I'm not saying you haven't got any insight - I'm just saying banal cliches are not the way to convey it At the risk of further nit-picking, you say you " prefer though not to resort to semantics " when you are specifically picking apart the lyrics to a song is a bit rich. Either we are talking about what people really mean by their choice of words, or we aren't If you are helping kids through youth programmes and suchlike, good on you and more power to your elbow. But failing to understand that violence, murder and all-round-bad-attitude have been part of popular music since day 1 suggests you aren't on a strong footing. To then sound like Mary Whitehouse while you do it - surely not even you want to align yourself with the reactionary forces throughout the history of pop music? And it's not semantics to suggest that your quote "I think any kid that thinks there any merit in making music about killing and robbing people needs their head testing " does exactly that