solo career has touched on both band's styles but is mostly a thing of itself. And what a thing that is


If you haven;t seen him live of late you must - there simply isn't anyone else like him

I'm a regular cinema goer and recently caught the following:


No Country For Old Men - Absolutely a triumph for the return of The Coen Brothers. I guess you could call it a modern western based on the novel by Cormac McCarthy. Great performances and a truly cold, chilling performance by Javier Bardem as the central psycho / clean up guy. Should get an oscar easily. So good a film it doesn't even have a score!


Sweeney Todd - As musical films go, it doesn't get darker than this. Tim Burton pulls all the stops out on this screen adaption of the Stephen Sondheim stage show, graphic throat slashings intact. So extreme they gained the film an 18! Johnny Depp pulls another masterful performance and easily proves that he is the most versitile actor working in Hollywood today ... And the man can sing too!


Go and watch these movies and tell me what you think.

Heard Tim Burton saying that he made it so bloody because for him that is less scary than leaving too much to the imagination. Films like the first Saw would prove the point, and the 2nd and 3rd Saws made with much much bigger budgets and more blood were just not up there with it.

As it's been mentioned on the getting to know you thread, I thought I'd post a couple of clips from the wonderfilm that is The Princess Bride.


Battle of wits


Best sword fight ever!!!


Basically, these clips show why it appeals to everyone, it has action adventure, comedy, a beautiful Princess, an evil prince, pirates, romance? And Columbo!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • OP has perhaps inadvertently provided free advertising for Gails, drawing attention to Dulwich Gails being open on Christmas Day.
    • Staff get taxis in and out and get paid extra (which I think is x2). Some people like to work on Bank Holidays and others don’t. Some people actively avoid Christmas for personal reasons. Long live freedom of choice! 
    • Here is another article from the excellent Special Needs Jungle (SNJ) with tips for responses to the SEND conversation survey. Including shoe horning in EHCPs which they "forget" to ask a question about in the conversation. And living as we do in Southwark with the huge misfortune of 100% academy secondary schools, some thoughts on this and how unlikely inclusion in mainstream is within the current education landscape. Closing date 14 Jan 2026. And please consider a donation to the excellent entirely run by volunteers SNJ. In my view the government could save money by creating some smaller mainstream secondary schools for kids who can cope in primary school but not  with the scale of secondary, and need a calmer less busy setting. The funding would have to be different - it is currently on a per pupil basis which favours larger schools. But it would undoubtedly be cheaper than specialist provision, and the huge cost to individual children and families (emotional and financial) and to society. https://www.specialneedsjungle.com/tips-help-complete-governments-send-conversation-survey-law/ If anyone wants to take a radical step to help their struggling child, my tip is to move far away: these are the best two schools I have ever visited and in a beautiful part of the country. I only wish we'd moved there before it was too late for my son who had to suffer multiple failings at Charter North and then at the hands of Southwark SEND, out of education from February to October in year 10-11, having already suffered the enduring trauma of a very difficult early life, which in combination with ADHD made his time at schools which just don't care so very unbearable for all of us. https://www.cartmelprioryschool.co.uk/ https://settlebeck.org/ As an add on, I would say to anybody considering adoption, please take into account the education battles that you are very much more likely to face than the average parent. First you have schools to deal with, already terrible; then being passed from pillar to post within Southwark Education, SEND, Education Inclusion Team, round and round as they all do their best to explain why they are not responsible and you need someone different, let's hold another multi-agency meeting, never for one minute considering that if they put the child at the centre and used common sense they would achieve a lot more in much less time without loads of Southwark employees sitting in endless meetings with long suffering parents. It is hard to fully imagine this at the start of your adoption journey, full of hope as you are, but truly education is not for the faint hearted, and should be factored into your decision. You'll never hear from people who are really struggling and continue to do so, only from those who've had challenges but overcome them and it's all lovely. And education, the very people who should be there to help, are the ones who make your lives the most hellish out of everything your child and you face.
    • It’s a big problem all over London. I’ve seen it happen in Kennington and Bloomsbury in the last year. I think there has been some progress recently with some key arrests, but you do need to be very careful when walking around with your phone out, especially, as you say, if wearing noise cancelling headphones. Sorry you experienced this 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...