Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Atheist Bus Campaign Goes Nationwide


  Quote
A ?140,000 advertising campaign aimed at persuading more people to "come out" as atheists was launched today with a plan to broadcast a message doubting God's existence on the sides of buses, the tube and on screens in central London.


Its slogan ? "There's probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life" ? can already be seen on buses in central London. A total of 200 bendy buses in London and 600 buses across England, Scotland and Wales will carry the slogan from today and tomorrow following a fundraising drive which raised more than ?140,000.




So the Atheists are "outing" themselves. What do you think?



A great idea? A way of stirring up trouble? Necessary? Irrelevant?

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/4873-all-aboard-the-atheist-bus/
Share on other sites

Pascal's wager has zero merit... surely if there was a god, he/she/it would know that Pascal's position was a cop-out!


*Bob*, I think the inclusion of "probably" is sensible. We cannot know with 100% authority whether there is a god or not. What we can do is look at the world around us, consider the evidence, and conclude that the existence of a god is very, very unlikely indeed.


I am broadly with Marmora Man on this one (although I don't think it's such an issue in this country). There are lots of examples round the world where religion is having a very negative influence on politics, education, health, and more. I think this campaign is a little weak, but the message is sound.

I think you are getting slightly confused over the semantics, *Bob*.


Saying that you definitely believe there is no god, is not the same thing as saying that there definitely is no god. They are very different things.


The slogan on the side of the bus is not really an opinion or belief.

There's no semantics about it, Jeremy.


Of course there's been some general discussion of late about the nature of altheism ("oooh.. I'm a soft Atheist!" etc), but essentially there are only two positions:


Atheist - No God

Agnostic - Don't know.


Clearly some Atheists at Atheist Bus Campaign HQ are hedging their bets. Lame.

If the statement had read "There is no God..." then that would have offended religious groups and the Advertising Standards Authority would not have allowed it, so they had to compromise and stick "probably" in there. My sign would say something like:


If there is a God why does he allow the killing of innocent schoolchildren?

It's because he doesn't exist, accept it and enjoy being more responsible for the world around you.



I know it's not as amusing but may get the message across.


[edited once]

Essentially, The Church does quite well out of 'probably'.


If it wasn't for all those coffin-dodgers rushing into church during their twilight years 'just in case' there'd be even more tumbleweed rolling between the pews.


If churches are allowed to advertise their medieval nonsense wherever they please in public places and even encourage their hapless followers to try and press badly printed pamphlets into my hands first thing on a Saturday morning, then we ought to be allowed some sort of comeback.

Your comeback is not going to church/ mosque/ synagogue/ temple/ standing stones. Isn't that enough?


The buses will provide only sermon-fodder for a thousand ministers short of material after Christmas. Will they convert anyone to atheism, or relieve guilt in the doubters? Not really. And if not, what's the point? It's a lot of self-indulgent wank that will only confirm and encourage certain religious types in their belief that they are under attack, when the reality is that they are not.


In short, counterproductive.

*Bob* Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Atheist - No God

> Agnostic - Don't know.


No no... an Atheist *believes* there is no God, a religious person *believes* there is a god/gods/whatever. Neither has definiteive, undisputable evidence, so therefore it remains a belief.


It's nothing to do with altheism or "soft atheism", or even agnosticism. It's about being objective.


Throw belief and opinion out of the window. Approach the question from an open minded, scientific perspective - consider the facts - and arrive at a conclusion. The problem is that because Christians claim that God operates outside of the phyiscal universe (and is therefore exempt from laws of science), they have a theory which is impossible to disprove. Again, from an objective and scientific perspective, the best you can say is that their theory is very unlikely.


But I get the feeling that you and I are coming from a slightly different angle, *Bob*... we have to just agree to disagree on this one...

I guess by the book (the dictionary not that book) I'm an agnostic.


But it's not a cop out, it's more saying that if a higher power/intelligence/life form had a hand in the miracle and complexity of life (i find the universe less miraculous, maths seems to be getting to grips with that one, the rest is just physics and chemistry) then jolly well done, round of applause.


But were that to be the case, (rather than life being a natural facet of the entropic process of the aforementioned maths and physics and chemistry) then frankly we are but bacteria in the petri dish, and who are we to claim our visions or write up our myths and traditions as diktats from above.


So I'll live my life as best I can without the need for a Pascalian wager or to pick a particular religious poison thanks.

The Advertising Standards Authority actually had them include the word "PROBABLY".


I volunteer at the British Humanist Association. So to me, there is no god, and anyway, the ethos about it is "Let's concentrate on what we can do to help one another for the sake of humankind itself and NOT because of the carrot of heaven or the stick of hell".

Dawkins said he would have prefered "almost certainly no God", which accords more accurately with his teapot stance. "Probably" was indeed insisted upon by the ASA. But it still represents a sound philosophical basis for rationalists in so far as you remain open to the possibility that, if evidence of a deity is forthcoming, you will adapt your views accordingly.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Thank goodness for Greg. I had an awful situation whereby I was notified that water was leaking from my flat into the flat below me. I was 150 miles away at the time and had a panicked journey home not knowing what I was going to face.   I called Greg (after seeing reviews on the forum) as soon as I arrived home in the evening and he arrived just after 10pm and was able to shut off the problem. He had to come back to finalise the job which turned out to be caused in a communal area whereby there was a blockage in the stack pipe.   Greg worked quickly, efficiently and informed me every step of the way as to what he was doing and why. He also cleaned up really well afterwards.  Greg's charges are very reasonable and he will definitely be my "go-to" if I have any other plumbing issues in the future.    
    • Real Life was released in 1978. Yes it is a classic album.
    • Another recommendation for Nick. Copying below the review I have just left for him on Google: We don’t usually leave reviews for people online but are making an exception for Nick. He made fitted wardrobes for our loft conversion and did an absolutely fantastic job. The wardrobes are beautiful. Nick is passionate about producing a quality product, and also one that is bespoke to his clients’ needs. He guided us through the design to establish how we would actually use the space and built something that is fantastic. From start to finish the process was quick and each day he and his assistant Sean left the space tidy. I’m not sure we are easy people to please so the fact we are leaving a 5* review (indeed leaving a review at all) speaks volumes about what a great job Nick (and Sean) did. Nick also built a cupboard for our downstairs bathroom as part of the job and again it is brilliant. We would recommend them to anybody. 
    • Just had a flatpack IKEA wardrobe put together by the dynamic Father & Son team (Victor & Carl) and over the years they have come to the rescue with their quality workmanship and all round great people to work with. https://www.handymaneastdulwich.co.uk Thank you once again.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...